Supply Management of Rental Housing Facilities: Effect of Changes in the Quality of Housing Equipment in the Tokyo Housing Rental Market

Takeshi So, Chihiro ShimizuIntechOpen 2019 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

The Tokyo housing market is considered to be one of the fastest evolving markets in the world. In recent years, functions such as TV intercoms, bathroom dryers, system kitchens, and toilets with washlets, which are not often seen in European and US houses, have spread and become common in Japanese houses. Under such circumstances, the importance of various equipment ancillary to housing, together with the location and quality of the building, is increasingly a factor for determining the value of housing in Tokyo. This is because when a new product appears, the old product is ordered to be withdrawn from the market, or its commodity value is greatly depreciated. This study measured the economic value of improving the quality of housing with new equipment in the Tokyo rental housing market and clarified the extent of economic depreciation that is occurring due to obsolescence. According to the obtained results, new functions are being added sequentially to the Japanese rental housing according to the age of the building, and these functions are non-negligible in the determination of housing rent, even when compared with location and building structure. The effect of obsolescence due to the addition of new functions was roughly—5%.

Introduction: The Challenge of Technological Obsolescence

In many global real estate markets, property value is primarily dictated by location and square footage. However, the Tokyo rental market presents a unique case. Historically characterized by rapid economic growth and evolving earthquake safety regulations, Japanese housing has transitioned from basic shelters to high-tech living spaces.

This study addresses the phenomenon of "technological obsolescence." In a market where smart features like TV intercoms, "washlet" toilets, and system kitchens become standard rapidly, older buildings lacking these amenities face significant depreciation. The research aims to quantify the "shadow price" of these amenities and determine how much of a building's rent decline is attributable to being technologically out of date rather than just physical aging.

Methods

The researchers utilized a hedonic approach to decompose total rent into the individual values of specific attributes. Key methodological steps included:

  • Regression Analysis: Using Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) to estimate the marginal price effect of various features.
  • Era Segmentation: The housing stock was divided into three cohorts based on shifts in the Building Standards Act: Old (1968–1981), Main (1982–1999), and New (2000–2018).
  • Feature Classification: Equipment was categorized into Room Equipment (RE), Building Equipment (BE), and Contract Conditions (CC).
  • Obsolescence Modeling: By comparing poorly equipped properties across different ages against the general market, the study isolated depreciation caused specifically by a lack of modern functions.

Datasets

The study analyzed a massive dataset of 53,550 rental listings from October 2018, sourced from the LIFULL Co., Ltd. real estate portal. The data was cleaned to remove duplicates and outliers, with location value standardized by calculating travel time to Tokyo Station.

Descriptive statistics of the rental housing dataset categorized by building age (Old, Main, and New stock).

As shown in the descriptive statistics, the "New stock" commands a significant rent premium, with a mean monthly rent of 103,040 JYE compared to 84,968 JYE for "Old stock," despite having smaller average floor space (30.6 m² vs 32.5 m²).

Key Insights and Equipment Patterns

The authors identified four distinct patterns in how equipment affects rent:

  • Pattern A (The "New Normal"): Features like flooring and TV intercoms are now so common that they no longer command a premium in new buildings; instead, their absence results in a significant penalty.
  • Pattern B (Satiated Needs): Items like walk-in closets provide value that does not scale; once the basic need is met, additional capacity does not drive higher rent.
  • Pattern C (High Demand, Low Supply): Desirable but non-ubiquitous features like reheating baths (+3.45%) and underfloor heating still command high premiums.
  • Pattern D (Social Drivers): Changing social structures have increased the value of specific contract conditions, such as "guarantor unnecessary."

Key Results

  • The Obsolescence Tax: The lack of modern functions results in an approximately —5% effect on rent.
  • Depreciation Mitigation: The study found that 60 years after construction, the rent difference between a "well-equipped" and "poorly-equipped" building is about 5.5%, suggesting that hardware upgrades can effectively fight natural depreciation.
  • Premium Drivers: In the New Stock (post-2000), the highest rent drivers included high-rise status (+9.22%) and the ability to use the unit as an office (+6.11%).
  • Era Differences: New stock rents are roughly 20% higher than old stock, largely because they represent a fundamentally different technological product.

Limitations and Future Work

While the study proves that equipment upgrades raise rent, it does not provide a full cost-benefit analysis regarding the capital expenditure required for such renovations. Future research should include longitudinal studies to track depreciation curves over decades and explore how demographic shifts (age, gender, income) influence equipment preferences in the unique, fast-paced Tokyo market.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Tokyo housing market is considered to be one of the fastest evolving markets in the world. In recent years, functions such as TV intercoms, bathroom dryers, system kitchens, and toilets with washlets, which are not often seen in European and US houses, have spread and become common in Japanese houses. Under such circumstances, the importance of various equipment ancillary to housing, together with the location and quality of the building, is increasingly a factor for determining the value of housing in Tokyo. This is because when a new product appears, the old product is ordered to be withdrawn from the market, or its commodity value is greatly depreciated. This study measured the economic value of improving the quality of housing with new equipment in the Tokyo rental housing market and clarified the extent of economic depreciation that is occurring due to obsolescence. According to the obtained results, new functions are being added sequentially to the Japanese rental housing according to the age of the building, and these functions are non-negligible in the determination of housing rent, even when compared with location and building structure. The effect of obsolescence due to the addition of new functions was roughly—5%.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{so2019supply,
  author = {Takeshi So and Chihiro Shimizu},
  title = {{Supply Management of Rental Housing Facilities: Effect of Changes in the Quality of Housing Equipment in the Tokyo Housing Rental Market}},
  booktitle = {IntechOpen},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.5772/intechopen.86163},
}
Figure