The “Profiles” profile: “a change in the [medical] teaching and learning paradigm” hopefully scrutinised in the future

Christof SeilerSwiss 2016 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract: The publication of the new Profiles article in the Swiss Medical Weekly marks halftime of the extensive second revision of the SCLO first published in 2000.

Introduction

Switzerland is currently undergoing a significant transformation in its medical education landscape. This transition involves moving from the long-standing "Swiss Catalogue of Learning Objectives" (SCLO), first established in 2000, to a new competency-based framework known as Profiles (Principal Relevant Objectives for Integrative Learning and Education in Switzerland). As this revision reaches its "halftime" mark, it is essential to scrutinize whether this shift represents a genuine pedagogical advancement or a rhetorical rebranding.

The Legacy of the SCLO

For over fifteen years, the SCLO served as the primary roadmap for Swiss medical students and faculties. It was characterized by an exhaustive list of approximately 1,800 clinical pictures or diagnoses. While comprehensive, this "catalogue" approach faced significant criticism. It often became a battlefield for different medical disciplines, each vying for greater representation of their specific field within the 85-page document. Furthermore, the sheer volume of information risked encouraging rote memorization rather than the development of functional clinical reasoning.

The Profiles Paradigm: From Knowledge to Competency

The new Profiles document attempts to address these issues by shifting the focus from a list of diseases toward a framework of professional activities. Key components of this shift include:

  • Situations as Starting Points: The curriculum is now anchored by 277 specific clinical situations (e.g., a patient presenting with chest pain) that a graduate must be prepared to handle from their first day of practice.
  • Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs): These define the core tasks that a supervisor can "entrust" to a trainee once they have demonstrated sufficient competence.
  • CanMEDS Roles: The framework adopts the six-role model (Scholar, Professional, Communicator, etc.) as its ideological foundation, aiming to produce a well-rounded physician.

A Critical Perspective: "Old Wine in New Bottles"?

In a recent editorial, Christian Seiler challenges the notion that this shift is a radical "paradigm shift." He argues that the new EPAs are largely derivable from the "mastering levels" (levels of competence) already present in the original 2000 SCLO. He suggests that the primary benefit of the reform might be psychological; by "inventing a new show," reformers compel faculty to rethink their teaching methods, which can have a revitalizing effect on medical education regardless of the framework's objective superiority.

Furthermore, Seiler raises concerns about the "less is more" philosophy. Clinical reasoning requires "objects of thought"—a robust foundation of medical knowledge. By reducing the explicit list of clinical pictures (specifically removing the discipline-specific Chapter 6 of the SCLO, which contained hundreds of objectives for internal medicine and surgery), there is a risk of limiting a student's ability to associate and link information, which is the cornerstone of diagnostic reasoning.

The Challenge of Evidence-Based Education

Perhaps the most significant critique is the lack of empirical evidence supporting the Profiles approach. Medical education often evolves based on tradition or consensus rather than rigorous data. Seiler proposes that the "gold standard" for evaluating such a change would be a randomized controlled trial (RCT), where students are randomly assigned to either the SCLO or Profiles curriculum.

However, he acknowledges the immense logistical difficulties of such an experiment. "Learning contents" tend to diffuse between groups, making it nearly impossible to maintain a clean control group in a small country like Switzerland. Additionally, the author laments the "hibernation of medical education research," noting that a lack of funding prevents the rigorous scrutiny these shifts deserve.

Conclusion

The transition to Profiles is a bold step toward modernizing Swiss medical education. However, as the author notes, the ideal medical graduate—mastering all CanMEDS roles—is akin to a "six-leafed clover": a rare and perhaps impossible standard for a fresh graduate. To ensure that this reform truly improves student outcomes, it must be subjected to scientific evaluation in the future. Without evidence, we cannot be certain if we are witnessing a pedagogical revolution or merely a change in terminology.

Summary updated

Abstract

The publication of the new Profiles article in the Swiss Medical Weekly marks halftime of the extensive second revision of the SCLO first published in 2000.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{seiler2016profiles,
  author = {Christof Seiler},
  title = {{The “Profiles” profile: “a change in the [medical] teaching and learning paradigm” hopefully scrutinised in the future}},
  booktitle = {Swiss},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.4414/smw.2016.14288},
}
Figure