Water Level Calculation and Influencing Factors of Single-Step Locks with Water-Saving Basins

Duo Xu, Zhonghua Li, Jianfeng AnLecture Notes in Civil Engineering 2024 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

During the design of ship locks with water-saving basins (WSBs), determining the optimal water levels and hydraulic heads is critical for operational efficiency. This paper establishes a mathematical framework for calculating these parameters in single-step locks, integrating factors such as total head, upstream and downstream water level variations, the number of WSB stages ($n$), and the area ratio ($k$). Through analytical modeling and a 60m high-head lock case study, the research identifies the "n over k" rule—where increasing the number of stages is more effective than increasing basin area—and defines the "sweet spot" for design to avoid diminishing returns. The study also evaluates operational strategies, concluding that water replenishment schemes are superior for locks on natural rivers with fluctuating water levels.

Introduction

High-head ship locks face significant challenges, primarily massive water consumption per cycle and extreme hydraulic pressure on valves and delivery systems. Water-saving basins (WSBs) mitigate these issues by "recycling" water—storing it during discharge and reusing it for the next filling. However, designing these systems is complex, especially for locks on natural rivers where upstream and downstream levels fluctuate significantly. This paper replaces traditional trial-and-error design with a rigorous calculation model that accounts for these real-world variables.

Mathematical Modeling of Water Levels

The proposed framework is based on a "Calculation Model of Water Level" derived from mass conservation and water balance principles. This model determines the high ($Z_{wt}$) and low ($Z_{wb}$) water levels for each basin stage, as well as the working head ($H_{c-wsb}$).

Schematic of the lock filling (A) and discharging (B) processes, illustrating the relationship between lock chamber levels and water-saving basin levels.

As shown in the figure above, the model accounts for the residual head ($\Delta H$) and the variations in upstream ($Z_{up}$) and downstream ($Z_{down}$) water levels. By establishing these relationships, engineers can calculate the precise change in water level ($H_c$) required for each stage of operation.

The Impact of Design Parameters: The "n over k" Rule

A central finding of the research is the relative impact of the number of basin stages ($n$) versus the area ratio ($k$, the ratio of basin area to lock chamber area). The authors introduced a compositive coefficient ($\delta$) to integrate these variables into a single evaluative metric.

The compositive coefficient $\delta$ as a function of the number of stages $n$. The steep initial decline illustrates the high efficiency of adding stages compared to increasing basin area.

The analysis reveals a law of diminishing returns: while increasing $n$ or $k$ reduces the working head, the marginal gains drop off significantly once a system exceeds 5 stages ($n > 5$) or an area ratio of 2.0 ($k > 2.0$). Crucially, the number of stages ($n$) is a much more powerful lever for reducing hydraulic stress than simply making the basins larger.

Operational Strategies and Case Study

The paper compares two strategies for handling water level variations: "overflow" (spilling excess water downstream) and "replenishment" (adding water from the upstream channel to the basins). In natural river environments, replenishment schemes are found to be more efficient, maintaining higher water-saving rates while reducing excavation costs.

In a case study of a 60m single-level ship lock, the model demonstrated that:

  • Increasing $k$ from 1.0 to 3.0 only reduced the maximum working head from 24.04m to 18.53m.
  • Increasing $n$ from 1 to 3 slashed the head from 39.93m to 24.04m.

Based on these results, a 3-stage WSB scheme was proposed as the most reasonable balance between water-saving efficiency and construction investment for the 60m lock. Additionally, the study noted that "integrated" (stacked) basin arrangements require a high area ratio (typically $k > 3.1$) to maintain safe vertical distances between water levels; otherwise, a decentralized arrangement is necessary.

Conclusion

This mathematical framework provides a robust tool for optimizing high-head ship lock design. By prioritizing the number of stages over basin area and accounting for river level fluctuations, engineers can significantly reduce water consumption and operational stress. Future work will focus on integrating these hydraulic formulas with 3D structural modeling and assessing the dynamic effects of valve opening speeds.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract During the water level design process of lock with water saving basins (WSBs), it's an important part that to determine the water level and head of the WSB, and there are many influencing factors in the process. This paper derives and establishes calculation formulas for evaluating the water level and the water head of the single-step lock with WSBs, which integrates the total head of ship lock, the upper and lower stream water level variation, the number of the WSB levels and area of the WSB, and the remaining head. On the basis of formulas, the influence of factors such as the upper and lower stream water level variation, the number of the WSB levels and the area of the WSB on the water level and the water head of the WSB are analyzed, and the control conditions of the integrated and decentralized arrangement of WSBs and water-saving rates of replenishment and overflow operations are calculated. The results show that when total head of the lock is constant, head of the WSB decreases with the increase of the area of the WSB and the number of the WSB levels, and the increase of the number of the WSB levels is greater than the increase of the area of the WSB; when the number of levels and area of the WSB increase to a certain level, the reduction of the water head of the WSB becomes slow; the highest and lowest water levels of the WSB are controlled by the maximum variation of the downstream and upstream water levels respectively. Finally, the water levels and the water head of difference WSB schemes are calculated and compared in a 60m single-level ship lock, and a reasonable water level scheme of WSB is proposed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2024water,
  author = {Duo Xu and Zhonghua Li and Jianfeng An},
  title = {{Water Level Calculation and Influencing Factors of Single-Step Locks with Water-Saving Basins}},
  booktitle = {Lecture Notes in Civil Engineering},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/978-981-97-9184-2\_45},
}
Figure