3D Printing of Biomass–Fungi Composite Material: Effects of Mixture Composition on Print Quality

Abhinav Bhardwaj, Al Mazedur Rahman, Xingjian Wei, Zhijian Pei, David Truong, Matt Lucht, Na ZouJournal of Manufacturing and Materials Processing 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how the amount of psyllium husk powder in a biomass-fungi composite mixture affects its 3D printability and the quality of the printed object. The researchers found that a specific ratio of psyllium husk to water is crucial for achieving good extrudability and shape stability, offering a pathway to more sustainable 3D printed materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The construction and packaging industries face significant environmental challenges, including high CO2 emissions from cement production and massive plastic waste. Biomass-fungi composites offer a sustainable alternative, utilizing agricultural waste as a substrate for fungal growth (mycelium) to create low-cost, biodegradable materials. While 3D printing holds promise for fabricating complex shapes with these materials, optimizing the mixture composition for successful printing remains a challenge. This paper specifically addresses the gap in understanding how varying the amount of psyllium husk powder, a natural gelling agent, influences the print quality of these biomass-fungi composites.

Methods

The researchers prepared four different biomass-fungi mixtures, varying the amount of psyllium husk powder added to a base mixture of biomass-fungi material and wheat flour. The key variable was the ratio of psyllium husk powder (wp) to water (vw), with ratios of 0, 1:40, 2:40, and 3:40 being tested. These mixtures were then subjected to a material extrusion 3D printing process using a Delta WASP 2040 printer.

Print quality was assessed using two primary metrics:

  • Extrudability: This evaluated whether the material could be extruded through the printer nozzle without tearing and if the resulting filament had consistent dimensions.
  • Shape Stability: This measured the ability of the deposited layers to maintain their shape and resist deformation under the weight of subsequent layers.

To understand the underlying reasons for the observed print quality, the rheological properties of each mixture were characterized using a TA Instruments DHR-2 rheometer. This involved measuring viscosity, shear elastic modulus (G'), shear loss modulus (G"), and the loss tangent (tan(δ)) across a range of shear rates and frequencies.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized self-prepared mixtures and experimental printing.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Psyllium Husk is Crucial, but Too Much is Bad: The study highlights that psyllium husk powder is essential for making the biomass-fungi mixture printable. However, there's an optimal range; too little makes it unprintable, and too much can negatively impact extrudability. This suggests a delicate balance is needed for successful 3D printing.
  • Rheology as a Predictor of Printability: The paper effectively links the rheological properties (viscosity, loss tangent) of the mixtures to their print quality. This provides a scientific basis for understanding why certain compositions print better than others, moving beyond empirical observation.
  • Shear Thinning Behavior is Key: All printable mixtures exhibited shear-thinning behavior, meaning their viscosity decreases under shear. This is a common and desirable characteristic for 3D printing pastes, allowing them to flow easily through the nozzle but regain some viscosity to hold their shape.
  • Loss Tangent as an Indicator of Solid-like vs. Liquid-like Behavior: The loss tangent (tan(δ)) was a particularly insightful metric. Values below 1 indicate solid-like properties, while values above 1 suggest liquid-like behavior. The study showed how increasing psyllium husk powder content shifted the mixture's behavior, influencing its printability and shape stability.

Key Results

  • Mixture A (0 psyllium husk): Not extrudable. Only water was deposited, leaving a dry puck of material.
  • Mixture B (1:40 wp/vw): Exhibited good extrudability with no tearing and good dimensional consistency (average width variation of 1.87%). However, its shape stability was poorer, with an 11% reduction in layer height after deposition of the second layer.
  • Mixture C (2:40 wp/vw): Showed the best overall print quality, with good extrudability and significantly improved shape stability (only a 5% reduction in layer height). This mixture met the criteria for both extrudability and shape stability.
  • Mixture D (3:40 wp/vw): While technically extrudable, it did not show good extrudability, with printed filaments being discontinuous. This was linked to an increase in solid-like behavior as indicated by the loss tangent.
  • Rheological Trends: Increasing psyllium husk content generally reduced viscosity and elastic modulus for mixtures A, B, and C. Mixture D showed a similar loss modulus to C but a higher tan(δ) value, indicating a shift towards more solid-like behavior compared to B and C.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * The study focused on a limited range of psyllium husk concentrations. * The paper acknowledges that Mixture D, while extrudable, had discontinuous filaments, suggesting its extrudability was not optimal. * The study did not investigate the long-term effects of time on mixture preparation and printability.

Future Work: * SEM characterization of the biomass-fungi mixtures and printed samples to understand microstructural changes. * Investigating the effects of elapsed time after mixture preparation on rheology and printability. * Exploring other additives or processing parameters to further optimize print quality.

Summary updated

Abstract

It is known that 3D printing can facilitate greater design flexibility in the printing of custom shapes for packaging and construction applications using biomass–fungi composite materials. The feasibility of this new method was demonstrated by a preliminary experiment, the results of which were reported in a journal publication in 2020. As a follow-up, this paper reports on an experimental study on the relationship between the mixture composition (i.e., the psyllium husk powder content) and print quality using this new method. Four mixtures were prepared by varying the amounts of psyllium husk powder (in grams) added to 400 mL of water. The ratios (g/mL) of psyllium husk powder weight (wp) over volume of water (vw) for the mixtures were 0, 1:40, 2:40, and 3:40. Each mixture also contained 100 g of biomass–fungi material and 40 g of whole wheat flour. The print quality of the samples was evaluated based on the extrudability and shape stability. The results showed that mixtures without any psyllium husk powder were not extrudable. An increase in the ratio of psyllium husk powder to water from 1:40 to 2:40 resulted in improved print quality; however, when the psyllium husk powder to water ratio was increased to 3:40, the extrudability became worse. This phenomenon was explained by analyzing the rheological properties of the mixtures.
BibTeX
@article{bhardwaj2021d,
  author = {Abhinav Bhardwaj and Al Mazedur Rahman and Xingjian Wei and Zhijian Pei and David Truong and Matt Lucht and Na Zou},
  title = {{3D Printing of Biomass–Fungi Composite Material: Effects of Mixture Composition on Print Quality}},
  journal = {Journal of Manufacturing and Materials Processing},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/jmmp5040112},
}
Figure