3-D Position Optimization of Solar-Powered Hovering UAV Relay in Optical Wireless Backhaul

Heyou Liu, Muhammad Salman Bashir, Mohamed‐Slim AlouiniIEEE Trans. Aerosp. Electron. Syst 2024

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of optimizing the 3D position of a solar-powered UAV relay for efficient wireless communication. By considering factors like solar energy harvesting, atmospheric conditions (clouds, turbulence), and optical wireless backhaul, the research provides a framework to maximize end-to-end channel capacity, crucial for extending UAV operational time and improving communication reliability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The widespread deployment of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) as communication relays faces a significant hurdle: limited onboard energy. While solar-powered UAVs offer a promising solution for extended flight, their effectiveness is heavily influenced by their position. This paper addresses the complex problem of optimizing the 3D position of a solar-powered UAV relay that connects a network of ground sensors to an optical ground station (OGS). The communication system utilizes RF for sensor-to-UAV links and optical wireless (FSO) for the UAV-to-OGS backhaul. The core challenge lies in balancing the need to maximize solar energy harvesting with the requirement to maintain optimal communication link quality, especially under varying atmospheric conditions that affect both solar power generation and FSO signal propagation. Existing research often focuses on 2D optimization or doesn't fully account for the interplay of solar energy, atmospheric effects, and the dual-link communication system.

Methods

The paper proposes a comprehensive approach to optimize the UAV's 3D position (x, y, z) to maximize the end-to-end channel capacity. Key methods include:

  • Channel Modeling: Detailed models for the RF sensor-to-UAV link (assuming Line-of-Sight) and the optical wireless UAV-to-OGS backhaul link are developed. The FSO link model incorporates impairments like pointing errors, atmospheric turbulence (modeled using exponentiated Weibull distribution), and attenuation due to clouds and air.
  • Solar Energy Harvesting and Consumption Models: The paper models the solar energy harvested by the UAV based on its altitude and atmospheric conditions, and also considers the power consumed by the UAV for hovering.
  • Optimization Framework: The problem is formulated as maximizing the end-to-end channel capacity, considering both Amplify-and-Forward (AF) and Decode-and-Forward (DF) relaying strategies.
  • 2D Optimization: Initially, the paper derives approximate closed-form solutions for optimal 2D (x, y) positioning for scenarios where UAV height is fixed, focusing on maximizing aggregate sensor-to-UAV capacity.
  • 3D Optimization: The core contribution is the 3D position optimization, where the UAV's altitude (z) is also optimized. This involves solving complex optimization problems, often requiring numerical techniques, to find the (x, y, z) coordinates that maximize the end-to-end capacity.
  • Asymptotic Analysis: The paper analyzes various asymptotic scenarios (e.g., high/low SNR in different links) to derive simplified solutions and gain deeper insights into the trade-offs involved.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on simulated data generated from the developed channel and energy models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Altitude-Atmosphere Trade-off: The optimal UAV altitude is a critical factor, balancing increased solar energy harvesting at higher altitudes with potential degradation of communication link quality due to increased path loss.
  • Atmospheric Impact: Cloud cover and atmospheric turbulence significantly influence both solar energy harvesting and the reliability of the optical wireless backhaul. Worse atmospheric conditions often necessitate higher UAV altitudes to maintain performance.
  • Positioning Sensitivity: The optimal UAV position is highly sensitive to atmospheric conditions. In severe fading, the UAV tends to move closer to the OGS to mitigate the impact of optical link impairments.
  • AF vs. DF Relay: The paper analyzes both AF and DF relaying strategies, highlighting how their performance and optimal positioning can differ, particularly under varying SNR conditions.
  • Max-Min Fairness: For sensor-to-UAV links, a max-min fairness approach is used to ensure a minimum level of service for all sensors, influencing the optimal 2D positioning.

Key Results

  • The paper derives approximate closed-form solutions for optimal 2D UAV positioning under certain SNR conditions, demonstrating high accuracy in asymptotic regimes.
  • It shows that for a fixed UAV height, the optimal position in the (x, y) plane to maximize capacity is often the same as the OGS position, especially when pointing error is the dominant fading factor.
  • Graphical illustrations (Figs. 5, 6, 7, 8) demonstrate the impact of various parameters (noise power, cloud attenuation, turbulence) on optimal UAV position and end-to-end capacity. For instance, increased cloud attenuation leads to higher optimal UAV altitudes.
  • The study highlights that as optical channel fading becomes more severe, the optimal UAV location shifts closer to the OGS to minimize the effect of fading.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The paper acknowledges simplifications, such as assuming Line-of-Sight (LoS) for RF links and nominal fading, and a simplified linear model for the relationship between cloud attenuation factors.
  • Numerical Optimization: While closed-form solutions are derived for some cases, the general 3D optimization problem often requires numerical techniques, which can be computationally intensive.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further research could explore more complex atmospheric models, non-LoS RF links, and the integration of multiple UAVs for enhanced coverage and resilience. Investigating the impact of different relaying protocols and energy harvesting technologies could also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

A major hurdle in widespread deployment of UAVs (unmanned aerial vehicle) in existing communications infrastructure is the limited UAV onboard energy. Therefore, this study considers solar energy harvesting UAVs for wireless communications. In this context, we consider three dimensional position optimization of a solar-powered UAV relay that connects a distant sensor field to an optical ground station (OGS) for data processing. The integrated sensor-UAV-OGS network utilizes radio frequency band for sensor-to-UAV links and the optical band for the UAV-to-OGS feeder link. Since atmospheric conditions affect both the harvested solar energy as well as the optical wireless signal, this study tackles UAV position optimization problems under various channel conditions such as clouds, atmospheric turbulence and dirt. From this study, we discover that the optimum position of the UAV -- that maximizes the end-to-end channel capacity -- is heavily dependent on the atmospheric channel conditions.
BibTeX
@article{liu2024d,
  author = {Heyou Liu and Muhammad Salman Bashir and Mohamed‐Slim Alouini},
  title = {{3-D Position Optimization of Solar-Powered Hovering UAV Relay in Optical Wireless Backhaul}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Aerosp. Electron. Syst.},
  year = {2024},
}
Figure