STRUCTURAL DESIGN OF A PRACTICAL LARGE-SPAN CABLE-FRAME TYPE OF SUSPENDED SINGLE-LAYER RETICULATED SHELL WITH FREE SURFACE

Zhihong Zhang, Dong Shi-linOpenalex Unknown 2011 · DOI · OpenAlex

TL;DR

This paper provides a comprehensive design blueprint for a novel hybrid spatial structure: the "free surface" suspended single-layer reticulated shell. By combining a stiff upper steel shell with a flexible lower cable-bar system, the authors demonstrate how to achieve massive spans (up to 148m) with significantly reduced internal forces and enhanced stability compared to traditional designs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Large-span roofs, like those on stadiums and gymnasiums, face a constant battle between weight and structural integrity. While "suspen-domes" (hybrid structures combining shells and cables) have been used for decades, they are typically restricted to regular spherical geometries.

The challenge arises when architects demand "free surfaces"—irregular or non-algebraic shapes that don't follow a simple sphere or cylinder. Designing these is a nightmare for engineers because the geometry of the supporting cable system isn't intuitive; hoop cables aren't perfectly horizontal, and support bars aren't perfectly vertical. This paper addresses the lack of a standardized design procedure for these complex, irregular hybrid systems, using the Yueqing Olympic Center Gymnasium as a primary case study.

Methods

The authors outline a two-phase design process: Shape Determination and Load/Action Effects Analysis.

  1. Upper Structure Form-Finding: To create the "minimal surface" of the irregular upper shell, the authors used the Force Density Method. Because the resulting grid might not be practical for construction, they developed a custom Matlab program using scattered data interpolation to map a constructible grid onto the mathematically derived surface.
  2. Lower System Shape Finding: The geometry of the lower cable-bar system was determined using a combination of the Local Analysis Method and the Dynamic Relaxation Method (DRM). DRM is particularly useful here because it treats a static equilibrium problem as a pseudo-dynamic one, allowing for stable convergence even in systems with zero initial stiffness.
  3. Structural Verification: Once the shape was "found," the team used standard FEA tools (Sap2000 and Midas Gen) to perform non-linear geometrical analysis, checking for stress ratios and deflection limits under various load combinations (wind, snow, temperature, and seismic).

Datasets

As a structural engineering paper, this work does not use traditional "training" datasets. Instead, it utilizes the specific architectural and site parameters of the Yueqing Olympic Center Gymnasium in China:

  • Dimensions: An elliptical plan with a long axis of 148m and a short axis of 128m.
  • Loading Parameters: Based on Chinese national codes (e.g., dead load of 0.60kN/m², wind pressure of 0.70kN/m²).
  • Benchmarks: The paper compares the hybrid system's performance against a standalone single-layer reticulated shell.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The 1/3 Rule: The most striking insight is that the axial forces in the upper lattice members of a suspen-dome are reduced to approximately one-third of what they would be if the shell worked independently.
  • Stability Boost: The hybrid system increases the static non-linear geometrical stability by about 1.5 times compared to a single-layer shell.
  • Geometry is Emergent, Not Fixed: In free-surface designs, the "hoop" cables are not circular or horizontal. Their shape must emerge from the non-evenly distributed spatial flexibility of the upper shell.
  • Joint Innovation: The authors propose a specialized joint where diagonal cables penetrate the upper steel beams. This design is specifically engineered to be waterproof—a critical practical detail for large-span roofs that is often overlooked in purely theoretical papers.

Key Results

  • Practical Success: The design was successfully implemented for a 148m span gymnasium.
  • Deflection Control: The maximum nodal displacement occurred under the "Dead + Wind" load case, resulting in a displacement-to-span ratio of 1/406, well within safety margins.
  • Material Efficiency: Table 4 shows that most beam elements maintained a stress ratio below 0.7 (with a maximum limit of 0.9), and cable internal forces did not exceed 50% of their breaking capacity.
  • Thermal Resilience: The self-equilibrated nature of the system meant that temperature variations (+25°C to -25°C) had a negligible effect on overall stability.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their current computational sequence is somewhat linear (upper structure then lower structure). They suggest that future research should focus on a more precise simultaneous shape determination analysis that accounts for the interaction between the upper and lower systems in a single iterative loop.

Additionally, while this paper focuses on strength and deflection, the authors note that detailed discussions on modal analysis, wind-induced vibration, and the complexities of the construction sequence (the actual tensioning process) are reserved for future publications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cable-frame type of suspended single-layer reticulated shells with free surface proposed by the author of the present paper is a novel type of large-span hybrid spatial structures. The whole design procedure regarding a practical gymnasium steel roof using this structural system is presented. System constitution including form finding of the upper structure and shape determination analysis of the lower cable-bar system is given out in details and emphasized. Load/action effects are thoroughly summarized for member sections design. A special joint design when diagonal cables penetrating the corresponding upper steel beam member is also brought forward. Hopefully the present paper could benefit the further research and practical engineering on hybrid spatial structures.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2011structural,
  author = {Zhihong Zhang and Dong Shi-lin},
  title = {{STRUCTURAL DESIGN OF A PRACTICAL LARGE-SPAN CABLE-FRAME TYPE OF SUSPENDED SINGLE-LAYER RETICULATED SHELL WITH FREE SURFACE}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.18057/ijasc.2011.7.4.4},
}

Loading related content...

Figure