3D FEM-BEM coupled resolution for acoustic waves propagation in potential flow

Nolwenn Balin, Guillaume Sylvand, Fabien CasenaveHAL 2012

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel coupled Finite Element Method (FEM) and Boundary Element Method (BEM) approach to accurately simulate acoustic wave propagation in complex airflow environments, such as those around aircraft. By combining FEM for near-field potential flow and BEM for far-field uniform flow, the method overcomes limitations of traditional approaches and offers a more realistic simulation of noise generation and propagation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aircraft manufacturers face increasing pressure to reduce environmental impact, which necessitates accurate simulation of acoustic wave propagation, especially in complex airflow conditions. Traditional methods like BEM are limited to uniform flows, while the airflow around aircraft can reach significant speeds (Mach 0.8) and exhibit complex behaviors due to components like turbofans and wings. This creates a need for simulation tools that can handle these non-uniform, potential flow regions accurately, while also efficiently modeling the propagation in the surrounding uniform flow. This paper tackles this challenge by developing a hybrid FEM-BEM approach to bridge these different flow regimes.

Methods

The core of this work is a coupled FEM-BEM formulation. The problem is divided into two domains: an interior domain (Ω) representing the potential flow near the aircraft and an exterior domain (Ωe) representing the far-field uniform flow.

  • FEM for Potential Flow (Ω): The acoustic equations in the potential flow domain are formulated using a weak form (variational formulation). This allows for the treatment of complex flow behaviors within this region.
  • BEM for Uniform Flow (Ωe): For the uniform flow domain, a Lorentz transformation is applied to simplify the acoustic equations into a Helmholtz equation. This transformation is crucial for efficiently using BEM in the exterior domain.
  • Coupling: The key innovation lies in the coupling between these two domains. The interface (Γ∞) between the potential and uniform flow regions requires continuity of acoustic pressure and velocity. This is achieved by identifying integrals from the FEM formulation in the potential flow domain with those arising in the BEM formulation for the uniform flow. A Levillain's S-formulation is used to solve this coupled system.
  • Modal Excitation: The paper also addresses how to model acoustic sources within the potential flow domain, specifically using modal sources. This involves expressing the unknowns on the modal surface as a sum of incident and reflected modes and solving for the unknown coefficients.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on developing and validating a numerical method using canonical test cases and a fan model problem.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Flow Regimes: The most significant insight is the successful development of a unified framework that accurately couples the distinct physics of potential flow (near-field) and uniform flow (far-field) for acoustic propagation. This overcomes a major limitation of existing methods.
  • Lorentz Transformation for BEM Efficiency: The application of the Lorentz transformation to the uniform flow domain is a clever way to reduce the problem to a Helmholtz equation, making BEM computationally tractable for this region.
  • Realistic Acoustic Simulation: By incorporating potential flow, the method allows for more realistic simulations of noise generation and propagation around complex geometries like aircraft, where uniform flow assumptions are insufficient.
  • Validation on Canonical and Complex Cases: The paper demonstrates the method's validity through comparisons with analytical solutions for canonical problems (sphere) and a more complex fan model, showing good agreement.

Key Results

  • Accuracy: For a cylindrical duct test case, the coupled FEM-BEM formulation showed a small error (2% in L²-norm) when compared to a pressure BEM formulation, indicating good accuracy.
  • Fan Model Comparison: The FEM-BEM results for a fan model problem showed good agreement with an analytic solution for both individual modes and the RMS sum of propagative modes. Differences observed were attributed to the truncation of the computational domain.
  • Potential Flow Influence: For the sphere test case, the presence of a more realistic potential flow around the sphere led to increased local acoustic velocity and pressure magnitudes, particularly in the shadow zone, highlighting the impact of non-uniform flow.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Non-Potential Flow: The authors acknowledge that further tests are needed to determine the method's capabilities for configurations with non-potential flows, which are representative of more complex industrial scenarios.
  • Meshing Requirements: Further investigation into the meshing requirements for the FEM part is suggested, as finite element dispersion can necessitate finer meshes for accurate results.
  • Industrial Test Cases: While validated on canonical cases, the authors suggest that more extensive testing on realistic industrial configurations is required to fully assess the method's capabilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

International audience
BibTeX
@inproceedings{balin2012d,
  author = {Nolwenn Balin and Guillaume Sylvand and Fabien Casenave},
  title = {{3D FEM-BEM coupled resolution for acoustic waves propagation in potential flow}},
  booktitle = {HAL},
  year = {2012},
}

Loading related content...

Figure