078 Injury risk in school children with probable developmental coordination disorder or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder

Kyle McCallum, Benjamin Tan, Rebecca A Marjoram, Carly McKay, Patricia K. Doyle–Baker, Tal Jarus, Deborah Dewey, Carolyn A. Emery2021 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates whether elementary school children with probable Developmental Coordination Disorder (pDCD) or Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (pADHD) face a higher risk of sports and recreation (S&R) injuries. Analyzing a cohort of 681 students in Calgary, Canada, the research found an overall injury incidence proportion of 28.2 per 100 participations. Contrary to the common assumption that motor coordination difficulties or impulsivity lead to higher injury rates, no statistically significant difference was found between children with pDCD or pADHD and their typically developing peers. These findings suggest that injury prevention strategies should be applied universally across the elementary school population rather than targeting specific neurodevelopmental groups.

Introduction

The "injury burden"—defined by the frequency and impact of physical injuries—is a well-established concern for adolescent athletes aged 13 to 19. However, there is a notable lack of empirical data regarding younger children, particularly those under the age of 13. This developmental window is critical as children begin to engage more formally in organized sports and recreational activities.

A specific area of concern involves children with neurodevelopmental conditions. Developmental Coordination Disorder (DCD) is characterized by motor coordination difficulties that interfere with daily activities, while Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) often involves symptoms of inattention and impulsivity. It has long been hypothesized that these traits might render children "accident-prone," leading to a higher risk of injury during physical activity. This study seeks to provide empirical evidence to confirm or refute whether these children are actually at a higher risk in a school-aged population (ages 8–13).

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study involving 681 students recruited from 33 randomly selected elementary schools in Calgary, Canada. The participants were in grades 4 through 6, ranging in age from 8 to 13 years.

To identify children with probable neurodevelopmental conditions, the study employed two validated screening tools:

  1. DCDQ’07 (DCD Questionnaire): A parent-report tool used to identify children with motor coordination challenges consistent with pDCD.
  2. VADPRS (Vanderbilt ADHD Rating Scale): A scale used to identify children meeting the criteria for pADHD.

Injury data were collected through surveys completed by children and their parents or guardians, covering the preceding one-year period. For the purposes of this study, an injury was defined as an event requiring medical attention or resulting in time lost from physical participation. The researchers calculated the Incidence Proportion (IP) (injuries per 100 participations) and the Injury Rate (IR) (injuries per 1,000 participation hours).

Results

The study revealed a significant baseline injury burden across the entire cohort. The overall S&R Incidence Proportion was 28.2 injuries per 100 participations, with an Injury Rate of 2.43 injuries per 1,000 participation hours.

When comparing the target groups to typically developing children, the raw injury rates were slightly higher for those with pDCD (3.13) and pADHD (2.82) compared to the control group (2.2). However, statistical analysis using Odds Ratios (OR) adjusted for relevant variables showed no significant increase in risk:

  • pDCD: OR = 1.08 (95% CI: 0.64–1.84)
  • pADHD: OR = 1.14 (95% CI: 0.53–2.45)
  • Combined (pDCD and pADHD): OR = 1.24 (95% CI: 0.58–2.65)

Because the 95% confidence intervals for all groups included 1.0, the differences were not statistically significant. This indicates that children with these conditions do not face a demonstrably higher risk of injury than their peers in this school-aged population.

Discussion

The findings of this study challenge the "clumsiness" assumption—the idea that children with motor coordination or attention difficulties are inherently more prone to injury in sports settings. While the raw rates were marginally higher, the overlap in confidence intervals suggests that the factors contributing to injury in elementary-aged children are likely more complex than neurodevelopmental status alone.

One encouraging takeaway is the evidence of participation parity. The ability to calculate comparable injury rates suggests that children with pDCD and pADHD are participating in sports and recreation at levels similar to their peers. This highlights the success of inclusive physical education and community sports programs.

However, the high overall injury rate (28.2 per 100 participations) remains a point of concern. This baseline risk suggests that injury prevention should not be limited to "high-risk" groups but should instead be a universal priority for all children in elementary sports.

Limitations and Future Work

Several limitations should be considered when interpreting these results. First, the study used "probable" designations (pDCD/pADHD) based on screening tools rather than clinical, gold-standard diagnostic assessments. Second, the reliance on a one-year retrospective survey introduces the possibility of recall bias, where participants may forget minor injuries or misreport the timing of events. Finally, while the total sample size was 681, the specific sub-groups (particularly those with comorbid pDCD and pADHD) were relatively small, which may have limited the statistical power to detect subtle differences in risk.

Future research should focus on longitudinal tracking of injuries and the evaluation of universal injury prevention strategies that can be implemented across diverse school populations to reduce the overall burden of injury in young children.

Summary updated

Abstract

The median number of completed weekly reports was 45 . The annual IP for injury was 68% and for illness 77%. The injury IR was 6.9/1000 hours and the illness IR 9.3/1000 hours. The median time to injury was 19 weeks (95% CI: 10.5-27.4) and to illness 9 weeks (95% CI: 1.4-16.6). Most injuries occurred during training and 34% were classified as severe (!21 days of time loss). An increased injury risk was observed among athletes in team sports (HR 1.88; 95% CI: 1.19-2.99), athletes with a previous severe injury (HR 2.37; 95% CI: 1.47-3.83) and male athletes (HR 1.76; 95% CI: 1.06-2.93). The most common illness type was infection (84%). Athletes in team sports (HR 1.64; 95% CI: 1.05-2.54) had a higher illness risk. One third of the athletes (34%; 95% CI 32.0-35.2) reported weekly that they felt anxious/depressed and 48% (95% CI 45.7-50.1) reported moderate or extreme pain every week. Conclusions Paralympic athletes report a considerably high incidence of injuries and illnesses as well as pain and psychological complaints. This emphasizes the need to develop preventive strategies and optimize medical services for this heterogeneous athlete population.
BibTeX
@misc{mccallum2021injury,
  author = {Kyle McCallum and Benjamin Tan and Rebecca A Marjoram and Carly McKay and Patricia K. Doyle–Baker and Tal Jarus and Deborah Dewey and Carolyn A. Emery},
  title = {{078 Injury risk in school children with probable developmental coordination disorder or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1136/bjsports-2021-ioc.74},
}
Figure