4 Episodic Memory Deficits and Fronto-Limbic Correlates in Older Adults Living with HIV: Comparison to Parkinson’s Disease and Normal Aging

Rosemary Fama, Eva M. Müller‐Oehring, Taylor F. Levine, Edith V. Sulivan, Priya Asok, Stephanie A. Sassoon, Helen Brontë‐Stewart, Kathleen L. Poston, Kilian M. Pohl, Adolf Pfefferbaum, Tilman SchulteJournal of the International Neuropsychological Society 2023 · DOI

This research summary explores a comparative study on cognitive decline in aging populations, specifically looking at how HIV and Parkinson’s Disease (PD) affect the brain's memory architecture.

TL;DR

While older adults living with HIV and those with Parkinson’s Disease exhibit nearly identical deficits in verbal episodic memory, the underlying structural causes differ. MRI data reveals that memory impairment in HIV is linked to orbitofrontal volume, whereas in Parkinson’s, it correlates with hippocampal volume, suggesting distinct pathological pathways to similar cognitive symptoms.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Thanks to antiretroviral therapy (ART), people living with HIV (PLWH) are reaching near-normal life expectancies. However, this success has revealed a new challenge: a high prevalence of mild-to-moderate cognitive impairment. Researchers are concerned about a "synergistic" effect between chronic HIV infection and the natural aging process.

Specifically, both HIV and Parkinson’s Disease (PD) are known to degrade the fronto-limbic circuits—the neural "highways" connecting the front of the brain (responsible for executive function) to the deeper limbic system (responsible for emotion and memory). This study investigates whether the memory deficits seen in aging PLWH are functionally and structurally the same as those seen in PD, or if they represent a unique neurobiological profile.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study comparing three groups:

  1. PLWH: 42 participants.
  2. Parkinson’s Disease (PD): 41 participants.
  3. Controls (CTRL): 37 healthy individuals.

All participants were between 45 and 79 years old. To assess memory, the team used the California Verbal Learning Test-2 (CVLT-2), which measures how well a person can learn, retain, and recall a list of words.

To look at the brain's structure, they used 3T MRI imaging and the SRI24 atlas to measure the volume of specific regions, including the hippocampus, thalamus, and various segments of the frontal lobe. They corrected these volumes for age and head size using a large reference dataset of 238 healthy controls to ensure the results weren't just a byproduct of natural aging or physical stature.

Datasets

  • Primary Study Group: 120 participants (HIV, PD, and age-matched controls).
  • Normative Reference Dataset: 238 healthy controls (ages 19–86) used to establish baseline "normal" brain volumes for Z-score calculations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Behavioral Convergence: On the surface, HIV and PD look remarkably similar. Both groups struggled significantly more than the control group with learning new words and recalling them later. Interestingly, there was no statistically significant difference between the HIV and PD groups' scores on any memory index.
  • Structural Divergence: Despite the similar symptoms, the "damage" was located in different places. The HIV group showed significantly smaller volumes in the middle frontal gyrus and the thalamus compared to the PD and control groups.
  • The "Where" Matters for Memory: The most striking finding was the correlation between brain volume and memory performance:
  • In PLWH, memory scores were tied to the orbitofrontal volume. This suggests that memory issues in HIV may be driven more by "top-down" executive or encoding deficits.
  • In PD, memory scores (specifically retention) were tied to hippocampal volume, the classic "hub" for long-term memory storage.

Key Results

  • Memory Impairment: Both HIV and PD groups were impaired in learning across trials and in short-delay/long-delay free and cued recall compared to controls.
  • Brain Volume Reductions: The HIV group had smaller middle frontal volumes than both PD and CTRL groups. They also had smaller thalamic volumes than the PD group.
  • Correlation Specificity: Correlational analyses (using a strict Bonferroni correction, $p < .01$) showed that lower word recall in the HIV group was associated with smaller orbitofrontal volume. In contrast, lower retention in the PD group was associated with smaller hippocampal volume.
  • Cueing Benefit: All three groups (HIV, PD, and CTRL) benefited similarly when given cues, suggesting that the ability to utilize external "hints" remains somewhat intact across these conditions.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this is a cross-sectional study, meaning it captures a single point in time. It cannot definitively say how these brain changes progress over years.

Future research should focus on longitudinal tracking to see if the orbitofrontal deficits in PLWH eventually spread to the hippocampus, or if they remain distinct "nodes" of failure within the fronto-limbic circuitry. Additionally, exploring how different ART regimens or the duration of HIV infection impact these specific brain volumes could help refine clinical treatments for the aging HIV population.

Summary updated

Abstract

Objective: The prevalence of mild to moderate cognitive impairment, including episodic memory deficits, in people living with HIV (PLWH) remains high despite the life-extending success of antiretroviral pharmacotherapy. With PLWH now reaching near-normal life expectancy, questions concerning a potential synergy between age- and HIV disease-related effects, including degradation in fronto-limbic circuits, neural systems also compromised in Parkinson’s disease (PD), have emerged. Participants and Methods: This cross-sectional study examined the similarities and differences in component processes of verbal episodic memory and their neural correlates in 42 PLWH, 41 individuals with PD, and 37 controls (CTRL) (all participants aged 45-79 years). Learning over five trials, short-delay (SD) and long-delay, (LD), free-recall (FR) and cued-recall (CR) indices were assessed using the California Verbal Learning Test-2. Retention scores for FR and CR were derived adjusting for Trial 5 performance. All memory scores were age- and education-corrected based on the control group and reported as Z-scores. Regional brain volumes were calculated using 3T MRI data and the SRI24 atlas to delineate frontal (precentral, superior, orbital, middle, inferior, supplemental motor, and medial) and limbic (hippocampus, thalamus) regions. Brain volumes were age- and head-sized corrected based on 238 controls (19-86 years old). Results: Compared with the CTRL group, the HIV and PD groups were impaired on learning across trials and on SD and LD free- and cued-recall, with no group difference between the HIV and PD groups on any score. All three groups benefited similarly from cues compared with free-recall. The HIV and PD groups did not differ from CTRL on retention scores. Regarding brain volumes, the HIV group had smaller middle frontal volumes than the PD or CTRL groups and smaller thalamic volumes than the PD group. Correlational analyses (Bonferroni correction for 8 comparisons, p&lt;.01) indicated that fewer total number of words recalled on Trial 5, learning over Trials 1-5, total words recalled on SD-CR, LD-FR, and LD-CR were associated with smaller orbitofrontal volume in the HIV but not the PD group; the correlations between orbitofrontal volume and memory scores were significantly different between the HIV and PD groups. In PD, but not HIV, lower retention scores on SD-FR and LD-CR correlated to smaller hippocampal volume. Conclusions: Impairment in learning and cued recall performance indicate that both encoding and retrieval processes are affected in PLWH and PD. Neural correlates of verbal memory differed between groups, with orbitofrontal volume associated with learning and recall in PLWH, whereas hippocampal volume was associated with retention scores in PD. Together, these results suggest that different nodes within the fronto-limbic mnemonic circuitry underlie the mutual verbal episodic memory deficits observed in older PLWH and PD. Support: AA023165, AA005965, AA107347, AA010723, NS07097, MH113406, and the Michael J. Fox Foundation for Parkinson’s Research
BibTeX
@article{fama2023episodic,
  author = {Rosemary Fama and Eva M. Müller‐Oehring and Taylor F. Levine and Edith V. Sulivan and Priya Asok and Stephanie A. Sassoon and Helen Brontë‐Stewart and Kathleen L. Poston and Kilian M. Pohl and Adolf Pfefferbaum and Tilman Schulte},
  title = {{4 Episodic Memory Deficits and Fronto-Limbic Correlates in Older Adults Living with HIV: Comparison to Parkinson’s Disease and Normal Aging}},
  journal = {Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1017/s1355617723008512},
}
Figure