619 Pain Management in Burn and Wound Patients: Effects of Acupuncture in Pain Score and Medication

Erika Tay Lasso, Anjali Herekar, Clara Riggle, Sheng Li, Hui Jer Hwang, Mariko Horie, Kenneth S Phelps, Kimberly Burton, Leonardo Alaniz, Gabrielle Hovis, Kim Hecht, Molly E Nunez, Victor Joe, Theresa L. ChinJournal of Burn Care & Research 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated acupuncture's effectiveness in managing pain for burn and wound patients, a population often reliant on opioids. The findings suggest acupuncture significantly reduces pain scores and non-opioid medication use, offering a promising complementary approach to traditional pain management in this challenging patient group.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Managing pain in burn and wound patients is a significant clinical challenge. Historically, opioid and non-opioid medications have been the primary tools, but the ongoing opioid epidemic necessitates exploring multidisciplinary, holistic approaches. Acupuncture, known for its efficacy in other chronic pain and anxiety conditions, is proposed as a potential adjunct therapy to reduce reliance on conventional pain medications and improve patient outcomes.

Methods

This research employed a prospective observational study design, enrolling patients admitted to a burn service. The study excluded patients unable to provide consent or those younger than six years old. Key data collected included:

  • Pain Scores: A numeric pain scale (1-10) was administered before and after each acupuncture session. For patients who slept through the post-session assessment, the score was taken upon waking.
  • Medication Use: Daily records of opioid and non-opioid medications were kept. Opioid dosages were converted to daily morphine equivalents (MME) for standardized comparison.
  • Comparison: Data was compared between "acupuncture days" (ACd) and "non-acupuncture days" (n-ACd).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study collected data prospectively from patients within the burn service at the University of California Irvine Medical Center.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Acupuncture as a Pain Modulator: The study strongly suggests that acupuncture can effectively reduce pain intensity in burn and wound patients, as evidenced by significant drops in reported pain scores.
  • Reducing Non-Opioid Reliance: While opioid use showed no significant difference, acupuncture was associated with a notable decrease in acetaminophen use. This highlights its potential to help patients step down from certain non-opioid analgesics.
  • Holistic Pain Management: The findings support the integration of acupuncture into a broader pain management strategy, moving beyond solely pharmacological interventions, especially in light of the opioid crisis.
  • Patient Experience: A notable observation was that a significant portion of patients (26%) fell asleep after acupuncture, hinting at its potential relaxing and restorative effects beyond direct pain relief.

Key Results

  • Pain Score Reduction: The median pain score dropped from 5 (IQR: 2.6-6.4) before acupuncture to 1.5 (IQR: 0.2-2.8) after treatment, representing a significant improvement.
  • Medication Use:
    • Median morphine use on ACd was 26.6 MME (15.8-62.1) vs. n-ACd 27.35 MME (15.5-65.3) – no significant difference.
  • Median acetaminophen use on ACd was 1007.5mg (313.39 -1950) vs. n-ACd 1381.25mg (642.5-2535) – a significant reduction.
  • After adjusting for TBSA and chronic opioid use, patients received an average of 391 MME less per day on ACd (p=0.334) and 395.12mg less acetaminophen per day on ACd (p=0.005).
  • Overall Pain Reduction: Acupuncture was associated with a significant lower pain score, with a mean reduction of 2.799 points.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study was observational, meaning it cannot establish causality definitively.
  • The lack of a control group (e.g., sham acupuncture or no acupuncture) makes it harder to isolate the specific effects of acupuncture from placebo or natural healing.
  • The significant difference was observed in non-opioid (acetaminophen) use, not opioid use, suggesting that while helpful, it may not be a direct substitute for strong analgesics in all cases.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that additional education on a tiered approach to pain medication is essential to reduce unnecessary opioid use. Further research with controlled designs could explore the optimal integration of acupuncture into burn care protocols and its long-term impact on pain management and opioid reduction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Introduction Pain management in burn patients is a complex ongoing problem. Opioid and non-opioid medications have historically been used as the primary pain management modality in burn care. Considering the ongoing opioid epidemic, a multidisciplinary holistic approach is needed for pain management. Acupuncture has been recognized to help in different settings such as chronic back pain, neurological problems, depression, and anxiety. We hypothesize that burn and wound patients receiving acupuncture will have a decrease in opioids and non-opioid medications on acupuncture day (ACd) compared to non-acupuncture day (n-ACd) and a reduction of pain scores before and after acupuncture. Methods A prospective observational study in all patients admitted to the burn service was made. We exclude patients that were unable to provide consent or age 6 years and younger. A numeric pain score (1-10) was collected from the patients before and after each acupuncture session; if patients were sleeping after acupuncture pain score was collected when they woke up. A prospective collection of daily opioids and non-opioids medications was made. Opioids were converted to daily morphine equivalents (MME). Results From February to August 2021, 53 patients on the burn service were treated with acupuncture for a total of 185 sessions. The median age was 49 years (IQR:32.5-63.0). Median TBSA for burn patients was 3.3% (IQR:1.5-8.1). The number of sessions per patient ranged from 1-12 with a median of 3 (IQR1.7-4). Before acupuncture, the median pain score was 5 (IQR:2.6-6.4), and after treatment was it was 1.5 (IQR:0.2-2.8). Of 185 sessions, 49 (26%) of those sessions, patients fell asleep afterward. Median morphine use on ACd was 26.6 MME (15.8-62.1) vs. n-ACd 27.35 MME (15.5-65.3). For non-opioid medication, the median of acetaminophen on ACd 1007.5mg (313.39 -1950) vs. n-ACd 1381.25mg (642.5-2535). After adjusting for TBSA and chronic opioid use, patients were given a daily mean of 391 MME CI: (1201.12-419.12 p=0.334) less in ACd vs. n-ACd. In addition, acetaminophen had a daily mean of 395.12mg CI: (130.05, 660.19 p=0.005) less in ACd vs. n-ACd. Overall, acupuncture was associated with a significant lower pain score with a mean of 2.799 points less. Conclusions Acupuncture seems to abrogate pain in burn and wound patients, as demonstrated by doses of pain medication. While there was no significant difference in opioid medications, there was a significant difference in acetaminophen, indicating that additional education of a tiered approach to pain medications is essential to reduce unnecessary opioid use.
BibTeX
@article{lasso2022pain,
  author = {Erika Tay Lasso and Anjali Herekar and Clara Riggle and Sheng Li and Hui Jer Hwang and Mariko Horie and Kenneth S Phelps and Kimberly Burton and Leonardo Alaniz and Gabrielle Hovis and Kim Hecht and Molly E Nunez and Victor Joe and Theresa L. Chin},
  title = {{619 Pain Management in Burn and Wound Patients: Effects of Acupuncture in Pain Score and Medication}},
  journal = {Journal of Burn Care \& Research},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1093/jbcr/irac012.247},
}
Figure