1A1-C12 A tool system to protect soft tissues for robot-assisted orthopedic surgery

Takayuki Osa, Naohiko Sugita, Yoshikazu Nakajima, Kazuo Fujiwara, Nobuhiro Abe, Toshifumi Ozaki, Masahiko Suzuki, Mamoru MitsuishiThe Proceedings of JSME Annual Conference on Robotics and Mechatronics (Robomec) 2008 · DOI

Abstract

In robot-assisted orthopedic surgery systems, rotational tools are frequently employed due to their compatibility with traditional industrial CAM software. However, the high-speed rotational cutting edge poses a significant risk to non-target soft tissues such as skin, tendons, and the patella. This paper presents the development of a specialized cutting tool equipped with an active tool cover designed to shield non-working parts of the blade. The system's efficacy was evaluated through a total knee arthroplasty (TKA) procedure on a human cadaver, demonstrating a marked reduction in soft tissue damage.

Introduction

The shift toward Minimally Invasive Surgery (MIS) in orthopedics aims to minimize patient trauma and accelerate recovery. However, the restricted workspace inherent in MIS increases the likelihood of accidental contact between high-speed surgical tools and surrounding anatomy. Standard end mills, often spinning at speeds up to 60,000 rpm, can easily tear soft tissue if the non-working side of the blade is not properly shielded. This research addresses the need for a dynamic protection mechanism that can navigate the tight quarters of an MIS environment without compromising surgical precision.

System Design and Methodology

The proposed system integrates a dynamic tool cover into a multi-axis robotic platform.

Hardware and Active Control

The core of the system is an 8mm diameter ball end mill. Unlike static guards, this tool features a semi-cylindrical cover with two degrees of freedom:

  1. Axial Control: An air-pressurized chamber allows the cover to retract, exposing the tool tip for plunging, or extend to protect the shaft.
  2. Rotational Control: A dedicated motor orients the shield circumferentially around the bit.
Design of the tool cover system showing axial and rotational control.

Robotic Integration

The tool is mounted on a multi-axis robot capable of complex maneuvers. A control algorithm calculates the tool's position relative to the planned cutting surface every 10 milliseconds. This ensures the shield's open side always faces the target bone, while the protected side faces vulnerable soft tissue.

The multi-axis robotic system used for bone-cutting procedures.

Experimental Validation

The system was validated through a cadaveric total knee arthroplasty. Using a small 80mm incision, the robot performed bone resection on the left leg of an adult male cadaver. The workflow included pre-operative CT scanning and 3D position tracking to generate precise tool paths that incorporated shield orientation commands.

Results and Discussion

The experimental results confirmed that the active shielding system successfully performed the required bone resections while maintaining the integrity of the surrounding skin and ligaments.

Key Insights

  • Active vs. Passive Protection: By treating the shield as a controllable robotic axis, the system can actively "sweep" tissue away from the cutting zone.
  • Comprehensive Shielding: The cover proved effective not only for soft tissues but also for protecting hard structures like the patella from accidental nicks.
  • Dynamic Response: The 10ms control loop provided sufficient responsiveness for complex tool paths.

Limitations and Future Directions

Despite the successful trial, several areas for improvement were identified. The tool cover experienced slight deformation, suggesting a need for increased mechanical stiffness. Additionally, the cover obscures the surgeon's direct line of sight, necessitating the integration of cameras or augmented reality for better visualization. Future work will also focus on miniaturizing the tool footprint and improving software to prevent the shield itself from colliding with bone structures.

Conclusion

The developed tool cover system represents a significant step toward safer robot-assisted MIS. By actively shielding the non-working parts of high-speed rotational tools, the system mitigates the risks of soft tissue damage, potentially expanding the feasibility of robotic assistance in complex orthopedic procedures.

Summary updated

Abstract

In robot-assisted orthopedic surgery system, rotational tools are often used because traditional industrial CAM can be applied to these systems. On the other hand, in case that a rotational cutting tool is used, non-working part of the cutting edge is likely to collide and damage soft tissue such as skin, tendon and patella. We developed a cutting tool equipped with a tool cover to cover a non-working part of the cutting edge to protect soft tissue in minimally invasive orthopedic surgery. In order to evaluate the cutting tool system, we performed a total knee arthroplasty with a cadaver. The experiment showed that the cutting tool system decreased the damage of soft tissue and the cutting tool system was effective.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{osa2008c,
  author = {Takayuki Osa and Naohiko Sugita and Yoshikazu Nakajima and Kazuo Fujiwara and Nobuhiro Abe and Toshifumi Ozaki and Masahiko Suzuki and Mamoru Mitsuishi},
  title = {{1A1-C12 A tool system to protect soft tissues for robot-assisted orthopedic surgery}},
  booktitle = {The Proceedings of JSME Annual Conference on Robotics and Mechatronics (Robomec)},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1299/jsmermd.2008.\_1a1-c12\_1},
}
Figure