Retraction Note: Sepsis-induced elevation in plasma serotonin facilitates endothelial hyperpermeability

Yicong Li, Coedy Hadden, Anthonya Cooper, Asli Ahmed, Hong Wu, Vladimir Lupashin, Philip R. Mayeux, Fusun KilicScientific 2019 · DOI · OpenAlex

The retraction was issued by Scientific Reports, a Nature Research journal.

Abstract

This article, originally published in 2016, has been formally retracted by the Editorial Office of Scientific Reports. The retraction follows an investigation into figure assembly errors and the subsequent inability of the authors to provide original raw data for several key figures. While the hypothesis regarding serotonin's role in sepsis-induced vascular leakiness remains a topic of scientific interest, the specific findings of this paper are no longer considered reliable due to these integrity concerns.

Introduction

Sepsis is a complex, life-threatening condition characterized by a dysregulated systemic inflammatory response to infection. A critical component of sepsis pathophysiology is endothelial hyperpermeability, a state where the lining of blood vessels becomes "leaky," allowing fluid and proteins to escape into the surrounding tissues. This process often leads to edema, hypotension, and multi-organ failure, which are primary drivers of mortality in septic patients.

The original research sought to identify the molecular triggers of this permeability. The authors hypothesized that elevated levels of serotonin (5-HT) in the plasma—released from platelets during the inflammatory cascade—act as a key facilitator for the breakdown of the endothelial barrier. By targeting this pathway, the study suggested potential therapeutic avenues for mitigating the severity of sepsis. However, the validity of these conclusions has been undermined by significant data discrepancies.

Analysis of the Retraction

Figure Assembly Errors

The integrity of the study was first questioned regarding the assembly of Western blot data. Western blotting is a standard laboratory technique used to quantify protein expression. In such experiments, "loading controls" (typically proteins like actin or GAPDH that are expressed at constant levels) are essential to demonstrate that any observed changes in the target protein are not due to differences in the amount of sample loaded into the gel.

The retraction note specifies that the actin control images were swapped between Figure 5B and Figure 6A. Such errors, whether clerical or systemic, undermine the internal validity of the experimental results, as the controls no longer accurately represent the specific samples they are meant to validate. This error suggests a lack of rigorous oversight during the final assembly of the manuscript.

Data Provenance and Transparency

Following the identification of these errors, the Editorial Office requested the original raw data—specifically the uncropped images of the membranes—for Figures 2, 5, and 6. The authors were unable to provide these original records.

In contemporary scientific practice, the inability to produce raw data (the "receipts" of the experiment) is a critical failure. Without these records, it is impossible for independent reviewers or the journal's editors to verify that the published figures accurately reflect the underlying experimental results. Consequently, the Editorial Office determined that the results could no longer be supported by the available evidence.

Author Responses and Dissent

The decision to retract was not unanimous among the research team. While four authors agreed to the retraction and three others could not be reached for comment, the corresponding author, Fusun Kilic, officially disagreed with the decision. This highlights the often-contentious nature of retractions when errors are identified years after the initial publication, and the authors maintain the underlying biological conclusions are still valid despite the technical errors.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The retraction of this study serves as a significant case study in research integrity. It underscores the necessity for laboratories to maintain rigorous, long-term data archiving practices to withstand editorial scrutiny. For the broader scientific community, the link between serotonin and endothelial permeability in sepsis remains an open question that requires further investigation through transparent and reproducible studies.

Researchers in vascular biology and critical care should exercise caution when citing the original 2016 findings and look toward more recent, verified literature to inform their work on sepsis-induced organ dysfunction.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article has been retracted.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2019retraction,
  author = {Yicong Li and Coedy Hadden and Anthonya Cooper and Asli Ahmed and Hong Wu and Vladimir Lupashin and Philip R. Mayeux and Fusun Kilic},
  title = {{Retraction Note: Sepsis-induced elevation in plasma serotonin facilitates endothelial hyperpermeability}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-019-50843-4},
}

Loading related content...

Figure