Retracted Article: A Study on the Effect of Digital Inclusive Finance on the Financial Restraint of Small and Medium-sized Enterprises

Bo HuangE3S 2021 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract: The author has expressed the wish to retract this article on the ground that he/she wants to proceed with major revision and further analysis. The Publisher approved to the retraction.

Introduction

Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are vital drivers of economic growth, yet they consistently face a "financing gap." Traditional financial institutions often perceive SMEs as high-risk due to a lack of collateral and opaque financial records. This leads to financial restraint, a condition where firms must rely heavily on internal cash flow to fund operations and growth because external capital is inaccessible or prohibitively expensive.

This study investigates whether "Digital Inclusive Finance"—the application of digital technology to financial services—can mitigate these constraints. By leveraging big data and mobile platforms, digital finance aims to lower customer acquisition costs and improve risk assessment for underserved populations.

Methodology and Data

The research employs the cash flow sensitivity of cash model to measure financial restraint. The underlying logic is that financially constrained firms will save a higher proportion of their internal cash flow to guard against future liquidity shocks. If digital finance successfully eases these constraints, the sensitivity of a firm's cash holdings to its internal cash flow should decrease.

Table of variable definitions and symbols used in the econometric model.

The study utilizes data from 2011 to 2019, combining the China Digital Inclusive Finance Development Index (from Peking University) with firm-level financial data from the CSMAR database for SMEs listed on China’s SME Board. Regional macroeconomic data from the National Bureau of Statistics is used to control for traditional financial development.

Key Insights and Empirical Results

The regression analysis focuses on the interaction between digital finance indices and firm cash flow. A negative coefficient on these interaction terms suggests that as digital finance develops, the need for firms to hoard internal cash diminishes, indicating eased financial restraint.

Regression results showing the impact of digital finance indices on cash flow sensitivity (ΔCH).

1. Breaking Information Asymmetry

Digital finance utilizes non-traditional data (e.g., transaction history from e-commerce platforms) to conduct credit evaluations. This allows lenders to assess the creditworthiness of SMEs that lack traditional credit histories, effectively reducing the information gap that typically hinders SME lending.

2. The Substitution Effect and Regional Variance

The study finds a significant "substitution effect." In regions with lower levels of traditional financial development (measured by loan-to-GDP ratios), the impact of digital finance is more pronounced. In these areas, digital tools provide a vital alternative to inefficient or scarce traditional banking services. Conversely, in highly developed financial hubs, the marginal benefit of digital finance is lower.

3. Quantitative Findings

As shown in the regression results, the interaction coefficients between the Digital Finance Index (and its sub-indices for coverage and depth) and Cash Flow are consistently negative and statistically significant (ranging from approximately -0.0005 to -0.0007). This supports the hypothesis that digital inclusive finance significantly alleviates the financial restraint of SMEs.

Conclusion and Retraction Note

While the study provides evidence that digital inclusive finance helps bridge the financing gap for SMEs, particularly in less-developed regions, it is important to note that the article was retracted by the author. The retraction was requested to allow for "major revision and further analysis," suggesting that the underlying model or data processing may undergo significant changes in future iterations.

Future research may need to address potential sample biases—as this study focused on relatively successful listed SMEs—and explore more nuanced proxies for regional financial health beyond simple loan-to-GDP ratios.

Summary updated

Abstract

The author has expressed the wish to retract this article on the ground that he/she wants to proceed with major revision and further analysis. The Publisher approved to the retraction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2021retracted,
  author = {Bo Huang},
  title = {{Retracted Article: A Study on the Effect of Digital Inclusive Finance on the Financial Restraint of Small and Medium-sized Enterprises}},
  booktitle = {E3S},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1051/e3sconf/202123503014},
}
Figure