Values Education through Curriculum: A Bibliometric Analysis of Researches in China

Jun Sun, Minlou Liu, Hengqiang HuAdvances 2022 · DOI · OpenAlex

TL;DR

This paper provides a bibliometric roadmap of the "Values Education through Curriculum" (VEC) movement in China, tracing its evolution from a 2014 pilot program to a national research explosion. Using CiteSpace to analyze over 1,300 core academic papers, the authors identify Shanghai as the intellectual "pioneer," highlight a shift from teaching practice to core theory, and reveal how the field pivoted to address online learning during the COVID-19 pandemic.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In 2014, China introduced a comprehensive educational concept known as Values Education through Curriculum (VEC). The goal was to move beyond isolated political theory classes and integrate ideological and moral education into every professional course—from mathematics to engineering.

While the policy push was massive, the academic landscape was fragmented. The authors of this paper address the need for a "bird's-eye view" of this burgeoning field. They seek to identify who the key researchers are, which institutions lead the charge, what topics are currently "hot," and how the research focus has shifted over the last decade.

Methods

The authors conducted a bibliometric analysis, a quantitative method used to map the structure of a scientific field.

  • Tool: They employed CiteSpace (6.1.R3), a specialized visualization software designed to detect and visualize emerging trends and "bursts" in scientific literature.
  • Analysis Types: The study performed co-occurrence mapping for authors and institutions, keyword frequency analysis, and "citation burst" detection to identify sudden shifts in research interest.

Datasets

The study utilized the Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI) database, specifically filtering for:

  • Journal Quality: Only papers published in "Chinese core journals" (PKU criterion) were included to ensure a high academic standard.
  • Timeframe: 2014 to September 2022.
  • Sample Size: A final dataset of 1,366 academic papers after filtering out non-research items like conference reports and news introductions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Policy-Led Research Cycles: The research didn't grow organically; it followed government milestones. There was an "intermittent exploratory stage" (2014–2018) followed by a "concentrated emergent stage" (2019–present) triggered by the 2018 National Education Conference.
  • The "Shanghai Edge": Shanghai was the site of the original 2014 pilot program, and it remains the intellectual hub. Six of the top ten most-cited papers in the field originated from Shanghai institutions.
  • Fragmented Collaboration: Despite the high volume of papers, the research community is highly dispersed. Most authors publish independently or in very small groups; the study found only one core research team with more than three members.
  • The COVID-19 Pivot: One of the most significant "keyword bursts" occurred in 2020 for "online teaching." This indicates that the VEC community rapidly adapted to the pandemic, focusing on how to maintain values education in a digital-first environment.

Key Results

  • Exponential Growth: Annual publications skyrocketed from just 3 papers in 2015 to a peak of 480 papers in 2021.
  • Leading Institutions: Comprehensive and science/engineering universities are the primary drivers. Jilin University and Southwest University tied for the most productive institutions (19 papers each).
  • Foundational Works: Two papers by Deyi Gao and Aidong Zong (2017) are the "bibles" of the field, with 2,886 and 1,877 citations respectively—an exceptionally high count for a relatively young field.
  • Thematic Hotspots: The most frequent keywords include "foster virtue through education," "teaching reform," and "higher vocational college," showing a strong focus on practical implementation in the vocational sector.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Database Limitations: The study relies solely on the CNKI database. While CNKI is the standard for Chinese research, it does not capture international perspectives or papers published in English-language journals.
  • Incomplete 2022 Data: Because the data collection ended in September 2022, the full-year trend for 2022 could not be finalized.
  • Qualitative Gap: As a bibliometric study, the paper focuses on what is being written and by whom, but it does not evaluate the actual effectiveness of VEC programs in the classroom. The authors suggest that future research should transition from "teaching practice" to deeper "core theory" and interdisciplinary applications (e.g., in translation and interpretation majors).

Summary updated

Abstract

Values Education through Curriculum (VEC), which was first introduced in China in 2014, referred to a comprehensive educational concept in which all types of professional curriculums advance alongside ideological and political theory courses, in the form of building an all-person, all-process, and all-curriculum education pattern, to realize the fundamental task of fostering virtue through education.China had actively supported VEC construction in recent years, which had in turn generated a lot of research interest.This study employed the visualization software CiteSpace to give a bibliometric analysis of the current condition, hot spots, and trends in this academic subject based on the Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI) database.The findings revealed a significant growth tendency in the VEC-themed literature, whose authors were more distributed and there were fewer research teams.The results of core research teams and top-cited papers demonstrated Shanghai's "pioneer edge" in VEC research.Higher education journals and vocational education journals, according to CNKI journal classifications, were more likely to publish VECthemed studies.The literature mostly focused on the implementation paths, teaching method reform, and curriculum construction of VEC, while research in this field remained active.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2022values,
  author = {Jun Sun and Minlou Liu and Hengqiang Hu},
  title = {{Values Education through Curriculum: A Bibliometric Analysis of Researches in China}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.2991/978-2-494069-89-3\_347},
}

Loading related content...

Figure