3D Muscle Volume and 3D Fat Fraction After Successful and Failed Arthroscopic Rotator Cuff Repair at 5-Year Follow-up

Philipp Kriechling, Jethin Joshy, Stefan Klotz, Georg C. Feuerriegel, Philipp Fürnstahl, Reto Sutter, Mazda Farshad, Karl WieserThe American Journal of Sports Medicine 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses advanced 3D MRI techniques to quantitatively assess muscle changes in the supraspinatus after rotator cuff repair. It reveals that successful repairs lead to significant muscle volume increase and stable fat infiltration over 5 years, while failed repairs show only modest muscle gains and worsening fat infiltration, highlighting the long-term impact of repair success on muscle health.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rotator cuff (RC) tears are common, and while surgical repair aims to restore function, success rates can be limited by factors like muscle atrophy and fatty infiltration. Previous research often relied on qualitative, 2D assessments of these degenerative changes, which are less precise. This study addresses the need for more accurate, quantitative, and 3D analysis of muscle volume and fat infiltration over a long-term follow-up (5 years) to understand how these factors differ between successful and failed RC repairs. The authors hypothesize that successful repairs will lead to better muscle recovery and less fatty infiltration compared to failed repairs.

Methods

The researchers employed quantitative 3D magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) using a chemical-shift-based technique (2-point or 6-point Dixon sequences). This method allows for the precise quantification of both muscle volume and intramuscular fat content. They performed segmentation of the complete supraspinatus muscle from the MRI data to obtain 3D measurements. Clinical outcomes were assessed using the Constant-Murley score (CS) and subjective shoulder value (SSV). Statistical analysis involved Mann-Whitney U tests and Wilcoxon signed rank tests for group comparisons, with post hoc power analysis to assess the study's statistical power. Interrater reliability for the segmentation and analysis was also calculated using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC).

Datasets

The study utilized data from a prospectively enrolled cohort of 115 patients who underwent arthroscopic RC repair for full-thickness supraspinatus tears. For the 5-year follow-up analysis, 18 patients with failed repairs were matched to 21 patients with successful repairs. The data collected included preoperative, 3-month, 12-month, and a minimum 60-month (5-year) follow-up MRI scans, as well as clinical examination data at these time points. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • 3D is Crucial: The study strongly suggests that 2D assessments of muscle volume and fat infiltration are insufficient, and 3D analysis provides a more accurate picture of these degenerative changes.
  • Long-Term Muscle Recovery: Successful RC repair not only halts but actively reverses muscle atrophy, leading to significant gains in supraspinatus muscle volume over a 5-year period.
  • Fat Infiltration as a Key Differentiator: While successful repairs maintain a stable level of fatty infiltration, failed repairs show a concerning increase in fat content over time, indicating ongoing muscle degeneration.
  • Failed Repairs Aren't Static: Even in failed repairs, there's a modest improvement in muscle volume from the 3-month to the 5-year mark, though this is significantly less than in successful repairs and is accompanied by worsening fatty infiltration.
  • Clinical Outcomes Don't Fully Reflect Muscle Health: Interestingly, the clinical outcomes (Constant-Murley score, SSV) were similar between successful and failed repair groups at the 5-year follow-up, suggesting that subjective and functional measures might not fully capture the underlying structural changes in the muscle.

Key Results

  • Muscle Volume: Successful repairs showed a mean volume increase of 18% at 3 months and 23% at 5 years postoperatively. Failed repairs showed a smaller increase of 3% at 3 months and 12% at 5 years. Despite these differences in change, the absolute volumes at 5 years were comparable (43 cm³ for successful vs. 40 cm³ for failed).
  • Fat Fraction (3D): Successful repairs maintained a stable 3D fat fraction (around 7.4% at 5 years), while failed repairs showed a significant increase from 9.1% preoperatively to 15.5% at 5 years. This represents a 70% increase compared to preoperative levels in the failed group.
  • Clinical Outcome: Absolute Constant-Murley scores were 81 ± 6 for successful repairs versus 72 ± 15 for failed repairs (P = .069), and relative scores were 94% ± 7% versus 85% ± 17% (P = .078), indicating a trend towards better outcomes in the successful group, though not statistically significant.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: The study acknowledges that the analysis of a subset of the original cohort resulted in smaller case numbers, potentially underpowering the study for some outcome parameters, particularly clinical outcomes.
  • Segmentation Subjectivity: While interrater reliability was good, the manual segmentation of muscle by two physicians introduced a degree of individual decision-making. The authors suggest that future applications of AI or cluster learning could improve accuracy.
  • Inclusion of Tear Types: The study included both acute and chronic tears, which could be a confounding factor for outcome analysis.
  • Correction Factor for MRI: Due to changes in MRI devices and protocols over the study period, a correction factor was applied to the 60-month fatty infiltration data, which could introduce some variability.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that defining a precise "time-zero" for postoperative analysis and exploring the potential for rerupture are important areas for future research. They also highlight the need for larger patient cohorts and potentially different study designs to further explore these outcome parameters.

Summary updated

Abstract

Successful RC repair was associated with relevant improvement of supraspinatus muscle mass and an unchanged fatty infiltration at a midterm follow-up of 5 years. However, failed repairs achieved only mild improvement of supraspinatus muscle volume and showed deterioration of fatty infiltration.
BibTeX
@article{kriechling2025d,
  author = {Philipp Kriechling and Jethin Joshy and Stefan Klotz and Georg C. Feuerriegel and Philipp Fürnstahl and Reto Sutter and Mazda Farshad and Karl Wieser},
  title = {{3D Muscle Volume and 3D Fat Fraction After Successful and Failed Arthroscopic Rotator Cuff Repair at 5-Year Follow-up}},
  journal = {The American Journal of Sports Medicine},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1177/03635465241299795},
}
Figure