Welfare Reform in California: Early Results from the Impact Analysis

Jacob Alex Klerman, V. Joseph Hotz, Elaine Reardon, Amy G. Cox, Donna O. Farley, Steven J. Haider, Guido W. Imbens, Robert F. SchoeniRAND 2003 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract: Examines the effects of the California Work Opportunity and Responsibility to Kids (CalWORKs) program on work activity participation rates of welfare recipients, welfare caseloads, and outcomes for welfare leavers. While the CalWORKs reforms appear to have been responsible for some of the uniform improvement in outcomes shown by the analysis, the robust economy and other policy changes were probably also important.

Introduction

In 1996, the federal Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act (PRWORA) replaced the Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) program with Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), ending the era of welfare as an open-ended entitlement. California responded by enacting the California Work Opportunity and Responsibility to Kids (CalWORKs) program in 1997. This report provides a comprehensive evaluation of the program's early impacts, focusing on work participation, caseload dynamics, and the economic well-being of those leaving the system.

The Causal Challenge: Policy vs. Economy

A central question for researchers was whether the dramatic improvements in welfare outcomes during the late 1990s were driven by the new "work-first" requirements or by the exceptionally strong economic expansion of the era. California's caseload peaked in 1995—later than the national peak in 1994—due to a deeper and more persistent state recession. Disentangling these factors is crucial for understanding the true efficacy of the CalWORKs reforms.

Methodology

The evaluation utilized a variety of nonexperimental techniques to assess the program's impact:

  • Descriptive Trend Analysis: Comparing pre- and post-reform outcomes in California against national benchmarks.
  • Simulation Modeling: Using "mechanical" and "behavioral" models to estimate how California’s caseload would have changed if it had adopted the more restrictive benefit structures seen in other states.
  • Dynamic Decomposition: Analyzing the flows of individuals onto and off the welfare rolls to identify the primary drivers of caseload reduction.

The study relied on several large-scale datasets, including the Medi-Cal Eligibility Data System (MEDS) for individual participation tracking, Employment Development Department (EDD) records for longitudinal earnings data, and Current Population Survey (CPS) data for national comparisons.

Key Findings: The "Positive Inducement" Strategy

California’s approach to welfare reform was unique in its emphasis on "positive inducements." While many states implemented punitive measures like full-family sanctions, California allowed recipients to keep a significant portion of their earnings—specifically the first $225 plus 50% of any additional income.

Caseload and Work Participation

This policy design led to two distinct outcomes:

  1. Higher Work Participation: By FFY 1999, California’s work participation rate reached 42.2%, notably higher than the national average of 38.3%. The financial incentives effectively encouraged recipients to combine work with aid.
  2. Slower Caseload Decline: California’s caseload fell by 41% between 1995 and 2000, compared to a 56% decline nationally. This was largely a "mechanical effect" of the state's high benefit levels and generous earnings disregards, which allowed working families to remain eligible for partial assistance longer than they would in low-benefit states.

Economic Drivers

The researchers estimated that the booming economy was responsible for approximately half of the total caseload decline. The remaining decline was attributed to policy changes and other external factors.

Outcomes for Welfare Leavers

Despite the slower caseload decline, the transition to work appeared successful for many. Welfare leavers saw their earnings grow by approximately 10% annually during their first three years off assistance. Furthermore, poverty rates for single-mother households in California declined sharply, mirroring national trends and suggesting that the reforms did not lead to the widespread increase in poverty that some critics had feared.

Limitations and Future Considerations

The study identifies several caveats. Data quality regarding specific work activities (such as Job Club participation) was inconsistent across counties. Additionally, a "shadow caseload" exists—roughly one-third of leavers did not appear in official employment records, suggesting they may be supported by the informal economy or other unrecorded sources. Finally, because the 60-month lifetime limit only began in 1998, its full impact could not be assessed in this early-stage analysis.

Conclusion

The CalWORKs reforms successfully shifted the focus of California's welfare system toward work. The state's policy choices reflect a deliberate balance: by providing stronger financial incentives and maintaining a more robust safety net, California achieved higher work participation rates at the cost of a larger, more expensive caseload compared to more punitive states.

Summary updated

Abstract

Examines the effects of the California Work Opportunity and Responsibility to Kids (CalWORKs) program on work activity participation rates of welfare recipients, welfare caseloads, and outcomes for welfare leavers. While the CalWORKs reforms appear to have been responsible for some of the uniform improvement in outcomes shown by the analysis, the robust economy and other policy changes were probably also important.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{klerman2003welfare,
  author = {Jacob Alex Klerman and V. Joseph Hotz and Elaine Reardon and Amy G. Cox and Donna O. Farley and Steven J. Haider and Guido W. Imbens and Robert F. Schoeni},
  title = {{Welfare Reform in California: Early Results from the Impact Analysis}},
  booktitle = {RAND},
  year = {2003},
  doi = {10.7249/mr1358},
}
Figure