Retraction Note to: Early magnitude estimation for the MW7.9 Wenchuan earthquake using progressively expanded P-wave time window

Chaoyong Peng, Jiansi Yang, Yu Zheng, Zhiqiang Xu, Xudong JiangScientific 2015 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

Earthquake Early Warning Systems (EEWS) are critical tools for mitigating seismic risk in active regions. However, a persistent challenge in real-time seismology is parameter saturation, which often leads to the underestimation of magnitude for large earthquakes. This paper, originally published in Scientific Reports, explored a method to overcome this by using a progressively expanded P-wave time window (PTW), specifically analyzing strong-motion records from the 2008 $M_W$ 7.9 Wenchuan earthquake.

Methodology: Dynamic Windowing

Standard EEWS often rely on a fixed, short time window (e.g., 3 seconds) of the initial P-wave to estimate magnitude. For massive earthquakes, the rupture duration far exceeds this window, causing the system to miss the full energy release.

The researchers employed a technique involving a progressively expanded PTW and distance range. They measured two key early warning parameters:

  • $P_d$ (Peak Displacement): The maximum amplitude of the initial P-wave displacement.
  • $\tau_c$ (Characteristic Period): A parameter derived from the frequency content of the initial waveform.

By expanding the window as the rupture progressed, the system could provide more accurate, evolving magnitude estimates and rapid predictions of the potential damage area.

Data and Results

The study utilized strong-motion records from the Wenchuan earthquake. Unlike standard seismometers, strong-motion sensors can accurately record intense ground motion without "clipping."

Key Findings:

  1. Timing: Reliable magnitude estimates could have been available 40 seconds after the earthquake's origin time. These estimates could have been further refined in the subsequent 20 seconds as data from more distant stations arrived.
  2. Model Suitability: The results showed that existing regression relationships between early warning parameters and magnitude are suitable for $M_W \approx 8$ events, provided an appropriate PTW is used.
  3. Parameter Selection: The authors suggested prioritizing $P_d$ for magnitude estimation, as it exhibits less saturation compared to $\tau_c$ during very large events.
  4. Causes of Saturation: The study identified that magnitude underestimation is partly due to the combined effect of high-pass filtering and the frequency dependence of the radiating source during the rupture process.

Retraction Context

In 2015, this paper was formally retracted. While the scientific data and the results regarding the Wenchuan earthquake were not contested, the retraction was issued due to significant text overlap with a previously published study by Colombelli et al. (2012).

The retraction note specifies that while the data was not contested, the text was plagiarized.

This summary serves to highlight the technical contributions of the research while acknowledging the breach of academic integrity that led to its retraction.

Summary updated

Abstract

More and more earthquake early warning systems (EEWS) are developed or currently being tested in many active seismic regions of the world. A well-known problem with real-time procedures is the parameter saturation, which may lead to magnitude underestimation for large earthquakes. In this paper, the method used to the MW9.0 Tohoku-Oki earthquake is explored with strong-motion records of the MW7.9, 2008 Wenchuan earthquake. We measure two early warning parameters by progressively expanding the P-wave time window (PTW) and distance range, to provide early magnitude estimates and a rapid prediction of the potential damage area. This information would have been available 40 s after the earthquake origin time and could have been refined in the successive 20 s using data from more distant stations. We show the suitability of the existing regression relationships between early warning parameters and magnitude, provided that an appropriate PTW is used for parameter estimation. The reason for the magnitude underestimation is in part a combined effect of high-pass filtering and frequency dependence of the main radiating source during the rupture process. Finally we suggest only using Pd alone for magnitude estimation because of its slight magnitude saturation compared to the τc magnitude.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{peng2015retraction,
  author = {Chaoyong Peng and Jiansi Yang and Yu Zheng and Zhiqiang Xu and Xudong Jiang},
  title = {{Retraction Note to: Early magnitude estimation for the MW7.9 Wenchuan earthquake using progressively expanded P-wave time window}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1038/srep07602},
}

Loading related content...

Figure