TL;DR
This study leverages a novel combination of airborne and spaceborne Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) data to create a high-resolution 3D surface velocity field for the tectonically active Cerro Prieto basin. This detailed mapping is crucial for understanding the complex interplay of geothermal energy extraction and natural tectonic processes driving ground deformation in the region.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Accurately mapping and understanding ground deformation is vital for managing risks associated with natural hazards and human activities like geothermal energy extraction. While Interferometric SAR (InSAR) is excellent at measuring deformation along the satellite's line-of-sight (LOS), deriving a full 3D displacement vector (up, north, east) is challenging. This is because SAR satellite orbits and viewing angles are not ideal for capturing all components of motion equally, particularly the north-south component, which often has the highest error. Previous studies in the Cerro Prieto basin, a region with significant geothermal activity and tectonic strain, were limited to 1D or 2D deformation estimates, often neglecting the north component or relying on sparse ground-based measurements. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by integrating multiple SAR datasets with different geometries to achieve a comprehensive 3D surface velocity field.
Methods
The core of this research lies in a sophisticated InSAR processing and inversion technique. The authors employed a Small Baseline Subset (SBAS) approach to generate LOS displacement maps from multiple SAR images. This method is robust against temporal and spatial decorrelation, allowing for the retrieval of slow deformation rates.
The key innovation is the 3D displacement vector decomposition using a weighted least-squares inversion algorithm. This algorithm combines LOS displacement measurements from SAR sensors with different geometries (ascending, descending, east, and west passes). By accounting for the unique incidence angle and heading of each sensor, the inversion can disentangle the contributions of vertical, north, and east motion. This approach is applied pixel-by-pixel to generate the 3D velocity field. The methodology was rigorously validated using synthetic deformation data generated from a known anthropogenic deformation model.
Datasets
The study utilized a combination of SAR datasets:
- Sentinel-1A: Spaceborne C-band SAR imagery from ascending and descending orbits.
- UAVSAR: Airborne L-band SAR imagery from east and west flight segments.
- RADARSAT-2: Spaceborne C-band SAR imagery from ascending and descending orbits.
These datasets were collected between 2012 and 2016. The derived 3D surface velocity field was validated against:
- Precise leveling data: Collected by the Mexican Institute of Water Technology (IMTA) between 2012 and 2015.
- Continuous GPS (cGPS) data: From stations within the Cerro Prieto basin, part of the Northwestern Mexico Geodetic Network (REGNOM).
Key Insights and Ideas
- The North Component Matters: This study strongly emphasizes that neglecting the north-south displacement component in 3D deformation analysis can lead to significant over- or underestimations of vertical and eastward motion, especially when the north component itself has large magnitudes.
- Synergy of SAR Geometries: Combining SAR data from different viewing angles (ascending, descending, east, west) is crucial for accurately resolving all three components of surface displacement. Semi-orthogonal geometries provide the necessary constraints.
- Geothermal Activity and Subsidence: The detailed 3D velocity field reveals that subsidence in the Cerro Prieto basin is primarily driven by geothermal fluid extraction, with horizontal displacements showing a convergence pattern towards the center of the subsidence bowl.
- Tectonic Boundaries: The study confirms that the Imperial and Cerro Prieto faults act as significant boundaries for the observed deformation, highlighting the interplay between tectonic structures and anthropogenic influences.
Key Results
- The study successfully generated a 3D surface velocity field (3DSVF) for the Cerro Prieto Step-Over.
- The vertical displacement rate reached up to approximately 150 mm/yr in the recharge zone and 135 mm/yr in the exploitation zone.
- Horizontal displacement rates were up to 40 mm/yr, showing convergence towards the basin's center.
- Validation against precise leveling data showed a total RMSE of 0.96 cm/yr and a correlation coefficient of 0.91, indicating good agreement.
- Comparison with cGPS data showed a total RMSE < 8 mm/yr for the 3D displacement rates, demonstrating robust agreement between InSAR and geodetic techniques.
- A deceleration in subsidence rate was observed in the recharge zone during the 2015–2016 period compared to 2012–2014, suggesting a potential slowdown in fluid extraction or changes in reinjection strategies.
Limitations and Future Work
- UAVSAR Data Limitations: The study acknowledges that errors in UAVSAR datasets, particularly the north displacement component, can influence results. This was partly addressed by masking pixels with low temporal coherence. The larger radar wavelength of UAVSAR also reduces sensitivity to displacements.
- Geothermal Production Data: Direct correlation of subsidence rates with specific geothermal energy production data (e.g., steam extraction, water reinjection volumes) was limited due to the inaccessibility of detailed operational data. The study relied on publicly available information like the number of wells.
- Reference Point Sensitivity: The choice of the InSAR reference point can influence the absolute displacement rates, and variability was noted between different studies and datasets, potentially due to different reference points or 2D vs. 3D approaches.
Future work could focus on integrating more extensive and continuous GPS data, exploring higher-resolution SAR data (e.g., Sentinel-1 with shorter revisit times), and potentially incorporating other geophysical datasets to further refine the understanding of the complex interactions within the Cerro Prieto basin. The authors also suggest that this detailed 3D deformation mapping is crucial for seismic hazard assessments in the region.
Summary updated