Sustainable Development of Urban Subway Tunnels Using Seismic Waves

Yao Tong, Xiao Luo, Chen YangLecture Notes in Civil Engineering 2024 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

With the proposal of low-carbon travel transportation, the subway has become the first choice for most urban residents. However, subway infrastructure is highly vulnerable to seismic activity, which can cause irreparable and significant losses. This study utilizes a three-dimensional finite element model developed in ANSYS to investigate the dynamic response of the lining of orthogonal tunnels in Chongqing's metro line 4 interval tunnel under the influence of an intensity VIII earthquake. By analyzing the deformation results at various time intervals and locations, along with actual earthquake measurements, reasonable spacing and hazard site determinations for the orthogonal tunnels are obtained.

Introduction: The Challenge of the Underground Maze

As cities push for sustainable, low-carbon transportation, subway networks are becoming increasingly dense. In mountainous regions like Chongqing, China, this density leads to a complex "underground maze" where tunnels must frequently cross over or under one another at right angles—known as orthogonal tunnels. When an earthquake hits, these intersection points become high-stress zones. If the tunnels are positioned too closely, seismic waves can cause the lining of one tunnel to interfere with the structural integrity of the other. Determining the optimal vertical space between these tunnels is a critical engineering challenge for urban resilience.

Methodology

The researchers employed a 3D Finite Element Method (FEM) using ANSYS software to simulate the real-world conditions of Chongqing’s Metro Line 4. The model consisted of a 100m³ soil block containing two horseshoe-shaped tunnels, each approximately 7.2m high and 7.4m wide.

3D finite element model (a) and orthogonal tunnel spatial layout (b)

Key technical components of the model included:

  • Viscoelastic Artificial Boundaries: Used to simulate an infinite soil domain and prevent seismic waves from reflecting off the edges of the digital model.
  • Soil Mechanics: The soil was modeled using the Mohr-Coulomb constitutive model, accounting for geological layers (Class IV and V envelopes) specific to the Chongqing project.
  • Seismic Input: An artificial synthetic wave tailored to an intensity VIII earthquake was applied, with a peak acceleration of 0.20g.
  • Variables: The team tested four different vertical spacing ratios: 0.5D, 1.0D, 1.5D, and 2.0D (where "D" is the tunnel diameter).

Key Insights and Results

To evaluate the structural response, the study monitored stress and displacement at specific points around the tunnel lining cross-section.

Monitoring points A through H on the tunnel lining cross-section

1. The 1.5D "Rational Choice"

Counter-intuitively, more space is not always better. The researchers found that while tensile stress decreased by 19% as spacing increased from 0.5D to 1.5D (dropping from 4.2 MPa to 3.40 MPa), it actually began to increase again once spacing reached 2.0D. This identifies 1.5D as the optimal "rational choice" for urban planning to minimize lining stress.

2. Upper Tunnel Vulnerability

The upper tunnel was found to be significantly more "restless" than the lower one, experiencing 2.31 times the maximum horizontal displacement. This suggests that seismic reinforcement should be prioritized for the shallower structure in an orthogonal pair.

3. The Entrance Hazard

While the intersection point is a primary concern, the data showed that peak horizontal displacement actually occurred about 20 meters from the tunnel entrance (portal). At the narrowest spacing (0.5D), cumulative horizontal displacement reached 2.6 cm, exceeding the 2.0 cm safety limit stipulated by the New Austrian Tunnelling Method.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that the dynamic response of orthogonal tunnels is highly sensitive to vertical spacing and location relative to the portal. A spacing of 1.5D provides the best balance of structural safety. Furthermore, engineers must look beyond the intersection point and provide additional reinforcement at tunnel entrances and for the upper tunnel structures. Future work should explore oblique crossing angles and different soil signatures to further refine these safety standards.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract With the proposal of the low-carbon travel transportation, the subway has become the first choice for most urban residents. If it is affected by earthquakes, it will cause irreparable and significant losses. This study utilizes a three-dimensional finite element model developed in ANSYS to investigate the dynamic response of the lining of orthogonal tunnels in Chongqing's metro line 4 interval tunnel under the influence of an intensity VIII earthquake. By analysing the deformation results at various time intervals and locations, along with actual earthquake measurements, reasonable spacing and hazard site determinations for the orthogonal tunnels are obtained.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tong2024sustainable,
  author = {Yao Tong and Xiao Luo and Chen Yang},
  title = {{Sustainable Development of Urban Subway Tunnels Using Seismic Waves}},
  booktitle = {Lecture Notes in Civil Engineering},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/978-981-97-8401-1\_67},
}
Figure