791 Incidence, costs and outcomes of non-union, delayed union and mal-union following long bone fracture

Christina L. Ekegren, Belinda J. Gabbe, Elton Edwards, Richard de Steiger, Richard S. Page2016 · DOI

Introduction

The successful management of long bone fractures—specifically those of the humerus, tibia, and femur—is a cornerstone of orthopedic trauma care. The primary clinical objective is "union," the biological process where the bone successfully knits back together. However, this process is not always seamless. Healing complications are generally categorized into three types:

  • Non-union: A complete failure of the bone to heal.
  • Delayed union: Healing that takes significantly longer than the standard clinical timeframe.
  • Mal-union: Healing that occurs in an unsatisfactory anatomical position or alignment.

While these complications are well-recognized by clinicians, previous research has often been limited by small sample sizes or a focus on specific fracture types. There has been a notable lack of comprehensive data regarding the aggregate economic burden on healthcare systems and the long-term functional impact on patients. This study sought to quantify the incidence, inpatient costs, and 12-month outcomes of readmissions for these healing complications.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective cohort study using data linkage between the Victorian Orthopaedic Trauma Outcomes Registry (VOTOR) and hospital administrative datasets in Victoria, Australia. The study analyzed 3,908 patients who sustained humeral, tibial, or femoral fractures over a five-year period.

Patients were tracked for two years post-injury to identify readmissions specifically related to non-union, delayed union, or mal-union. The study evaluated several key outcomes:

  • Economic: Hospital length of stay (LOS) and inpatient costs.
  • Functional: The Extended Glasgow Outcome Scale (GOS-E) at 12 months.
  • Quality of Life: The EQ-5D health-related quality of life scale at 12 months.
  • Vocational: Return-to-work status at 12 months.

Multivariable modeling was employed to adjust for confounders and identify independent risk factors for developing these complications.

Results

Incidence and Risk Factors

Of the 3,908 patients studied, 9% were readmitted for healing complications within two years of their initial fracture. Among these complications, non-union was the most prevalent, accounting for 77% of cases. This indicates that the total failure of the healing process is a far more frequent cause for readmission than misalignment.

The analysis identified several significant risk factors. Patients had higher odds of experiencing healing complications if they:

  • Were of older age.
  • Had sustained multiple fractures (polytrauma).
  • Were covered by a compensation scheme (e.g., transport accident or workers' compensation).

Economic Burden

The financial impact of healing complications is substantial. On average, a complication readmission added three days to a patient's total hospital stay. The costs associated with these readmissions reached up to AUD $25,000 per patient. Across the entire study cohort, the aggregate cost of managing these complications was AUD $5.4 million.

Patient Outcomes at 12 Months

The study highlights that the impact of a healing complication extends well beyond the clinical resolution of the fracture. At the 12-month post-injury mark, patients who suffered complications reported significantly worse outcomes across all measured metrics compared to those who healed normally:

  • Function: Lower scores on the GOS-E, indicating persistent physical limitations.
  • Quality of Life: Lower EQ-5D scores, reflecting a diminished state of overall well-being.
  • Employment: Significantly lower rates of returning to work, suggesting a profound socioeconomic impact on the individual.

Discussion and Conclusion

This study demonstrates that healing complications following long bone fractures are not merely clinical hurdles but represent a major public health and economic burden. The high prevalence of non-union suggests a need for better biological or mechanical interventions during the initial phase of treatment.

The correlation between compensation status and complications is a complex finding often seen in trauma literature; it may serve as a proxy for injury severity or reflect different psychosocial stressors and care pathways. Regardless of the underlying cause, these patients represent a high-risk group that may require more intensive monitoring.

The significant reduction in quality of life and return-to-work rates at one year underscores the necessity of viewing fracture recovery through a long-term lens. The authors conclude that future research must prioritize the prevention of these complications and the development of targeted rehabilitation strategies to improve the functional trajectory of high-risk patients.

Limitations

The study's reliance on hospital readmission data likely underestimates the true incidence of healing complications, as it may miss patients treated exclusively in outpatient settings or those with minor delays that did not require re-hospitalization. Additionally, the findings are specific to the Australian healthcare and compensation context, which may limit generalizability to systems with different funding and care models.

Summary updated

Abstract

<h3>Background</h3> The management of long bone fractures is complex and the risk of healing complications persists. Previous studies have reported widely varying incidence and cost estimates for fracture healing complications, with the majority focusing on small cohorts with specific fracture types and treatment methods. Also, there is a lack of research on patient outcomes. The aim of this study was to describe the incidence, inpatient costs and 12-month outcomes of readmissions for healing complications following long bone fracture. <h3>Methods</h3> All humeral, tibial and femoral fractures registered by the Victorian Orthopaedic Trauma Outcomes Registry over a 5-year period were linked with hospital data to identify 2-year readmissions for non-union, delayed union or mal-union. Study outcomes for patients with complication readmissions included hospital length of stay, inpatient costs, function (Extended Glasgow Outcome Scale), work status and quality of life (EQ-5D) measured 12 months post-injury. Cases with and without complications were compared using univariable and multivariable methods. <h3>Results</h3> Of the 3908 patients included, 9% were readmitted for healing complications within 2 years of their index fracture. The most common complication type was non-union (77% of complications). Admissions for fracture healing complications incurred an extra 3 days in hospital and costs of up to AUD $25,000 per patient (AUD $5.4 M in total). Patients with healing complications reported worse function, quality of life and return to work rates 12 months post-injury. After adjusting for key confounders, patients had higher odds of developing complications if they were older, receiving compensation or had multiple fractures. <h3>Conclusions</h3> Patients who develop complications have poorer outcomes and place additional burden on healthcare and compensation systems. As such, there is a need to prioritise future research aimed at preventing fracture healing complications and improving patient outcomes.
BibTeX
@misc{ekegren2016incidence,
  author = {Christina L. Ekegren and Belinda J. Gabbe and Elton Edwards and Richard de Steiger and Richard S. Page},
  title = {{791 Incidence, costs and outcomes of non-union, delayed union and mal-union following long bone fracture}},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1136/injuryprev-2016-042156.791},
}
Figure