Using Digital Visualization of Archival Sources to Enhance Archaeological Interpretation of the ‘Life History’ of Ships: The Case Study of HMCS/HMAS Protector

James Hunter, Emily Jateff, Anton van den HengelCoastal 2019 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

In 2013, researchers affiliated with the South Australian Maritime Museum and University of Adelaide’s Australian Centre for Visual Technologies [ACVT] conducted an archaeological and laser scanning survey of the former Australian warship HMCS/HMAS Protector. Between its launch in 1884 and service in the First World War, Protector was substantially modified. Once decommissioned, the ship again underwent drastic changes. While several archival photographs exist that depict Protector at various stages of its life, they provide only scant understanding of the transformative processes applied to Protector’s hull. Researchers at ACVT have developed methods of generating 3D models from archival photographs, and are using Protector as a case study. Models have been created that depict the vessel at three specific periods of its service life, which in turn has enabled archaeologists to identify gradual variations to Protector’s hull that, in some cases, were so subtle they could not be discerned in existing archival photographs and other historic media.

Introduction

In maritime archaeology, a ship is rarely a static object; it is a "living" entity that undergoes constant modification, repair, and repurposing over decades. While archaeologists can survey a physical wreck, these remains are often degraded, submerged, or represent only the final stage of the ship's life. Archival photographs provide snapshots of earlier iterations, but they are inherently limited: they are 2D projections that lose depth information, and they are often taken from "canonical" angles that obscure specific details.

This research addresses the challenge of "re-dimensionalizing" these flat historical records to quantitatively track how a vessel’s hull, superstructure, and armament evolved over its functional career. By turning sparse, 2D archival photographs and hand-drawn plans into accurate 3D digital models, researchers have pioneered a way to reconstruct the "life history" of historic vessels.

Methodology

The researchers employed a combination of computer vision techniques and expert archaeological interpretation to build a comprehensive digital record of the HMCS/HMAS Protector. The workflow integrated several key technologies:

  • Structure-from-Motion (SfM) and VideoTrace: Standard SfM exploits the mathematical relationship between multiple images to estimate 3D geometry. Because archival photos are often too sparse for fully automated SfM, the team used VideoTrace software. This tool allows a "human-in-the-loop" approach where an archaeologist can interactively generate polygonal meshes over a point cloud, using domain expertise to compensate for missing data.
  • The "Pseudo-Image" Breakthrough: To overcome the lack of diverse photographic angles, the team created "pseudo-images" from 2D construction plans and schematics. By manually identifying correspondences between these hand-drawn plans and real photographs, they provided the SfM algorithm with the necessary geometric constraints to build a more complete model.
Integration of 2D construction plans as 'pseudo-images' to provide geometric constraints for 3D modeling.
  • Superimposition: By creating 3D models of the ship at three distinct life stages (1884 colonial gunboat, 1911-1924 naval auxiliary, and 1924-1944 civilian lighter), they could overlay the models to highlight exactly where material was added or removed.

Key Insights and Results

The project successfully produced three composite digital models representing the ship's major configurations, revealing structural evolutions that were previously invisible to the naked eye.

Revealing the Invisible

The 3D superimposition revealed changes so subtle they were previously unnoticed, such as a slight reduction in the "rake" (angle) of the funnel and foremast when the ship transitioned to the Royal Australian Navy. The models also allowed the team to quantify the "wholesale reduction" of the hull when the ship was converted to a civilian lighter (Sidney). They determined that exactly two-thirds of the stern tubes were cut away to improve hydrodynamics—a detail nearly impossible to discern from 2D photos alone.

Superimposition of 3D models highlighting subtle structural modifications over the ship's service life, such as changes in mast rake and funnel height.

Quantitative Findings

The researchers identified a 4-meter increase in the bow's freeboard during a 1912 refit and a perceptible increase in overall hull length caused by the bow enlargement. Furthermore, while the ship’s armor (barbettes) was removed during refits, the 3D models proved that the underlying gun pedestals remained in their original locations, showing how naval architects adapted new weaponry to old structural "bones."

Conclusion and Future Work

The primary limitation of this method is the dependency on a large photographic archive, which may not exist for all historic vessels. Furthermore, the SfM method requires "common features" across images; if a ship is modified too drastically between photos, the mathematical model can become unstable.

Future work aims to expand this technique to other iconographic formats like marine paintings and sketches to model ships from the pre-photography era. Additionally, the team plans to refine neural network-based methods to generate 3D models from even fewer archival images, potentially applying this workflow to lost land-based maritime infrastructure like piers and dockyards.

Summary updated

Abstract

In 2013, researchers affiliated with the South Australian Maritime Museum and University of Adelaide’s Australian Centre for Visual Technologies [ACVT] conducted an archaeological and laser scanning survey of the former Australian warship HMCS/HMAS Protector. Between its launch in 1884 and service in the First World War, Protector was substantially modified. Once decommissioned, the ship again underwent drastic changes. While several archival photographs exist that depict Protector at various stages of its life, they provide only scant understanding of the transformative processes applied to Protector’s hull. Researchers at ACVT have developed methods of generating 3D models from archival photographs, and are using Protector as a case study. Models have been created that depict the vessel at three specific periods of its service life, which in turn has enabled archaeologists to identify gradual variations to Protector’s hull that, in some cases, were so subtle they could not be discerned in existing archival photographs and other historic media.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hunter2019using,
  author = {James Hunter and Emily Jateff and Anton van den Hengel},
  title = {{Using Digital Visualization of Archival Sources to Enhance Archaeological Interpretation of the ‘Life History’ of Ships: The Case Study of HMCS/HMAS Protector}},
  booktitle = {Coastal},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-030-03635-5\_6},
}
Figure