Abstract: The three-manifold topological invariants $\hat Z$ capture the half-index of the three-dimensional theory with ${\mathcal{N}}=2$ supersymmetry obtained by compactifying the M5 brane theory on the closed three-manifold. In 2019, surprising general relations between the $\hat Z$-invariants, quantum modular forms, and vertex algebras have been proposed. In the meanwhile, an extensive array of examples have been studied, but several important general structural questions remain. First, for many three-manifolds we have seen hints of concrete $\widetilde {\rm SL}_2(\mathbb{Z})$ representations underlying the different $\hat Z$-invariants of the given manifolds. At the same time, these invariants appear to only span a subspace of the representation, and the role of the latter remains mysterious. We elucidate the meaning of the modular group representation, realized as vector-valued quantum modular forms, by first proposing the analogue $\hat Z$-invariants with supersymmetric defects, and subsequently showing that the full vector-valued quantum modular form for $\widetilde {\rm SL}_2(\mathbb{Z})$ is precisely the object capturing all the $\hat Z$-invariants of a given three-manifold, when the newly defined defects $\hat Z$-invariants are included. Second, it was expected that matching radial limits is a key feature of $\hat Z$-invariants when changing the orientation of the plumbed three-manifold, suggesting the relevance of mock modularity. We substantiate the conjecture by providing explicit proposals for such $\hat Z$-invariants for three three-manifolds and verify their mock modularity and limits. Third, we initiate the study of the vertex algebra structure of the mock type invariants by showcasing a systematic way to construct cone vertex operator algebras associated to these mock invariants, which can be viewed as the partner of logarithmic vertex operator algebras in this context.
Introduction: The 3d Modularity Puzzle
In the study of M-theory, compactifying an M5-brane theory on a 3-manifold ($M_3$) results in a 3D quantum field theory with $\mathcal{N}=2$ supersymmetry. A key observable of this theory is the "half-index," a topological invariant denoted as $\hat{Z}$. A major conjecture in the field suggests that these $\hat{Z}$ invariants are not just numbers, but components of quantum modular forms (QMF) and characters of vertex operator algebras (VOAs).
Despite the elegance of this framework, researchers faced two significant hurdles. First, for many manifolds, the known $\hat{Z}$ invariants only spanned a small subspace of the expected modular group representation. Second, while $\hat{Z}$ is well-defined for "weakly negative" plumbed manifolds, the formulas often diverge for "positive" manifolds (orientation-reversed), suggesting a deep link to mock modularity that lacked explicit verification.
Methodology
This research employs a combination of high-energy physics intuition and sophisticated number theory to bridge these gaps:
- Supersymmetric Defects: The authors propose a new class of invariants by inserting Wilson line defects (supersymmetric line operators) into the 3D theory. Mathematically, this involves modifying the contour integrals used to calculate $\hat{Z}$ by inserting $\mathfrak{sl}_2$ characters.
- Indefinite Theta Function Regularization: To handle orientation reversal, they use Zwegers’ technique for regularizing theta functions of indefinite lattices, mapping divergent "false" sums to convergent "mock" modular forms.
- Inverted Habiro Series: A surgery-based approach utilizing "inverted Habiro series" and Laplace-like transforms is used to compute invariants for manifolds constructed via knot surgeries.
- Cone VOAs: The study introduces vertex operator algebras associated with positive-definite cones in indefinite lattices, providing an algebraic home for the mock modular invariants.
Key Insights and Ideas
Defects Complete the Representation
The most significant finding is that the modular group does not just act on the basic $\hat{Z}$ invariants; it acts on the set of all possible supersymmetric boundary conditions. The "missing" components of the modular representation are exactly the $\hat{Z}$ invariants of the theory with defects. This completes the $SL_2(\mathbb{Z})$ action on supersymmetric boundary conditions, as illustrated in the conceptual framework of Figure 1.
The False-Mock Duality
The paper reinforces the idea that orientation reversal in topology ($M_3 \to -M_3$) is the geometric manifestation of the transition between "false" theta functions and "mock" modular forms in number theory. Just as logarithmic VOAs correspond to the "false" side, the newly proposed "cone VOAs" serve as the algebraic partners for the "mock" side.
Key Results
- Representation Isomorphism: For Brieskorn spheres, the authors prove that the vector space spanned by $\hat{Z}$ invariants with defects is isomorphic to specific Weil representations of the metaplectic group $\widetilde{SL}_2(\mathbb{Z})$.
- Explicit Mock Proposals: Explicit q-series are provided for orientation-reversed Brieskorn spheres $-\Sigma(2,3,7)$ and $-\Sigma(2,3,5)$, verifying their mock modular properties and matching their radial limits.
- Broad Verification: The "Modularity Conjecture" was tested against an extensive list of Seifert manifolds, finding consistent agreement between topological data and modular representations.
- Hyperbolic Knots: Even for non-plumbed knots like the figure-eight knot, surgery formulas produce interesting quantum modular objects, suggesting the theory extends beyond simple plumbing graphs.
Limitations and Future Work
While this work solidifies the $G=SU(2)$ case, generalizing these results to other ADE-type gauge groups remains a major next step. Additionally, while the "cone" construction works mathematically to produce mock forms, its precise physical interpretation in the context of 3D $\mathcal{N}=2$ theories requires further study. Finally, bridging the gap between this modular approach and the "resurgence analysis" of complex Chern-Simons theory remains a fertile area for future research.
Summary updated