10 GHz robust polarization modulation towards high-speed satellite-based quantum communication

Zengfu Wang, Huaxing Xu, Ju Li, Huicun Yu, Jinquan Huang, Hui Han, Chang-Lei Wang, Ping Zhang, Feifei Yin, Kun Xu, Bo Liu, Yitang DaiEPJ 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel 10 GHz polarization modulation scheme for satellite-based quantum communication that overcomes the speed limitations of previous methods. By leveraging the non-reciprocity of lithium niobate modulators, they achieve robust, low-error, and significantly faster modulation, paving the way for higher secure key rates in practical QKD systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Satellite-based Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) promises secure communication over long distances, but faces significant challenges. One major hurdle is the preparation and transmission of polarization-encoded photons, which are susceptible to environmental disturbances and high channel losses. To boost the Secure Key Rate (SKR), robust, low-error, and high-speed polarization modulation is crucial. Existing self-compensating schemes offer robustness but are limited to modulation speeds around 2 GHz due to unwanted interactions between electrical signals and reverse optical pulses within the modulator. This speed limitation hinders the overall performance of satellite QKD systems.

Methods

The core innovation of this work lies in utilizing the non-reciprocal characteristic of lithium niobate (LiNbO₃) modulators. Unlike traditional modulators where both forward and reverse optical pulses interact with the electrical signal, LiNbO₃ modulators exhibit different behavior depending on the direction of propagation. The authors exploit this by designing a Sagnac interferometer-based polarization encoder. In this setup, only the forward-propagating optical pulses are modulated by the electrical signal, while the reverse-propagating pulses are largely unaffected. This effectively eliminates the problematic interaction that limited previous schemes.

Key aspects of their method include:

  • Sagnac Interferometer: This configuration allows for self-compensation of phase noise and polarization mode dispersion (PMD), ensuring robustness against environmental effects.
  • LiNbO₃ Phase Modulator (PM): The non-reciprocal nature of this component is central to achieving high-speed modulation.
  • RF Sine Wave Modulation: Instead of square waves used in prior work, they employ an RF sine wave. This, combined with the non-reciprocity, ensures that the reverse pulses experience negligible modulation, even when traveling through the PM simultaneously with forward pulses.
  • Synchronization: Precise synchronization between the ultrashort optical pulses and the RF sine wave is achieved using a 10 MHz clock, ensuring optimal modulation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments rely on laboratory-generated optical pulses and standard measurement equipment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Non-reciprocity as a Key Enabler: The paper brilliantly demonstrates how a fundamental property of a material (non-reciprocity in LiNbO₃) can be harnessed to overcome a critical bottleneck in a quantum technology.
  • Breaking the Speed Barrier: By decoupling the modulation speed from the physical constraints of the optical path (like waveguide length), they shatter the previous ~2 GHz limit, reaching an impressive 10 GHz.
  • Robustness Maintained: Crucially, the high modulation speed is achieved without sacrificing the robustness and low error rates that are essential for QKD. The Sagnac interferometer design plays a vital role here.
  • Sine Wave Advantage: The use of an RF sine wave, rather than a square wave, for modulation is shown to be critical in minimizing unwanted modulation on the reverse optical pulses, further contributing to low error rates.

Key Results

  • 10 GHz Modulation Speed: The system successfully operates at a 10 GHz repetition frequency, a significant leap from previous ~2 GHz systems.
  • Low Intrinsic QBER: The measured average intrinsic quantum bit error rate (IQBER) for the four polarization states is as low as 0.53% over 10 minutes at 10 GHz, without any compensation.
  • High Polarization Extinction Ratio (PER): The experimental setup achieved a PER exceeding 18.24 dB, which corresponds to a QBER of approximately 1.5%.
  • Extended Transmission Distance: Simulations indicate that the proposed scheme can extend the transmission distance for satellite QKD to over 350 km while maintaining a high SKR.
  • Commercial Components: The scheme is designed to be implemented using commercially available components, making it more practical for real-world deployment.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Synchronization Sensitivity: While the paper emphasizes the importance of synchronization, it acknowledges that in practical systems, thermal noise and jitter can cause delays between optical pulses and electrical signals. This delay can degrade the PER for their sine wave modulation scheme, unlike the more tolerant square wave approach. Future work would need to address robust synchronization mechanisms to maintain performance under real-world conditions.
  • Simulation vs. Experiment: While experimental results are presented for 10 GHz, the extended transmission distance and SKR simulations are based on theoretical models. Further experimental validation of these long-distance capabilities would be beneficial.
  • Duty Cycle Impact: The paper highlights that a wider pulse width (leading to a higher duty cycle) can negatively impact PER due to phase noise introduced by the uneven sine wave envelope. Optimizing pulse width and synchronization is crucial.

The authors suggest that their scheme is a significant step towards enabling high-speed, high-loss satellite-based quantum communication and can be readily applied to other encoding schemes like time-bin.

Summary updated

Abstract

In practical satellite-based quantum key distribution (QKD) systems, the preparation and transmission of polarization-encoding photons suffer from complex environmental effects and high channel loss. Consequently, the hinge to enhancing the secure key rate (SKR) lies in achieving robust, low-error, and high-speed polarization modulation. Although the schemes that enable self-compensation demonstrate remarkable robustness, their modulation speed is limited to around 2 GHz to prevent the interaction between the electrical signal and the reverse optical pulses. Here, we utilize the non-reciprocity of the lithium niobate modulators and eliminate the modulation on the reverse optical pulses. This characteristic is widely available in the radio-frequency band, allowing the modulation speed to no longer be limited by the self-compensating optics and enabling further increases. The measured average intrinsic quantum bit error rate of the four polarization states at 10 GHz system repetition frequency is as low as 0.53% over 10 min without any compensation. The simulation results show that our scheme can maintain a SKR of about 5 kbps even at the extreme communication distances between the satellite and the earth. Our work can be efficiently applied in high-speed, high-loss satellite-based quantum communication scenarios.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2025ghz,
  author = {Zengfu Wang and Huaxing Xu and Ju Li and Huicun Yu and Jinquan Huang and Hui Han and Chang-Lei Wang and Ping Zhang and Feifei Yin and Kun Xu and Bo Liu and Yitang Dai},
  title = {{10 GHz robust polarization modulation towards high-speed satellite-based quantum communication}},
  booktitle = {EPJ},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1140/epjqt/s40507-025-00349-y},
}
Figure