To: Predictive factors for high-flow nasal cannula failure in patients with acute viral bronchiolitis admitted to the pediatric intensive care unit

M Ayad, Hannah Lorking, Vishal GuptaCritical 2025 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

This article critiques a recent study by Westphal et al. (2025) regarding predictive factors for high-flow nasal cannula (HFNC) failure in infants with acute viral bronchiolitis (AVB). While the original study identifies key predictors, this analysis highlights significant confounders—including patient age, gestational maturity, comorbidities, and viral etiology—that may impact the clinical reliability of the findings. The authors argue for a more nuanced approach to predicting treatment failure to improve bedside decision-making in the pediatric intensive care unit (PICU).

Introduction

High-flow nasal cannula (HFNC) has become a staple in PICUs for treating acute viral bronchiolitis (AVB). However, identifying which patients will fail HFNC and require more invasive ventilation remains a challenge. This paper, a correspondence regarding the study by Westphal et al., points out that while the original research identified predictive factors for HFNC failure, it may have overlooked several critical confounders. Without accounting for the nuances of a child’s age, underlying health conditions, and the specific virus involved, predictive models may not be reliable enough for bedside clinical use.

Critical Appraisal Methodology

As a piece of scientific correspondence, this paper employs critical appraisal rather than introducing new experimental data. The authors systematically reviewed the data presented in the Westphal et al. study, comparing it against established pediatric clinical standards and existing literature. Key areas of critique include the stratification of data by age and gestational maturity, the verification of diagnoses (specifically regarding atypical findings like pleural effusions), and the logic of using absolute flow rates versus weight-based flow rates.

Analysis of Clinical Confounders

Comorbidities and the "Success" Paradox

The original study included a subset of 13 patients with significant neurological or cardiac comorbidities. Interestingly, 12 of these 13 patients were in the HFNC "success" group. While statistically insignificant in the original study, this suggests these patients are sufficiently different from the general population that their inclusion could mask true risk factors for otherwise healthy infants.

Age and Respiratory Reserve

Respiratory reserve—the physiological capacity a child has to combat a viral infection—changes drastically from the neonatal period through toddlerhood. The authors argue that a lack of age-specific breakdown makes the original findings less actionable for clinicians treating diverse age groups within the PICU.

Weight-Based vs. Absolute Flow Rates

In pediatric practice, weight-indexed dosing is the standard. The original study used an absolute flow rate cutoff of 12 L/min as a predictor of success. However, a 12 L/min flow represents a vastly different treatment intensity for a 3kg infant compared to a 10kg infant. The authors advocate for the use of weight-indexed metrics (L/kg/min) to provide more unmistakable evidence of treatment efficacy.

Viral Etiology

Not all viruses impact the respiratory system equally. Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RSV) often leads to more severe disease than other pathogens. The authors suggest that future predictive models must include the specific causative virus as a variable to improve accuracy.

Diagnostic Ambiguity

The presence of pleural effusions in three patients suggests the original study may have included children with conditions other than typical bronchiolitis, such as bacterial pneumonia or heart failure. Such diagnostic ambiguity can skew results regarding HFNC failure specifically related to AVB.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The authors call for future research into AVB outcomes that specifically accounts for gestational age (separating extreme preterm from term infants), pathogen-specific data, and weight-based metrics. Shifting away from absolute flow rates to weight-indexed measurements will provide more useful evidence for practitioners managing respiratory failure in the PICU.

Summary updated

Abstract

TO THE EDITOR, “Predictive factors for high-nasal cannula failure in patients with acute viral bronchiolitis admitted to the paediatric intensive care unit” published on February 2025 in Critical Care Science,() is an interesting study and with subject matter important to general paediatric practice worldwide. I believe there are numerous interesting discussion points to be addressed. […]
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ayad2025predictive,
  author = {M Ayad and Hannah Lorking and Vishal Gupta},
  title = {{To: Predictive factors for high-flow nasal cannula failure in patients with acute viral bronchiolitis admitted to the pediatric intensive care unit}},
  booktitle = {Critical},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.62675/2965-2774.20250115},
}
Figure