2101 Development ofa Rehabilitation Robot Suit with Mechanical Safety Devices : Experimental Study

Shotaro Kanno, K. Katsumata, Satoshi Kitaguchi, Yoshihiro Kai, Wenlong Zhang, Masayoshi TomizukaKiso 2014 · DOI

Abstract

Safety is one of the most important issues in rehabilitation robot suits. We have developed a rehabilitation robot suit equipped with two mechanical safety devices. The robot suit assists a patient's knee joint. We call one safety device the "Velocity-based safety device" and the other the "torque-based safety device". The velocity-based safety device can switch off the motor of the robot suit if the device detects an unexpected joint angular velocity. Similarly, the torque-based safety device can switch off the motor if it detects an unexpected joint torque. The safety devices can work even if the computer breaks down because they consist of only passive mechanical components without actuators, controllers, or batteries. In this paper, we first review the characteristics of the safety devices and the rehabilitation robot suit equipped with the safety devices. We then present the experimental results of the simulated knee joint motion when the motor has turned off by the velocity based safety device. Finally, we discuss the effectiveness of the structure of the proposed robot suit based on the experimental results.

Introduction

In rehabilitation robotics, patient safety is paramount. Most modern robot suits rely on software-based safety limits; however, if the control computer crashes or the power fluctuates, the robot could potentially move at dangerous speeds or apply excessive force (torque) to a patient's limb, leading to injury.

The authors address the need for a "fail-safe" mechanism that does not rely on sensors, microcontrollers, or batteries. They propose a hardware-level solution where the physics of the machine itself acts as the emergency brake, ensuring protection even during a total electronic failure.

Conceptual diagram illustrating the risks of high velocity and torque during computer failure.

Mechanical Design and Methods

The prototype robot suit for the knee joint is equipped with two novel mechanical safety devices designed to operate independently of electronic control systems.

Velocity-Based Safety Device

This device utilizes a rotary damper connected to the drive shaft. As the shaft spins, the damper generates resistance proportional to the angular velocity. This resistance is balanced against a tension spring. If the angular velocity exceeds a pre-set limit, the damper's torque overcomes the spring's tension, causing a mechanical lever to flip a switch and cut the motor's power.

Torque-Based Safety Device

This mechanism employs a torsion spring and a series of wire ropes. When the torque applied to the joint exceeds a threshold, the torsion spring deforms. This deformation pulls the wire ropes, which slide a mechanical plate to trigger a power-off switch.

Exploded view showing the internal components of the velocity-based and torque-based safety devices.

Self-Locking Mechanism

The drive system incorporates a worm gear and worm wheel. This is a critical design choice because worm gears are naturally "self-locking" — once the power is cut by the safety devices, the gear prevents the motor from back-driving, immediately halting the limb's movement.

Experimental Evaluation

The prototype was evaluated using a physical experimental setup simulating a human limb. A 3.4 kg weight was attached to the robot's lower leg frame to simulate the mass and center of gravity of a human lower leg and foot (representative of a 170 cm tall, 62 kg individual). A motion capture system (HAS-500) tracked joint kinematics during safety triggers.

Key Results

The experimental study focused on the velocity-based device:

  • Trigger Accuracy: The device was set to trigger at a detection level of 2.01 rad/s. In five trials, the average actual trigger speed was 1.81 rad/s (standard deviation of 0.14 rad/s).
  • Stopping Behavior: Once power was cut, the limb decelerated rapidly. The knee joint exhibited a small, damped oscillation with an average amplitude of 2.41 degrees before coming to a complete stop.
  • Fail-Safe Confirmation: The experiments confirmed that the mechanical switch successfully cut the power and the worm gear held the load, preventing the simulated leg from falling.

Discussion and Conclusion

The study demonstrates the feasibility of passive mechanical safety systems in rehabilitation robotics. By using passive components, the safety system remains active even during total electronic failure. Furthermore, the torsion spring in the torque-based device acts as a buffer, absorbing kinetic energy and preventing a violent "jerk" during emergency stops.

While effective, the current prototype showed a roughly 20% error between intended and actual trigger speeds, likely due to tolerances in mechanical components like dampers and springs. Future work will focus on improving precision, assessing long-term mechanical wear, and conducting detailed energy absorption modeling to further refine patient comfort during emergency stops.

Summary updated

Abstract

Safety is one of the most important issues in rehabilitation robot suits. We have developed a rehabilitation robot suit equipped with two mechanical safety devices. The robot suit assists a patient's knee joint. We call one safety device the "Velocity-based safety device" and the other the "torque-based safety device". The velocity-based safety device can switch off the motor of the robot suit if the device detects an unexpected joint angular velocity. Similarly, the torque-based safety device can switch off the motor if it detects an unexpected joint torque. The safety devices can work even if the computer breaks down because they consist of only passive mechanical components without actuators, controllers, or batteries. In this paper, we first review the characteristics of the safety devices and tbe rehabilitation robot suit equipped with the safety devices. We then present the experimental results of the simulated knee joint motion when the motor has turned off by the velocity based safety device. Finally, we discuss the effectiveness of the structure of the proposed robot suit based on the experimental results.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kanno2014development,
  author = {Shotaro Kanno and K. Katsumata and Satoshi Kitaguchi and Yoshihiro KAI and Wenlong Zhang and Masayoshi Tomizuka},
  title = {{2101 Development ofa Rehabilitation Robot Suit with Mechanical Safety Devices : Experimental Study}},
  booktitle = {Kiso},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1299/jsmemdt.2014.14.95},
}
Figure