Seeds that give revisited: Participatory plant breeding and rural revitalization

Yiching Song, Ronnie Vernooy, Yongping Yang, S. Ceccarelli, Alessandra Galié, Stefania Grando, Eva Weltzien, Fred Rattunde, M. Sidibe, Kirsten Vom Brocke, Abdoulaye Diallo, Bettina I. G. Haussmann, Bocar Diallo, Baloua Nebié, Aboubacar Touré, Anja Christinck, Hilton Mbozi, J. N. Mushonga, Patrick Kasasa, Marvin Gómez, Juan Carlos Rosas, Sally Humphries, José Jiménez, Paola Orellana, Carlos Federico Domínguez Ávila, Mérida Barahona, Fredy Sierra, Pitambar Shrestha, Normita G. Ignacio, Norminda P. Naluz, Kaijian Huang, Milin Tian, Xin Song, Guanqi Li, Hong Liang, Yufen Chuang, Yanyan Zhang, Yunyue Wang, Lu ChunMing, Guangyu Han, Yifan Zhu, Bo Jiang, Ling Huang, Hongsong Wang, Xiang Li, Chuanhua ChenAgritrop 2023 · OpenAlex

Abstract

In 2003, the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) of Canada published “Seed that give. Participatory plant breeding,” synthesizing the achievements and lessons learned of the first 10 pioneering years of participatory plant breeding (PPB). This concept, first tabled at an international workshop in Wageningen in 1994, has since evolved into a global movement. In “Seeds that give revisited,” the original PPB champions reflect on their work over the last 20 years, joined by a new generation of professionals from China and beyond. This paper synthesizes two decades of global research to demonstrate that collaborative breeding between scientists and smallholder farmers is essential for creating resilient seed systems, prioritizing local adaptation and genetic diversity over industrial uniformity.

The Fundamental Disconnect in Global Agriculture

The book addresses a critical gap in global food security: the "formal" seed system’s failure to serve the world’s smallholder farmers. Conventional breeding prioritizes high-input environments and genetic uniformity—defined by the criteria of Distinctness, Uniformity, and Stability (DUS). However, smallholders frequently operate in marginal, rain-fed, or remote environments where these industrial varieties perform poorly.

Furthermore, industrial breeding often ignores traits critical to local livelihoods, such as cooking quality, storage longevity, and fodder value. This focus on uniformity has led to "genetic erosion"—the loss of local landraces—and increased vulnerability to climate change, as uniform crops lack the evolutionary plasticity required to handle shifting weather patterns.

The book cover of "Seeds that give revisited," highlighting the focus on participatory plant breeding and rural revitalization.

Methodological Evolution: Beyond Top-Down Research

To bridge this gap, contributors detail several evolving methodologies that move beyond traditional top-down research models:

  • Participatory Variety Selection (PVS): Farmers evaluate and rank stabilized varieties in their own fields.
  • Participatory Plant Breeding (PPB): A deeper collaboration where farmers are involved from the start—setting breeding goals, choosing parent lines, and selecting within segregating populations.
  • Evolutionary Plant Breeding (EPB): Instead of pure lines, farmers cultivate "evolutionary populations"—dynamic mixtures that cross-pollinate and evolve through natural selection in specific micro-climates.
  • Crowdsourcing (Tricot): The "Triadic Comparisons of Technologies" method uses digital tools to engage thousands of farmers, providing massive, decentralized datasets on genotype-by-environment interactions.
  • Social Scaffolding: The use of Farmer Field Schools (FFS) and Local Agricultural Research Committees (CIALs) ensures that breeding goals are gender-responsive and facilitate collective learning.

Global Impact and Evidence

Smallholder farmers act as primary custodians of genetic diversity, selecting seeds adapted to local micro-climates. Source, p. 1

Smallholder farmers act as primary custodians of genetic diversity, selecting seeds adapted to local micro-climates.

The book functions as a meta-analysis of 11 longitudinal case studies, providing robust evidence for the efficacy of participatory approaches:

  • Yield Gains in Marginal Areas: In Syria, PPB-selected barley lines showed yield advantages of 5% to 25% over local landraces in extreme low-rainfall areas (<250mm).
  • Scaling and Adoption: The "Seeds for Needs" crowdsourcing initiative in Ethiopia has scaled to involve more than 30,000 farmers. By 2007, 32 participatory varieties were adopted across five countries in the Middle East.
  • China’s Farmers’ Seed Network: This national platform has successfully linked community seed banks to official gene banks, creating a vital "backup" system for native germplasm and preserving maize and rice landraces in Guangxi and Yunnan provinces.
  • Legal Progress: Nepal has revised its registration formats to accept data collected via participatory methods, and the EU has legalized the experimental marketing of "heterogeneous" (non-uniform) populations for certain cereals.

Strategic Insights: Farmers as Expert Phenotypers

A recurring insight is that in marginal environments, farmers are often more efficient than professional breeders at identifying high-performing entries. They select for stability across seasons rather than peak yield in a single "perfect" year. Additionally, evolutionary populations act as a biological buffer; as climate change shifts local conditions, the genetic diversity within these populations allows the crop to adapt in real-time.

The research also highlights the gendered nature of seeds. Women, often the primary seed custodians, frequently have different trait priorities than men—prioritizing ease of processing and nutritional density over market price.

Limitations and the Path to Seed Sovereignty

Despite these successes, several hurdles remain. Institutional resistance persists within major international research centers (CGIAR), which often view PPB as a "social" rather than "scientific" endeavor. Furthermore, intense pressure to integrate into global trade agreements often forces developing nations to adopt strict Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) that undermine traditional farmer seed-sharing networks.

The authors conclude that the future of resilient agriculture lies in "seed sovereignty." This involves empowering farmer-led cooperatives to become self-sustaining business entities that can navigate formal certification while maintaining the local diversity essential for a changing climate.

Summary updated

Abstract

In 2003, the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) of Canada published “Seed that give. Participatory plant breeding,” synthesizing the achievements and lessons learned of the first 10 (pioneering) years of participatory plant breeding (PPB), a concept first tabled at an international workshop in Wageningen, the Netherlands, in 1994. IDRC was one of the early and most fervent supporters of PPB. See: https://publications.gc.ca/site/eng/9.648982/publication.html In “Seeds that give revisited,” the PPB champions highlighted in the 2003 book present and reflect on their work over the last 20 years, joined by a group of Chinese professionals who were inspired by the early PPB work, bringing the approach to new regions and crops. Contributors write about significant results obtained, but also about (new) challenges. The Conclusion brings the cases together.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2023seeds,
  author = {Yiching Song and Ronnie Vernooy and Yongping Yang and S. Ceccarelli and Alessandra Galié and Stefania Grando and Eva Weltzien and Fred Rattunde and M. Sidibe and Kirsten Vom Brocke and Abdoulaye Diallo and Bettina I. G. Haussmann and Bocar Diallo and Baloua Nebié and Aboubacar Touré and Anja Christinck and Hilton Mbozi and J. N. Mushonga and Patrick Kasasa and Marvin Gómez and Juan Carlos Rosas and Sally Humphries and José Jiménez and Paola Orellana and Carlos Federico Domínguez Ávila and Mérida Barahona and Fredy Sierra and Pitambar Shrestha and Normita G. Ignacio and Norminda P. Naluz and Kaijian Huang and Milin Tian and Xin Song and Guanqi Li and Hong Liang and Yufen Chuang and Yanyan Zhang and Yunyue Wang and Lu ChunMing and Guangyu Han and Yifan Zhu and Bo Jiang and Ling Huang and Hongsong Wang and Xiang Li and Chuanhua Chen},
  title = {{Seeds that give revisited: Participatory plant breeding and rural revitalization}},
  booktitle = {Agritrop},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure