Technological Evolution from RIS to Holographic MIMO

Jiguang He, Chongwen Huang, Li Wei, Yuan Xu, Ahmed Al Hammadi, Mérouane DebbahIntechOpen 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

TL;DR

This paper provides a comprehensive roadmap for the transition from Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RIS) to Holographic MIMO (HMIMO) as key enablers for 6G. It highlights how shifting from passive reflectors (RIS) to ultra-dense, active "metasurface" transceivers (HMIMO) can overcome the power and cost bottlenecks of traditional massive MIMO while pushing the boundaries of spectral and energy efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As we move toward 6G, wireless networks need higher data rates and better coverage, typically achieved by adding more antennas at base stations (Massive MIMO). However, traditional "fully digital" architectures are power-hungry and expensive because every antenna requires its own dedicated radio frequency (RF) chain.

The authors address the search for "greener" and more cost-effective solutions. They explore the evolution from RIS—passive surfaces that "steer" existing signals—to Holographic MIMO, which integrates the transceiver directly into a nearly continuous surface of sub-wavelength "meta-atoms." The paper tackles the specific hurdles of this evolution: hardware complexity, the difficulty of estimating channels without active processing at the surface, and the need for low-complexity beamforming in ultra-dense arrays.

Methods

The paper serves as a technical review and tutorial, synthesizing several advanced signal processing and hardware design methodologies:

  • Hardware Comparison: It contrasts the spatial feeding of RIS (external horns/arrays) with the integrated, flexible feeding of HMIMO.
  • Channel Estimation (CE): The authors review model-based (e.g., TRICE, Atomic Norm Minimization), data-driven (CNNs), and hybrid "deep unfolding" approaches to estimate the complex channels between the base station, the surface, and the user.
  • Low-Complexity Precoding: For HMIMO, where matrix inversions for hundreds of antennas are computationally prohibitive, the paper highlights the use of Neumann Series (NS) expansion to approximate Zero-Forcing (ZF) precoding.
  • Polarization Diversity: It explores the use of Tri-Polarization (TP) in HMIMO to increase the Degrees of Freedom (DoF) and system capacity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The work relies on theoretical modeling and numerical simulations based on established channel models (like mmWave/THz and radiative near-field models) rather than specific external empirical datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Holographic" Shift: Unlike RIS, which usually spaces elements at half-wavelength intervals, HMIMO uses sub-wavelength spacing. This creates a "spatially continuous aperture," allowing for super-directivity and the ability to manipulate the electromagnetic field with unprecedented precision.
  • Near-Field is the New Norm: Because HMIMO surfaces are physically large relative to the high frequencies (mmWave/THz) they use, the "far-field" boundary is pushed further away. Most users will actually be in the radiative near-field, requiring a shift from spherical wave modeling to more complex propagation physics.
  • 2-Bit Quantization is Enough: A surprising finding highlighted is that you don't need infinite precision to control these surfaces. Just 2 bits of quantization for the meta-atoms can closely approximate the performance of a theoretically perfect, continuous holographic surface.
  • Rotation as a Resource: The paper notes that simply rotating an RIS plane can provide extra Degrees of Freedom, significantly boosting ergodic capacity without needing to move the entire device.

Key Results

  • Energy Efficiency: RIS-based resource allocation can provide up to a 300% increase in energy efficiency compared to traditional multi-antenna amplify-and-forward relays.
  • Coverage Gains: Multi-hop RIS schemes can improve the coverage range of THz communications by 50% compared to systems without RIS.
  • Precoding Performance: The low-complexity Neumann Series-based ZF precoding for HMIMO (with 729 transmit antennas) was shown to nearly match the sum-rate performance of conventional ZF while drastically reducing computational overhead.
  • Estimation Accuracy: Deep unfolding-based channel estimation was shown to outperform traditional grid-based methods (like ANM), especially in scenarios with limited training overhead.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Multi-hop Complexity: While multi-hop RIS is great for coverage, estimating the "cascaded" channel (the signal's path through multiple surfaces) is extremely difficult due to error propagation and the lack of active processing at the RIS.
  • Mutual Coupling: In HMIMO, packing antennas closer than half a wavelength causes "mutual coupling," where antennas interfere with each other's radiation patterns. There is a point of diminishing returns where adding more antennas actually reduces efficiency.
  • Hardware Realization: The "contiguous" HMIMO mode remains a theoretical ideal; practical implementations must still rely on "discrete" meta-particles, and finding the optimal balance between density and power consumption is an ongoing challenge.

Summary updated

Abstract

Multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) techniques have been widely applied in current cellular networks. To meet the ever-increasing demands on spectral efficiency and network throughput, more and more antennas are equipped at the base station, forming the well-known concept of massive MIMO. However, traditional design with fully digital precoding architecture brings high power consumption and capital expenditure. Cost- and power-efficient solutions are being intensively investigated to address these issues. Among them, both reconfigurable intelligent surface (RIS) and holographic MIMO (HMIMO) stand out. In this chapter, we will focus on the ongoing paradigm shift from RIS to HMIMO, covering both topics in detail. A wide range of closely related topics, e.g., use cases, hardware architectures, channel modeling and estimation, RIS beamforming, HMIMO beamforming, performance analyses of spectral- and energy-efficiency, and challenges and outlook, will be covered to show their potential to be applied in the next-generation wireless networks as well as the rationales for the technological evolution from RIS to holographic MIMO.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2023technological,
  author = {Jiguang He and Chongwen Huang and Li Wei and Yuan Xu and Ahmed Al Hammadi and Mérouane Debbah},
  title = {{Technological Evolution from RIS to Holographic MIMO}},
  booktitle = {IntechOpen},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.5772/intechopen.112039},
}

Loading related content...

Figure