Young‐onset colorectal cancer in the Asia–Pacific region

Moe H. Kyaw, Joseph J.�y. SungThe Medical Journal of Australia 2016 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Since the early 2000s, colorectal cancer (CRC) in patients under the age of 50—traditionally considered a disease of the elderly—has emerged as a significant public health concern. While robust data from the United States and Europe indicate a rising incidence of young-onset CRC, the epidemiological landscape in the Asia–Pacific region remains complex and often contradictory. This paper examines the current evidence from population-based registries and institutional reports, highlighting the need for standardized definitions and clinical vigilance in the absence of clear regional trends.

Introduction

Colorectal cancer screening programs typically begin at age 50, based on the historical prevalence of the disease in older populations. However, data from the Surveillance, Epidemiology and End Results (SEER) registries in the United States have demonstrated a paradoxical shift: while CRC incidence is declining in older adults, it is steadily rising among the young. As the Asia–Pacific region undergoes rapid urbanization and adopts "Westernized" lifestyle factors—such as dietary changes, increased smoking rates, and sedentary behavior—there is growing concern that a similar trend may be unfolding.

The Definition of "Young-Onset"

A significant hurdle in interpreting CRC research is the lack of a consensus definition for "young-onset." Historical studies, including a landmark 2004 systematic review by O’Connell and colleagues, often defined the threshold as under 40 years of age. More recent literature, however, has shifted toward a threshold of under 50, aligning with the age at which routine population screening typically commences. Adopting a standardized definition of <50 years is essential for comparing international datasets and determining the appropriate age for screening interventions.

Unlike the clear upward trajectory seen in Western nations, data from the Asia–Pacific region presents a fragmented picture:

  • Australia: Findings are inconsistent. While some studies suggested an increase, recent data from New South Wales indicates that the incidence of young-onset CRC is not currently rising in that jurisdiction. Disparities between studies are likely due to differences in study periods and baseline incidence rates.
  • Hong Kong: Analysis of the Hong Kong Cancer Registry (1983–2006) showed no significant increase in CRC among younger cohorts.
  • South Korea: Data from 1999–2009 found no overall increase in young-onset CRC relative to older patients, though a specific rise in rectal cancer incidence was noted in the younger age group.

The Challenge of Institutional Bias

Much of the concern regarding young-onset CRC in Asia stems from institutional or hospital-based reports rather than population registries. For example, a tertiary center in India reported that 35.5% of its CRC patients were young-onset, while a Taiwanese institution reported 6.7%.

However, the authors caution against over-interpreting these figures due to "referral bias." Specialized centers often attract a disproportionate number of young patients with hereditary syndromes (such as Lynch syndrome or Familial Adenomatous Polyposis). Furthermore, in lower-resource settings, older patients may be less likely to seek specialized care, while younger, symptomatic patients are prioritized for referral, leading to an overestimation of the disease's prevalence in the general population.

Clinical and Pathological Profile

Despite the epidemiological uncertainty, the clinical presentation of young-onset CRC in the Asia–Pacific mirrors that seen in the West. The disease in younger patients is frequently more biologically aggressive than in older adults. Key characteristics include:

  • Distal Location: A higher prevalence of tumors in the distal colon and rectum.
  • Advanced Stage at Diagnosis: Often due to delays in seeking medical attention or clinical dismissal of symptoms.
  • Aggressive Histology: Frequent presence of poor cellular differentiation, mucinous features, and signet ring cells.

Conclusion and Future Directions

Currently, there is insufficient population-based evidence to justify lowering the age for universal CRC screening in the Asia–Pacific region. Instead, the focus must remain on clinical awareness and risk stratification. Clinicians should maintain a high index of suspicion for young patients presenting with red-flag symptoms, such as rectal bleeding, and ensure they receive timely diagnostic workups and genetic counseling.

Future research must prioritize large-scale, population-based data to determine if the drivers of young-onset CRC in the East—including the role of the microbiome and specific genetic markers—match those identified in Western populations. Until then, targeted screening for high-risk individuals remains the most prudent public health strategy.

Summary updated

Abstract

hen O'Connell and colleagues published their systematic review of young-onset colorectal cancer (CRC) in 2004, 1 defined as CRC in a person no older than 40 years of age, there had only been one study in the AsiaePacific region. 2 Several reports have subsequently raised concerns about an increasing incidence of young-onset CRC in this region.If the number of patients is indeed rising, should we respond to this epidemiological problem with new measures?Strong evidence suggests that the incidence of young-onset CRC is increasing in the United States and Europe, in contrast to a declining incidence in older people.Most of this evidence comes from population-based analyses of data from the SEER (Surveillance, Epidemiology and End Results) registries. 3 In this issue of the MJA, investigators from New South Wales suggest that, at least at present, the incidence of young-onset CRC is not increasing here. 4Different trends in the incidence of young-onset CRC were reported by two earlier population-based studies in Australia. 5,6The most likely explanations for the disparity in the results of these studies involve differences in the study periods and baseline incidence of young-onset CRC.For the rest of the AsiaePacific region, only two population-based studies have reported trends for young-onset CRC.An analysis of data from the Hong Kong Cancer registry did not find an increase in the incidence of young-onset CRC during 1983e2006. 7he second study, analysing data from the Korean cancer registry, similarly found no increase during 1999e2009 in the overall incidence of young-onset CRC relative to older patients, although the incidence of rectal cancer in the younger age group increased. 8
BibTeX
@article{kyaw2016youngonset,
  author = {Moe H. Kyaw and Joseph J.�Y. Sung},
  title = {{Young‐onset colorectal cancer in the Asia–Pacific region}},
  journal = {The Medical Journal of Australia},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.5694/mja16.00957},
}
Figure