1982–2010 Trends of Light Use Efficiency and Inherent Water Use Efficiency in African vegetation: Sensitivity to Climate and Atmospheric CO2 Concentrations

Abdoul Khadre Traoré, Philippe Ciais, Nicolas Vuichard, Natasha MacBean, Cécile Dardel, Benjamin Poulter, Shilong Piao, Joshua B. Fisher, Nicolas Viovy, Martin Jung, Ranga B. MyneniRemote 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates 30-year trends in how African vegetation uses light and water, revealing that while water use efficiency is increasing, light use efficiency trends are less clear. The research highlights the significant role of rising atmospheric CO2 in driving these changes, particularly in the central African forests.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how vegetation uses light and water is crucial for grasping the global carbon and water cycles, especially in Africa, a continent characterized by significant climate variability and dry conditions. While previous studies have explored these efficiencies, many have relied on limited in-situ measurements or focused on specific locations. This paper aims to fill this gap by analyzing long-term trends across major African biomes using satellite data and a sophisticated land surface model, and importantly, to disentangle the influences of climate change and rising CO2 on these trends.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Data-driven analysis: They utilized satellite-derived vegetation indices (NDVI3g) and fraction of absorbed photosynthetically active radiation (fAPAR3g) to construct observational products for Light Use Efficiency (LUE) and inherent Water Use Efficiency (iWUE*). This involved using a model calibrated with flux tower data (though notably, no African flux tower data was available for direct calibration).
  • Process-based modeling: The ORCHIDEE land surface model was used to simulate LUE and iWUE* trends. Two versions of the model were employed, differing in their soil hydrology schemes (a simpler two-layer model and a more complex 11-layer model).
  • Factorial simulations: To attribute observed trends, the model was run under different scenarios:
  • A simulation with transient atmospheric CO2 and a specific climate forcing (WFDEI).
  • A simulation with a simplified two-layer soil model and the same climate forcing.
  • A simulation with a fixed atmospheric CO2 concentration (representative of 1979) to isolate the CO2 effect.
  • A simulation using an alternative climate forcing (WFD) to assess climate forcing sensitivity.

Datasets

  • NOAA-AVHRR NDVI3g: Used for vegetation monitoring.
  • fAPAR3g (Global Inventory Modeling and Mapping Studies): A third-generation satellite dataset providing fraction of absorbed photosynthetically active radiation.
  • MTE (Model Tree Ensemble) products: Data-driven estimates of Gross Primary Productivity (GPP) and Evapotranspiration (ET), used for evaluating model performance.
  • WATCH-Forcing-Data-ERA-Interim (WFDEI): A gridded climate reanalysis dataset (1979-2010) used as the primary climate forcing for the ORCHIDEE model.
  • WATCH Forcing Data (WFD): An alternative climate forcing dataset (1958-2001, extended to 1901) used to assess climate forcing sensitivity.
  • GPCCv5 and GPCCv4 rain gauge measurements: Used for bias correction of precipitation data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CO2 is a major driver: The study strongly suggests that rising atmospheric CO2 concentrations are a primary factor behind observed increases in water use efficiency, particularly in forest ecosystems. This is a critical insight for understanding how terrestrial ecosystems will respond to future climate change.
  • Regional disparities are significant: Trends in LUE and iWUE* are not uniform across Africa. The central African forest and northern savannas show distinct patterns compared to other regions, highlighting the need for region-specific climate and vegetation management strategies.
  • Model limitations are revealed: While process-based models like ORCHIDEE are valuable tools, this study underscores their limitations in accurately capturing observed trends, especially for LUE and in certain regions like the northern savannas. This points to areas where model improvements are needed.
  • Climate forcing matters: The choice of climate forcing data can significantly influence simulated trends, particularly for iWUE*, emphasizing the importance of high-quality, consistent climate data for Earth system modeling.

Key Results

  • iWUE* trends: Observational data (MTE product) showed a significant positive trend in iWUE (10-20% per decade) over the northern savannas and central African forests between 1982 and 2010. In contrast, some regions like Kenya and Angola showed negative trends. The ORCHIDEE model reproduced a significant positive iWUE trend primarily in the central African forest.
  • LUE trends: Observational LUE trends were generally not statistically significant across most of Africa. The ORCHIDEE model simulated a modest positive LUE trend (around 5% per decade) in the central African forest.
  • CO2 attribution: Increasing atmospheric CO2 (a rise of 52.8 ppm over the study period) explained 30-50% of the modeled iWUE* increase and over 90% of the modeled LUE trend in the central African forest.
  • Climate forcing sensitivity: The choice of climate forcing data had a significant impact on simulated iWUE* trends, particularly in the central African forest, where differences could reach up to 75% of the trend magnitude.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data limitations: The study notes the scarcity and heterogeneity of in-situ measurements in Africa, which limits direct model calibration and validation. The MTE products, while valuable, have moderate confidence due to the lack of African flux tower data for calibration.
  • Model uncertainties: The ORCHIDEE model struggled to reproduce observed iWUE* trends in the northern savannas and negative trends in other regions. The model's phenology scheme and its sensitivity to CO2 fertilization in forest ecosystems are identified as areas for improvement.
  • Ecological processes: The study acknowledges that it did not specifically address the influence of ecological processes like photosynthesis, respiration, or fire, nor did it deeply investigate soil moisture availability's role in iWUE* and LUE trends.
  • Future work: The authors suggest improving ORCHIDEE simulations by better representing phenology using in-situ observations. They also emphasize the need to analyze seasonal trends and variability of LUE and iWUE, and to investigate the effects of land use change on these efficiencies, particularly in agricultural regions. Further research is also recommended to analyze the environmental and ecological processes affecting African iWUE and LUE trends.

Summary updated

Abstract

Light and water use by vegetation at the ecosystem level, are key components for understanding the carbon and water cycles particularly in regions with high climate variability and dry climates such as Africa. The objective of this study is to examine recent trends over the last 30 years in Light Use Efficiency (LUE) and inherent Water Use Efficiency (iWUE*) for the major biomes of Africa, including their sensitivities to climate and CO2. LUE and iWUE* trends are analyzed using a combination of NOAA-AVHRR NDVI3g and fAPAR3g, and a data-driven model of monthly evapotranspiration and Gross Primary Productivity (based on flux tower measurements and remote sensing fAPAR, yet with no flux tower data in Africa) and the ORCHIDEE (ORganizing Carbon and Hydrology In Dynamic EcosystEms) process-based land surface model driven by variable CO2 and two different gridded climate fields. The iWUE* data product increases by 10%–20% per decade during the 1982–2010 period over the northern savannas (due to positive trend of vegetation productivity) and the central African forest (due to positive trend of vapor pressure deficit). In contrast to the iWUE*, the LUE trends are not statistically significant. The process-based model simulations only show a positive linear trend in iWUE* and LUE over the central African forest. Additionally, factorial model simulations were conducted to attribute trends in iWUE and LUE to climate change and rising CO2 concentrations. We found that the increase of atmospheric CO2 by 52.8 ppm during the period of study explains 30%–50% of the increase in iWUE* and >90% of the LUE trend over the central African forest. The modeled iWUE* trend exhibits a high sensitivity to the climate forcing and environmental conditions, whereas the LUE trend has a smaller sensitivity to the selected climate forcing.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{traore2014trends,
  author = {Abdoul Khadre Traoré and Philippe Ciais and Nicolas Vuichard and Natasha MacBean and Cécile Dardel and Benjamin Poulter and Shilong Piao and Joshua B. Fisher and Nicolas Viovy and Martin Jung and Ranga B. Myneni},
  title = {{1982–2010 Trends of Light Use Efficiency and Inherent Water Use Efficiency in African vegetation: Sensitivity to Climate and Atmospheric CO2 Concentrations}},
  booktitle = {Remote},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.3390/rs6098923},
}
Figure