Second-Harmonic Scattering as a Probe of Structural Correlations in Liquids

Gabriele Tocci, Chungwen Liang, David M. Wilkins, Sylvie Roke, Michele CeriottiThe Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 2016 · DOI · arXiv · OpenAlex

Abstract

Second-harmonic scattering experiments of water and other bulk molecular liquids have long been assumed to be insensitive to interactions between the molecules. The measured intensity is generally thought to arise from incoherent scattering due to individual molecules. We introduce a method to compute the second-harmonic scattering pattern of molecular liquids directly from atomistic computer simulations, which takes into account the coherent terms. We apply this approach to large-scale molecular dynamics simulations of liquid water, where we show that nanosecond second-harmonic scattering experiments contain a coherent contribution arising from radial and angular correlations on a length scale of ≲1 nm, much shorter than had been recently hypothesized. By combining structural correlations from simulations with experimental data, we can also extract an effective molecular hyperpolarizability in the liquid phase. This work demonstrates that second-harmonic scattering experiments and atomistic simulations can be used in synergy to investigate the structure of complex liquids, solutions, and biomembranes, including the intrinsic intermolecular correlations.

Introduction: The SHS Paradox

Second-harmonic scattering (SHS), or Hyper-Rayleigh scattering, is a non-linear optical technique traditionally used to probe molecular orientation. In bulk liquids, which are statistically centrosymmetric, it was long assumed that coherent signals from individual molecules would cancel out, leaving only a weak, incoherent background. However, recent experimental observations challenged this view, suggesting the existence of long-range coherence in bulk liquids, with some hypotheses proposing correlation lengths as large as 2,000 nm.

This paper addresses the gap between these experimental observations and atomistic behavior by developing a computational framework to simulate SHS directly from molecular dynamics (MD). This allows for a rigorous determination of the origin and length scale of molecular correlations in liquid water.

Methodology: Bridging Simulation and Experiment

The researchers combined large-scale atomistic simulations with a new mathematical framework to decompose SHS intensity. They simulated a system of approximately 260,000 water molecules (using the TIP4P/2005 model) in a 20 nm cubic box to avoid finite-size effects.

A key innovation was the reformulation of the intensity equation to separate the molecular hyperpolarizability (the individual molecular response) from the structural correlation tensor (the spatial arrangement). This allowed the team to use MD to determine the structural component and then fit the effective hyperpolarizability to match experimental benchmarks, specifically nanosecond Hyper-Rayleigh scattering data of bulk water.

The 1-nm Correlation Scale

Contrary to previous hypotheses of long-range order, the simulation results reveal that the SHS signal is primarily driven by correlations within the first and second solvation shells—a distance of approximately 1 nanometer.

Structural correlation tensors and their spatial extent, demonstrating that SHS signals arise from correlations within the first ~1 nm.

As shown in the structural correlation tensors, the correlations between molecular dipoles ($W_{zzzzzz}$) are significantly stronger than those along other axes. The Fourier transform of these tensors (inset) confirms that these interactions decay rapidly, becoming negligible beyond 1 nm. This "1-nm reality check" provides a new understanding of the local structural order that SHS actually probes.

Validating the Coherent Model

The study demonstrates that models assuming purely incoherent scattering fail to reproduce the qualitative features of experimental data, such as the specific asymmetry of light intensity at various scattering angles. By including coherent terms and fitting the effective molecular hyperpolarizability, the researchers achieved near-perfect agreement with experimental data across all scattering angles ($\theta$).

Comparison of experimental intensity ratios (crosses) with simulated models: (a) incoherent, (b) coherent with quantum chemistry values, and (c) coherent with fitted hyperpolarizability.

In Figure 1, the transition from panel (a) to (c) illustrates the necessity of the coherent framework. While the incoherent model (a) produces flat lines that miss the experimental trends, the fully fitted coherent model (c) captures the functional form of ratios like $I_{SPP}/I_{PSS}$ and $I_{PPP}/I_{PSS}$ with high precision.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This work establishes that SHS is most powerful when used in synergy with atomistic simulations. While simulations provide the structural map, experiments provide the intensity needed to extract the effective hyperpolarizability of water in its liquid phase—a value difficult to obtain through standard quantum chemistry alone.

Future work will extend this framework to ionic solutions and electrolytes to determine how dissolved salts influence the reach of molecular correlations. Additionally, the method is poised to investigate complex liquid interfaces and biological membranes, where understanding short-range order is critical for biological function.

Summary updated

Abstract

Second-harmonic scattering experiments of water and other bulk molecular liquids have long been assumed to be insensitive to interactions between the molecules. The measured intensity is generally thought to arise from incoherent scattering due to individual molecules. We introduce a method to compute the second-harmonic scattering pattern of molecular liquids directly from atomistic computer simulations, which takes into account the coherent terms. We apply this approach to large-scale molecular dynamics simulations of liquid water, where we show that nanosecond second-harmonic scattering experiments contain a coherent contribution arising from radial and angular correlations on a length scale of ≲1 nm, much shorter than had been recently hypothesized ( Shelton , D. P. J. Chem. Phys. 2014 , 141 ). By combining structural correlations from simulations with experimental data ( Shelton , D. P. J. Chem. Phys. 2014 , 141 ), we can also extract an effective molecular hyperpolarizability in the liquid phase. This work demonstrates that second-harmonic scattering experiments and atomistic simulations can be used in synergy to investigate the structure of complex liquids, solutions, and biomembranes, including the intrinsic intermolecular correlations.
BibTeX
@article{tocci2016second,
  author = {Gabriele Tocci and Chungwen Liang and David M. Wilkins and Sylvie Roke and Michele Ceriotti},
  title = {{Second-Harmonic Scattering as a Probe of Structural Correlations in Liquids}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpclett.6b01851},
}

Loading related content...

Figure