2C5-2 Binocular disparity design in stereoscopic images for emotional enhancement

Daiki Atsuta, Sanghyun Kim, Takashi Kawai, Jukka HäkkinenThe Japanese Journal of Ergonomics 2014 · DOI

Introduction

While 3D media is often praised for its immersive qualities, the specific mechanisms by which binocular disparity—the technical basis for 3D depth—influences emotional response remain under-explored. This research investigates whether emotional arousal in 3D images is driven by specific, emotion-tailored depth designs or simply by the magnitude of 3D expansion. The study aims to determine if a "grammar" of depth exists or if increasing the overall depth range is the primary catalyst for heightened emotional intensity.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a controlled experiment with 20 university students using a 24-inch 3D display. Stimuli were selected from the International Affective Picture System (IAPS), covering four primary emotions: Happiness, Surprise, Sadness, and Fear.

Each image was presented in three distinct 3D conditions:

  1. 3D: A standard 3D conversion.
  2. E3D (Emotional 3D): Depth designed specifically to match the image's emotion based on cinematic analysis.
  3. D3D (Different 3D): Depth designed for an opposing emotion on Russell’s circumplex model (e.g., applying "fear" depth to a "happy" image).

Participants rated their emotional state using the Self-Assessment Manikin (SAM) scale, focusing on Valence (positive/negative quality) and Arousal (intensity).

Results and Analysis

Content vs. Depth Design

The study found that Valence is primarily determined by the image content itself. Statistical analysis (two-way ANOVA) showed a significant main effect for the original image ($p < .01$), but the specific 3D presentation condition (3D, E3D, or D3D) did not significantly alter whether an image felt positive or negative.

In contrast, Arousal was significantly influenced by both the image content ($p < .01$) and the 3D presentation condition ($p < .05$). Interestingly, there was no significant difference between the "correct" emotional depth (E3D) and the "wrong" emotional depth (D3D), suggesting that the specific distribution of depth is less critical for arousal than the total amount of depth provided.

Average arousal ratings across different 3D presentation conditions (3D, E3D, D3D) for four target emotions.

The Arousal-Valence Trade-off

A key insight emerged when re-ordering the results by the "expansion rate" of the 3D space (ranging from 145% to 333%). As the 3D expansion increased, arousal levels rose significantly. However, this came at a cost: valence tended to decrease as expansion increased, suggesting that while more depth makes an experience more intense, it may also make it less pleasant or more visually taxing.

Relationship between 3D expansion rate and emotional ratings, showing arousal increasing and valence decreasing as expansion grows.

Conclusion

The research concludes that the range of 3D expansion is the primary driver for emotional arousal in stereoscopic images, outweighing the importance of specific emotional depth patterns. While increasing depth enhances intensity, designers must balance this against a potential decrease in valence, likely due to increased visual strain. Future research will explore whether contracting 3D space can lower arousal and seek to identify the physiological threshold where high arousal transitions into discomfort.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{atsuta2014c,
  author = {Daiki Atsuta and Sanghyun Kim and Takashi Kawai and Jukka Häkkinen},
  title = {{2C5-2 Binocular disparity design in stereoscopic images for emotional enhancement}},
  journal = {The Japanese Journal of Ergonomics},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.5100/jje.50.s272},
}
Figure