A 3-D computational fluid dynamics model for forced air cooling of eggs placed in trays

Vikas Kumar, Ai Pheeng Wee, S.l. Birla, Jeyamkondan Subbiah, Harshavardhan ThippareddiJournal of Food Engineering 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a validated 3D computational fluid dynamics (CFD) model to predict the temperature of eggs during forced air cooling in trays. By integrating this model with a microbial growth model, it offers a more accurate assessment of Salmonella Enteritidis (SE) risk in shell eggs, addressing a critical need for improved food safety practices.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Salmonella Enteritidis (SE) infections, often foodborne, pose a significant public health concern, with eggs identified as a major vehicle for outbreaks. Rapid and effective cooling of shell eggs after laying is crucial to inhibit SE growth, as the organism thrives in warmer conditions, particularly in the yolk. Current food safety regulations and risk assessment models rely on simplified cooling rate estimations. However, the actual cooling process is complex, influenced by factors like air temperature and velocity, egg tray design, and the egg's location within the tray. Existing models often fail to capture these real-world complexities, leading to potential underestimations of SE risk. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a detailed CFD model that accurately simulates heat transfer during egg cooling in trays, enabling a more precise prediction of microbial growth.

Methods

The researchers developed a 3D computational fluid dynamics (CFD) model using the PHOENICS software. This model solves the continuity, momentum, and energy equations, incorporating a standard k-ɛ turbulence model to account for airflow dynamics.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Geometric Modeling: A simplified geometric model of an egg tray with five eggs in a single row was created, representing a typical industrial scenario. The egg shape was approximated as a spheroid.
  • Heat Transfer Modeling: The model simulates heat transfer within the egg (assumed as a composite solid) and convective heat transfer from the egg surface to the cooling air.
  • Turbulence Modeling: The k-ɛ turbulence model was chosen due to the high Reynolds numbers encountered in the confined spaces of the egg tray, ensuring accurate simulation of airflow.
  • Integration with Microbial Growth Model: The validated CFD model's temperature predictions were used as input for a dynamic SE growth model (based on Baranyi and Roberts, 1994, and a modified Ratkowsky equation). This integration allows for the estimation of SE growth during the cooling process.
  • Validation: The CFD model was rigorously validated against experimental data obtained from a wind tunnel under various cooling and heating scenarios (concurrent cooling, concurrent heating, and pre-chilled cooling).

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data collected from a wind tunnel setup. This data included:

  • Egg Yolk Temperatures: Measured using thermocouples inserted into eggs at various locations (upstream, midstream, downstream) within the tray.
  • Air Temperature and Velocity: Measured at the inlet of the test chamber using thermocouples and a hot-wire anemometer, respectively.

These experimental datasets were used to validate the CFD model's predictions across different cooling conditions and air velocities. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing experimental setups were used for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Location Matters: The position of an egg within the tray significantly impacts its cooling rate. Eggs at the upstream end cool faster than those at the downstream end due to the airflow pattern.
  • CFD for Realism: A 3D CFD model is essential for accurately capturing the complex heat transfer dynamics in an egg tray, which are influenced by airflow patterns and geometric arrangements. Simplified models are insufficient for precise risk assessment.
  • Microbial Risk Quantification: Integrating a heat transfer model with a microbial growth model provides a more tangible measure of food safety risk (SE growth) than temperature alone, making the results more actionable for food safety managers.
  • Model Reliability: The validated CFD model demonstrates good agreement with experimental data, with RMSE values for temperature prediction generally below 1°C, indicating its reliability for predicting egg cooling.

Key Results

  • Temperature Prediction Accuracy: The CFD model accurately predicted egg yolk temperatures across various scenarios. RMSE values for upstream, midstream, and downstream eggs were generally below 1°C. For example, in concurrent cooling at 0.6 m/s, RMSE values were 0.24°C (upstream), 0.36°C (midstream), and 0.28°C (downstream).
  • SE Growth Estimation: The integrated model estimated SE growth to be minimal (ranging from -0.05 to 0.21 log CFU/g) under pre-chilled cooling conditions, suggesting effective cooling in this scenario. Concurrent heating scenarios showed higher SE growth potential.
  • Cooling Time: In pre-chilled cooling scenarios, eggs could be cooled to safe temperatures within approximately 1-2 hours in the wind tunnel.
  • Model Validation: The model was validated for single trays and extended to multiple trays, showing consistent accuracy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Industrial vs. Lab Conditions: The study acknowledges that the rapid cooling observed in the wind tunnel may not directly translate to industrial chiller rooms, where natural convection and less direct airflow might lead to slower cooling rates.
  • Simplified Geometry: While the model represents a single row of eggs, industrial stacking involves multiple trays and complex airflow interactions that could be further investigated.
  • Composite Material Assumption: Treating eggs and trays as composite materials with uniform properties simplifies the model but might overlook finer thermal variations.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest developing a larger-scale CFD model that encompasses the entire chiller room to account for natural convection and more accurately represent industrial cooling conditions. Further investigation into the effect of tray materials and stacking arrangements on cooling rates is also recommended.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{kumar2011d,
  author = {Vikas Kumar and Ai Pheeng Wee and S.L. Birla and Jeyamkondan Subbiah and Harshavardhan Thippareddi},
  title = {{A 3-D computational fluid dynamics model for forced air cooling of eggs placed in trays}},
  journal = {Journal of Food Engineering},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jfoodeng.2011.08.003},
}
Figure