A 1.8 m Class Pathfinder Raman LIDAR for the Northern Site of the Cherenkov Telescope Array Observatory—Performance

Pedro José Bauzá-Ruiz, O. Blanch, P. Calisse, A. Campoy-Ordaz, S. M. Colak, M. Doro, L. Font, M. Gaug, R. Grau, Darko Kolar, C. Maggio, M. Martı́nez, S. Stanič, Santiago Ubach, Marko Zavrtanik, Miha ŽivecRemote 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces the Pathfinder Barcelona Raman LIDAR (pBRL), a prototype instrument designed to monitor atmospheric aerosols for the Cherenkov Telescope Array Observatory (CTAO). The pBRL demonstrates promising performance, achieving significant detection ranges and providing valuable aerosol profiles, even under challenging observational conditions, paving the way for its upgraded successor.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

High-energy gamma-ray astrophysics, as conducted by observatories like the Cherenkov Telescope Array (CTA), relies on precise atmospheric characterization. Atmospheric aerosols and clouds can significantly affect the Cherenkov light detected by these telescopes, introducing systematic uncertainties in energy and flux measurements. To mitigate this, CTAO requires continuous monitoring of atmospheric conditions, particularly aerosol extinction profiles and optical depth, across its line of sight. Existing LIDAR systems often lack the necessary capabilities, such as Raman channels for independent measurements or the required pointing flexibility. This paper addresses the need for a robust, multi-wavelength Raman LIDAR system capable of providing accurate atmospheric data for CTAO's calibration and science operations.

Methods

The paper details the performance of the pBRL, a prototype for the final Barcelona Raman LIDAR (BRL). Key methodological contributions include:

  • Power Budget Simulations: Extensive simulations were performed to assess the expected return power and signal-to-noise ratios under various atmospheric conditions (clear nights, moonlit nights, dust intrusions) and different operational scenarios.
  • LIDAR Pre-Processing (LPP) Software Suite: A novel, open-access software suite was developed for data processing. This suite incorporates several new statistical methods for:
  • Background Subtraction and Signal Gluing: Advanced techniques, including likelihood-based gluing and methods for correcting baseline ringing, were implemented to accurately combine signals from analog and photon-counting channels.
  • Layer Detection and Inversion: Algorithms for identifying and characterizing ground layers and clouds were developed, along with methods for retrieving extinction coefficients and LIDAR ratios.
  • Dynamic Rebinning: A dynamic algorithm was created to adjust bin widths, eliminating negative values and maintaining fine binning in regions with strong signals, ensuring data quality.
  • Range-Corrected Signal (RCS) Calculation: Methods for calculating RCS were refined, comparing different gluing algorithms and assessing their performance.

Datasets

The paper utilizes data from two primary test campaigns:

  • UAB Campus (Barcelona): Commissioning tests were conducted here, primarily under dark night conditions.
  • ORM (La Palma, CTAO-N site): Pathfinder campaign data was collected, notably under challenging conditions including moonlit nights, volcanic ash presence, and dust intrusions (calima).

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, real-world atmospheric data from these campaigns were used for performance validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Raman LIDAR's Value: The study strongly emphasizes the critical role of Raman channels in providing independent measurements of aerosol extinction and LIDAR ratios, which are essential for accurate atmospheric characterization and reducing systematic uncertainties for CTAO.
  • Software is Key: The development of the sophisticated LPP software suite, with its novel statistical methods for signal processing and data analysis, is highlighted as a crucial enabler for achieving the required performance.
  • Ringing Correction is Crucial: The presence of baseline ringing in photon-counting channels, especially under strong signal conditions, was identified as a significant issue. The paper demonstrates that effective correction of this ringing is vital for accurate data retrieval, particularly for Raman channels.
  • Hardware Limitations Impact Performance: The performance of the pBRL was significantly hampered by operational constraints, such as reduced laser power and PMT gain due to safety protocols and equipment protection. This underscores the importance of optimized hardware for meeting stringent requirements.
  • Non-Optimal Conditions Still Yield Valuable Data: Despite operating under non-ideal conditions (moonlit nights, reduced power), the pBRL was still able to provide valuable scientific results on aerosol characteristics and structure, demonstrating its potential.

Key Results

  • Maximum Range: The pBRL achieved maximum detection ranges of approximately 35 km in the elastic channels and 20 km in the Raman channel.
  • Range Resolution: A range resolution of about 50 m was achieved for strongly absorbing dust layers, and 500 m for optically thin clouds using the Raman channel. Similar resolutions were obtained for LIDAR ratios and Ångström exponents.
  • Aerosol Optical Depth (AOD) Accuracy: An accuracy of the order of 0.05 for aerosol optical depth retrieval was assumed, based on reasonable agreement between extinction coefficients from Raman and elastic lines.
  • Ångström Exponent Accuracy: Ångström exponents were successfully obtained with resolutions significantly better than the CTAO requirement of 0.3 RMSD.
  • Cloud Detection: The system demonstrated the ability to detect clouds and retrieve their properties, with VODs down to 0.01 being resolvable.
  • Time Efficiency: The system could achieve a minimum SNR of 10 within a minute for ranges up to 25 km under clear night conditions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Validation Under Non-Optimal Conditions: The pBRL's performance was primarily validated under moonlit nights and with reduced laser power and PMT gain, which limited the achievable performance and prevented full validation of all requirements.
  • Raman Channel Limitations: The 607 nm Raman channel was not used due to hardware limitations, and the 387 nm Raman channel's readout was not sufficiently calibrated or reliable for some analyses.
  • Hardware Improvements Needed: Several hardware upgrades are planned for the final BRL, including:
  • Gated PMTs for elastic channels to eliminate baseline ringing.
  • A reduced-power laser with a higher repetition rate to avoid data acquisition saturation.
  • Full implementation of near-range optics.
  • A higher PRF laser and PMTs with higher PDE for the final BRL.
  • Absolute Calibration: Achieving the stringent <3% RMSD accuracy for ground-layer VAODs will require continuous absolute LIDAR calibration.
  • Future Work: Further validation with dedicated simulations and real data sets on clouds, cross-calibrations with other instruments, and a detailed comparison with other systems are foreseen. The development of a more stable system and upgraded hardware is crucial for meeting all CTAO requirements.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Barcelona Raman LIDAR (BRL) will provide continuous monitoring of the aerosol extinction profile along the line of sight of the Cherenkov Telescope Array Observatory (CTAO). It will be located at its Northern site (CTAO-N) on the Observatorio del Roque de Los Muchachos. This article presents the performance of the pathfinder Barcelona Raman LIDAR (pBRL), a prototype instrument for the final BRL. Power budget simulations were carried out for the pBRL operating under various conditions, including clear nights, moon conditions, and dust intrusions. The LIDAR PreProcessing (LPP) software suite is presented, which includes several new statistical methods for background subtraction, signal gluing, ground layer and cloud detection and inversion, based on two elastic and one Raman lines. Preliminary test campaigns were conducted, first close to Barcelona and later at CTAO-N, albeit during moonlit nights only. The pBRL, under these non-optimal conditions, achieves maximum ranges up to about 35 km, range resolution of about 50 m for strongly absorbing dust layers, and 500 m for optically thin clouds with the Raman channel only, leading to similar resolutions for the LIDAR ratios and Ångström exponents. Given the reasonable agreement between the extinction coefficients obtained from the Raman and elastic lines independently, an accuracy of aerosol optical depth retrieval in the order of 0.05 can be assumed with the current setup. The results show that the pBRL can provide valuable scientific results on aerosol characteristics and structure, although not all performance requirements could be validated under the conditions found at the two test sites. Several moderate hardware improvements are planned for its final upgraded version, such as gated PMTs for the elastic channels and a reduced-power laser with a higher repetition rate, to ensure that the data acquisition system is not saturated and therefore not affected by residual ringing.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bauzaruiz2025m,
  author = {Pedro José Bauzá-Ruiz and O. Blanch and P. Calisse and A. Campoy-Ordaz and S. M. Colak and M. Doro and L. Font and M. Gaug and R. Grau and Darko Kolar and C. Maggio and M. Martı́nez and S. Stanič and Santiago Ubach and Marko Zavrtanik and Miha Živec},
  title = {{A 1.8 m Class Pathfinder Raman LIDAR for the Northern Site of the Cherenkov Telescope Array Observatory—Performance}},
  booktitle = {Remote},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/rs17111815},
}
Figure