2P2-B32 Development of artificial skin and Ascertain of texture of skin with cosmetics

Yasuhisa Kamikawa, Hirokazu Shirado, Takashi MaénoThe Proceedings of JSME Annual Conference on Robotics and Mechatronics (Robomec) 2006 · DOI

Abstract

There has been a remarkable increase in demand to quantitatively measure and evaluate texture especially in the process of product design for cosmetics, apparel, and household products. The purpose of this study is to analyze the relationship between texture perception of geometry and artificial skin and effect of lubricants. We selected solid lubricant and fluid lubricant on artificial skin as samples. Next we evaluated texture of samples by the Semantic Differential Method and calculated texture scores. Then we measured suppress strength, dynamic friction, and tracing speed of a finger while an examinee evaluated the texture of samples. From these results we calculated tribologic characteristic of samples. Finally we analyzed the relationship between tribologic characteristics and texture score using the multiple regression analysis method. In conclusion we were able to quantify texture from tribologic characteristics, thus becoming able to evaluate the difference in textures which were considered difficult to distinguish.

Introduction

In industries such as cosmetics and apparel, the "feel" or texture of a product is a critical design factor. However, human tactile sensation is notoriously difficult to quantify objectively. While humans can easily distinguish between subtle textures like "silky" (sara-sara) and "smooth" (tsuru-tsuru), translating these subjective feelings into engineering specifications remains a challenge.

When a person touches a surface treated with a lotion or cream, they engage in "active touch." This creates a complex physical state known as mixed lubrication, where the perceived friction is a combination of solid-to-solid contact and fluid-film resistance. This research aims to determine if these specific tribological states can explain and predict how we perceive different textures.

Conceptual framework of tribological characteristics and sensory evaluation.

Methodology

The researchers employed a multi-disciplinary approach combining materials science, mechanical engineering, and psychology:

  1. Artificial Skin Fabrication: Artificial skin was created to mimic the surface geometry (roughness) and elasticity of human skin, ensuring consistent experimental conditions.
  2. Tribological Modeling: A mixed lubrication model was used to describe friction ($F$) relative to load ($W$). This model accounts for Solid Friction ($\mu$), resulting from direct contact between surface peaks, and Fluid Friction ($\mu^*$), caused by the viscosity and flow of the lubricant.
  3. Physical Measurement: Using specialized sensors, the team measured downward force (suppress strength), dynamic friction, and tracing speed as examinees touched the samples.
  4. Sensory Evaluation: The Semantic Differential (SD) Method was used to rate samples across seven Japanese tactile descriptors: beta-beta (sticky), shittori (moist), nuru-nuru (slimy), sara-sara (silky), tsuru-tsuru (smooth), sube-sube (slippery), and zara-zara (rough).

Results and Discussion

The study found that human touch is highly sensitive to the ratio of solid contact versus fluid lubrication. Multiple regression analysis was performed to map physical tribological values (roughness, solid friction, and fluid friction) to the sensory scores.

Multiple regression analysis results mapping physical characteristics to sensory scores.

As shown in the results, the physical model explains sensory perception with remarkably high coefficients of determination ($R^2$):

  • Sticky (beta-beta): $R^2 = 0.98$
  • Slippery (sube-sube): $R^2 = 0.99$
  • Rough (zara-zara): $R^2 = 0.96$
  • Silky (sara-sara): $R^2 = 0.98$

Specific descriptors were found to correlate strongly with particular physical states. For instance, "sticky" (beta-beta) is highly correlated with fluid lubrication characteristics (0.69), while "rough" (zara-zara) is primarily driven by surface geometry (0.66). These results suggest that nearly all variation in tactile description can be accounted for by measuring just three physical parameters: surface roughness, solid friction, and fluid friction.

Conclusion

This research successfully quantified texture from tribological characteristics, enabling the evaluation of differences in textures that were previously considered difficult to distinguish. By bridging the gap between human sensory perception and the physics of friction, this framework allows researchers to calculate texture scores without requiring a human panel for every product iteration. Future work may involve expanding the model to include thermal conductivity and applying these findings to the development of advanced tactile displays or human-like robotic sensors.

Summary updated

Abstract

There has been a remarkable increase in demand to quantitatively measure and evaluate texture especially in the process of product design for cosmetics, apparel, and household products. The purpose of this study is to analyze the relationship between texture perception of geometry and artificial skin and effect of lubricants. We selected solid lubricant and fluid lubricant on artificial skin as samples. Next we evaluated texture of samples by the Semantic Differential Method and calculated texture scores. Then we measured suppress strength, dynamic friction, and tracing speed of a finger while an examinee evaluated the texture of samples. From these results we calculated tribologic characteristic of samples. Finally we analyzed the relationship between tribologic characteristics and texture score using the multiple regression analysis method. In conclusion we were able to quantify texture from tribologic characteristics, thus becoming able to evaluate the difference in textures which were considered difficult to distinguish.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kamikawa2006p,
  author = {Yasuhisa Kamikawa and Hirokazu Shirado and Takashi Maéno},
  title = {{2P2-B32 Development of artificial skin and Ascertain of texture of skin with cosmetics}},
  booktitle = {The Proceedings of JSME Annual Conference on Robotics and Mechatronics (Robomec)},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1299/jsmermd.2006.\_2p2-b32\_1},
}
Figure