2nd annual progress report : mealiness in fruits :consumer perception and means for detection : FAIT CT 95-032 :

C. van Dijk, E. Biekman, C. Boeriu, T. Ebbenhorst-Seller, Y.a.m. Gerritsen, Smaranda Muresan, Alex van Schaik, E.p.h.m. Schijvens, J. Termeer, P. TijskensSocio-Environmental 1998

TL;DR

This report details research into "mealiness" in fruits, a textural defect affecting consumer perception. The study explores various instrumental methods (NIRS, GC, HPLC, texture analysis) to objectively measure mealiness and correlate them with sensory evaluations, aiming to develop reliable detection techniques.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mealiness in fruits, particularly apples, is a significant textural defect that negatively impacts consumer satisfaction and marketability. This defect is often described as a dry, crumbly, or mealy texture, contrasting with the desirable crisp and juicy texture. While consumers can readily perceive mealiness, objectively quantifying it and understanding its underlying causes has been challenging. This research aims to bridge this gap by investigating instrumental methods that can reliably detect and measure mealiness, correlating these measurements with human sensory perception, and exploring the biochemical changes associated with its development.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach, combining sensory analysis with various instrumental techniques:

  • Sensory Analysis: A trained analytical panel evaluated apples for attributes like mealiness, firmness, crispness, juiciness, dryness, and aroma. An expert panel was also used for specific experiments.
  • Near-Infrared Spectroscopy (NIRS): Used to develop models for predicting sensory attributes and chemical properties of apples based on their spectral data.
  • Gas Chromatography (GC) and GC-Mass Spectrometry (GC-MS): Employed to analyze volatile aroma compounds, investigating how their profiles change during storage and relate to mealiness.
  • High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC): Used to quantify taste compounds such as sugars, acids (malic and citric), and ascorbic acid.
  • Texture Measurements:
    • ATO-method: Involved measuring liquid separation and total area of apple cylinders under compression.
  • Modified UPM-method: Assessed parameters like Fmax, plastic deformation, and degree of elasticity.
  • Enzymatic Maceration/Cell Sloughing: Investigated the role of pectin degradation in the middle lamella by using endo-polygalacturonase enzyme to break down cell walls.
  • Statistical Analysis: Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and Partial Least Squares (PLS) regression were used to analyze the complex datasets and identify relationships between instrumental measurements and sensory perceptions.

Datasets

The study utilized apples from various cultivars, including Cox's Orange Pippin, Jonagold, and Elstar. These apples were subjected to different storage conditions (e.g., CA storage, storage in perforated plastic bags at 20°C) to induce varying levels of mealiness. Tomatoes were also briefly investigated, but their mealiness levels were too low for meaningful analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mealiness is a complex attribute: It's not solely defined by one factor but is a combination of dry feeling, lack of juiciness, and changes in other textural attributes.
  • NIRS shows promise for prediction: The study demonstrated that NIRS can predict sensory attributes like mealiness and firmness with reasonable accuracy, offering a non-destructive method for quality assessment.
  • Aroma changes with mealiness: While sensory panels perceived a decrease in aroma during storage, GC analysis showed an increase in "total aroma" compounds, suggesting mealiness might hinder the release of these compounds during chewing.
  • Malic acid as an indicator: A negative correlation was observed between malic acid content and mealiness, suggesting it could be a useful chemical marker.
  • Pectin degradation is key: The research strongly supports the hypothesis that mealiness is linked to the degradation of pectin in the middle lamella, making cells more susceptible to sloughing.

Key Results

  • Sensory vs. Instrumental Correlation: Good relationships were found between sensory mealiness and instrumental measurements like liquid separation and total area (ATO-method), suggesting these can be predictors of mealiness.
  • NIRS Calibration: PLS models achieved R-squared values above 0.9 for calibration of mealiness, firmness, and sourness, with cross-validation R-squared values ranging from 0.62 to 0.80.
  • Malic Acid Correlation: A linear model with R²=0.645 was obtained for correlating malic acid content with mealiness scores in Elstar apples.
  • GC-Aroma Profile: Differences in volatile compound profiles were observed between Cox and Jonagold apples, and these profiles changed during storage, though direct correlation with sensory mealiness was complex.
  • Tomatoes - Limited Mealiness: Tomatoes exhibited very low levels of mealiness, making them unsuitable for training sensory panels or performing detailed measurements.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small Datasets: The authors acknowledge that small datasets, particularly in early experiments, limited the reliability of models and contributed to lower cross-validation R-squared values.
  • Batch Variation: High variation within batches, especially for NIRS measurements, posed a challenge.
  • Complexity of Mealiness: The study suggests that mealiness is a multidimensional attribute, and a single variable might not be sufficient to fully describe it. Future work could involve developing more sophisticated models using a set of variables.
  • Tomato Mealiness Redefinition: Due to the lack of mealiness in tomatoes, the researchers proposed redefining the problem as "softness" to continue the investigation, focusing on the underlying pectin degradation mechanisms.
  • Further Validation: The authors emphasize the need for repeating experiments on a larger scale with more apple varieties to confirm the predictive capacity of parameters like liquid separation and total area. Continued attention to extraction procedures for mimicking chewing is also planned.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{dijk1998nd,
  author = {C. van Dijk and E. Biekman and C. Boeriu and T. Ebbenhorst-Seller and Y.A.M. Gerritsen and Smaranda Muresan and Alex van Schaik and E.P.H.M. Schijvens and J. Termeer and P. Tijskens},
  title = {{2nd annual progress report : mealiness in fruits :consumer perception and means for detection : FAIT CT 95-032 :}},
  booktitle = {Socio-Environmental},
  year = {1998},
}
Figure