Retraction Note: A mechanistic model of the neural entropy increase elicited by psychedelic drugs

Rubén Herzog, Pedro A. M. Mediano, Fernando E. Rosas, Robin Carhart‐Harris, Yonatan Sanz Perl, Enzo Tagliazucchi, Rodrigo CofréScientific 2022 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

This note serves as a formal retraction of the 2020 study titled "A mechanistic model of the neural entropy increase elicited by psychedelic drugs." Following post-publication review, a critical error was identified in the computational script used to calculate differential entropy. Correction of this typo revealed that the proposed neural mass model does not produce the entropy increases previously reported, thereby invalidating the study's primary conclusions and its support for the Entropic Brain Hypothesis.

Introduction

The "Entropic Brain Hypothesis" is a cornerstone of modern psychedelic science, suggesting that the profound alterations in consciousness induced by substances like LSD or psilocybin are rooted in an increase in the "entropy" or unpredictability of brain activity. While empirical neuroimaging data consistently shows this increase in complexity, the underlying biological mechanisms—how molecular interactions at receptors translate into global changes in neural dynamics—remain a subject of intense investigation. In 2020, a study was published that aimed to bridge this gap by offering a mechanistic model of these processes.

Methodology and the Computational Error

The original research utilized a neural mass model, a mathematical framework designed to simulate the collective dynamics of large populations of neurons. By adjusting parameters within this model to simulate the presence of psychedelic compounds, the authors sought to quantify changes in the system's complexity.

The primary metric used for this quantification was differential entropy. However, it has since come to light that the script used to perform these calculations contained a significant typographical error. This error fundamentally altered the output of the entropy estimation process, leading to the false conclusion that the model successfully replicated the entropic state observed in human subjects.

Impact on Results

Upon correcting the script, the authors re-evaluated the model's performance. The results were definitive: the original neural mass model, as parameterized in the 2020 paper, fails to produce the expected increase in entropy characteristic of the psychedelic state. Consequently:

  • Invalidation of Findings: The entropy estimations reported in the original publication are mathematically incorrect and scientifically invalid.
  • Hypothesis Mismatch: The specific mechanistic model proposed does not support the Entropic Brain Hypothesis in its current form.
  • Scientific Consensus: All authors of the original study have reviewed the error and unanimously agreed to this retraction, prioritizing the integrity of the scientific record.

Discussion and Future Directions

This retraction serves as a sobering reminder of the fragility of computational modeling and the paramount importance of code integrity in neuroscience. A single typo in a calculation script can lead to "false positive" results that appear to confirm major scientific hypotheses, potentially misleading the field for years.

Despite this setback, the authors remain committed to modeling the neural effects of psychedelics. The failure of the initial model suggests that a more nuanced approach is required to capture the biological complexity of the brain's response. The authors are currently developing an expanded version of the model that incorporates:

  • Refined Receptor Modeling: Specifically focusing on the activation of the 5HT2A receptor, the primary target of classic psychedelics.
  • Dual-Pool Dynamics: Modeling the effects of these drugs on both excitatory and inhibitory neural populations simultaneously.

This revised framework aims to provide a more accurate representation of neural circuit interactions and will be subjected to rigorous testing to ensure its validity before future publication.

Summary updated

Abstract

s attention that there was a typo in the script used to calculate the differential entropy. Therefore, the reported entropy estimations are invalid and do not produce the expected increase in entropy when using
BibTeX
@inproceedings{herzog2022retraction,
  author = {Rubén Herzog and Pedro A. M. Mediano and Fernando E. Rosas and Robin Carhart‐Harris and Yonatan Sanz Perl and Enzo Tagliazucchi and Rodrigo Cofré},
  title = {{Retraction Note: A mechanistic model of the neural entropy increase elicited by psychedelic drugs}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-022-20093-y},
}
Figure