Science for Loss and Damage. Findings and Propositions

Reinhard Mechler, Elisa Calliari, Laurens M. Bouwer, Thomas Schinko, Swenja Surminski, J. Linnerooth‐Bayer, Jeroen C. J. H. Aerts, W. J. Wouter Botzen, Emily Boyd, Natalie Delia Deckard, Jan S. Fuglestvedt, Mikel González‐Eguino, Marjolijn Haasnoot, John Handmer, Masroora Haque, Alison Heslin, Stefan Hochrainer‐Stigler, Christian Huggel, Saleemul Huq, Rachel James, Richard Jones, Sirkku Juhola, Adriana Keating, Stefan Kienberger, Sönke Kreft, O.j. Kuik, Mia Landauer, Finn Laurien, Judy Lawrence, Ana Mariá López, Wei Liu, Piotr Magnuszewski, Anil Markandya, Benoît Mayer, Ian McCallum, Colin McQuistan, Lukas H. Meyer, Kian Mintz‐Woo, Arianna Montero-Colbert, Jaroslav Myšiak, Johanna Nalau, Ilan Noy, R. J. Oakes, Friederike E. L. Otto, Mousumi Pervin, Erin Roberts, Laura Schäfer, Paolo Scussolini, Olivia Serdeczny, Alex de Sherbinin, Florentina Simlinger, Asha Sitati, Saibeen Sultana, Hannah Young, Kees van der Geest, Marc van den Homberg, Ivo Wallimann-Helmer, Koko Warner, Zinta ZommersClimate 2018 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

The discourse surrounding "Loss and Damage" (L&D) has intensified as scientific evidence increasingly links anthropogenic climate change to the rising frequency and severity of extreme weather events. Despite the formal establishment of the Warsaw International Mechanism in 2013, the L&D debate remains characterized by political polarization and conceptual ambiguity. This paper synthesizes findings from a multi-disciplinary network of scientists and practitioners to propose five core scientific propositions. These propositions aim to move the L&D conversation from a "win-lose" negotiation game toward a framework of collective ambition, grounded in risk management, attribution science, and the recognition of socio-economic limits to adaptation.

Introduction: The L&D Impasse

In the context of international climate policy, "Loss and Damage" refers to the adverse effects of climate change that persist despite mitigation and adaptation efforts. While the concept has been part of United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) negotiations since the early 1990s, it has frequently been a source of friction. Vulnerable nations often view L&D through the lens of liability and compensation, while developed nations prefer a focus on future risk management and insurance. This polarization has left the field with vague concepts and contested methods.

To bridge this gap, this research provides a "science-based grounding" for L&D. By integrating perspectives from ethics, physical science, economics, and law, the authors identify a distinct policy space for L&D that moves beyond traditional adaptation. Using a "multiple lines of evidence" framework, this synthesis draws on global IPCC assessments and regional case studies from the Pacific Islands to the Arctic.

Five Propositions for Progress

The paper distills the current state of research into five key propositions designed to align stakeholder perspectives and inform actionable policy.

1. Risk Management as a Comprehensive Entry Point

Risk management can serve as an effective bridge between competing L&D narratives if it is framed comprehensively. This involves coupling technical risk assessment with climate justice considerations. By linking L&D to established disaster risk management (DRM) and adaptation practices, policymakers can find common ground. The goal is to move from a narrow focus on financial compensation to a broader strategy that includes minimizing and addressing risks through diverse interventions.

2. The Advancing Role of Attribution Science

Attribution science—the ability to identify the human "fingerprint" on specific climate events—is maturing rapidly. This science is fundamental to informing actions to minimize and address losses. However, the authors suggest a shift in how this data is used: rather than focusing solely on "blame" or legal liability, attribution should be used to quantify residual risks and inform the allocation of resources for recovery and resilience.

3. Recognizing Soft Limits to Adaptation

While "hard limits" (e.g., the physical disappearance of land due to sea-level rise) are well-understood, the research highlights the prevalence of "soft limits." These occur when adaptation is technically or physically possible but is prevented by socio-economic, political, or financial barriers. Evidence suggests these soft limits are already being breached in various geographies, from the Arctic to Small Island Developing States (SIDS), necessitating a more systematic examination of why adaptation fails even when solutions exist.

4. Solidarity in Climate Risk Insurance

Climate risk insurance is frequently proposed as a primary tool for L&D. However, the paper argues that standard commercial "mutuality" models—where premiums reflect individual risk—are insufficient for the most vulnerable. For insurance to serve the "cure" aspect of L&D, it must transition toward a "solidarity" model. This requires international accountability and external subsidies to ensure that those least responsible for climate change are not burdened with unaffordable premiums.

5. Shifting to a Narrative of Collective Ambition

The current perception of L&D as a "win-lose" negotiation hinders progress. The authors propose a more inclusive narrative centered on "collective ambition." In this view, addressing L&D is not just a moral obligation but a mutual benefit. For instance, ensuring the resilience of vulnerable regions helps maintain global supply chain stability and prevents mass displacement, creating a shared incentive for tackling climate risks.

A Taxonomy of Loss and Damage

To clarify the debate, the paper defines three categories of climate impacts:

  • Avoided: Impacts that were successfully prevented through mitigation and adaptation.
  • Unavoided: Impacts that could have been avoided but occurred due to socio-economic constraints or delayed action (breaching "soft limits").
  • Unavoidable: Impacts that are physically impossible to adapt to, such as the total loss of glaciers or permanent inundation of coastal areas.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The research frontier for L&D lies in addressing non-economic losses (NELD)—such as the loss of cultural heritage, biodiversity, or sacred sites—which are often ignored by traditional economic models. Furthermore, there is a critical need to overcome the "digital divide" in climate data; many developing nations lack the high-resolution data required for sophisticated risk management.

Ultimately, the paper calls for "transformative" measures that go beyond incremental adjustments. By grounding the L&D debate in these five scientific propositions, the international community can move toward a more effective and equitable response to the present realities of climate change.

Summary updated

Abstract

The debate on “Loss and Damage” (L&D) has gained traction over the last few years. Supported by growing scientific evidence of anthropogenic climate change amplifying frequency, intensity and duration of climate-related hazards as well as observed increases in climate-related impacts and risks in many regions, the “Warsaw International Mechanism for Loss and Damage” was established in 2013 and further supported through the Paris Agreement in 2015. Despite advances, the debate currently is broad, diffuse and somewhat confusing, while concepts, methods and tools, as well as directions for policy remain vague and often contested. This book, a joint effort of the Loss and Damage Network—a partnership effort by scientists and practitioners from around the globe—provides evidence-based insight into the L&D discourse by highlighting state-of-the-art research conducted across multiple disciplines, by showcasing applications in practice and by providing insight into policy contexts and salient policy options. This introductory chapter summarises key findings of the twenty-two book chapters in terms of five propositions. These propositions, each building on relevant findings linked to forward-looking suggestions for research, policy and practice, reflect the architecture of the book, whose sections proceed from setting the stage to critical issues, followed by a section on methods and tools, to chapters that provide geographic perspectives, and finally to a section that identifies potential policy options. The propositions comprise (1) Risk management can be an effective entry point for aligning perspectives and debates, if framed comprehensively, coupled with climate justice considerations and linked to established risk management and adaptation practice; (2) Attribution science is advancing rapidly and fundamental to informing actions to minimise, avert, and address losses and damages; (3) Climate change research, in addition to identifying physical/hard limits to adaptation, needs to more systematically examine soft limits to adaptation, for which we find some evidence across several geographies globally; (4) Climate risk insurance mechanisms can serve the prevention and cure aspects emphasised in the L&D debate but solidarity and accountability aspects need further attention, for which we find tentative indication in applications around the world; (5) Policy deliberations may need to overcome the perception that L&D constitutes a win-lose negotiation “game” by developing a more inclusive narrative that highlights collective ambition for tackling risks, mutual benefits and the role of transformation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mechler2018science,
  author = {Reinhard Mechler and Elisa Calliari and Laurens M. Bouwer and Thomas Schinko and Swenja Surminski and J. Linnerooth‐Bayer and Jeroen C. J. H. Aerts and W. J. Wouter Botzen and Emily Boyd and Natalie Delia Deckard and Jan S. Fuglestvedt and Mikel González‐Eguino and Marjolijn Haasnoot and John Handmer and Masroora Haque and Alison Heslin and Stefan Hochrainer‐Stigler and Christian Huggel and Saleemul Huq and Rachel James and Richard Jones and Sirkku Juhola and Adriana Keating and Stefan Kienberger and Sönke Kreft and O.J. Kuik and Mia Landauer and Finn Laurien and Judy Lawrence and Ana Mariá López and Wei Liu and Piotr Magnuszewski and Anil Markandya and Benoît Mayer and Ian McCallum and Colin McQuistan and Lukas H. Meyer and Kian Mintz‐Woo and Arianna Montero-Colbert and Jaroslav Myšiak and Johanna Nalau and Ilan Noy and R. J. Oakes and Friederike E. L. Otto and Mousumi Pervin and Erin Roberts and Laura Schäfer and Paolo Scussolini and Olivia Serdeczny and Alex de Sherbinin and Florentina Simlinger and Asha Sitati and Saibeen Sultana and Hannah Young and Kees van der Geest and Marc van den Homberg and Ivo Wallimann-Helmer and Koko Warner and Zinta Zommers},
  title = {{Science for Loss and Damage. Findings and Propositions}},
  booktitle = {Climate},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-319-72026-5\_1},
}
Figure