Abstract
The post-project evaluation can promptly discover the problems in the management of the investment and construction of the distribution network project, so as to provide decision-making guidance and support for the investment and construction of the distribution network project of the local power grid enterprise. However, in actual work, many local power grid companies have not established a scientific and reasonable post-evaluation and implementation mechanism for distribution network projects due to their relatively lack of experience in organization and management. Therefore, based on the whole life cycle theory, combined with the actual construction and management of local power grid companies' distribution network projects, this article builds a reasonable post-evaluation index system and evaluation method for distribution network projects, and conducts empirical analysis with D local power grid company as an example. It is used to guide local power grid enterprises to scientifically carry out post-engineering evaluation work.
Introduction
As power distribution networks expand rapidly to meet modern energy demands, local power grid enterprises face a significant management gap: the lack of a scientific methodology to evaluate projects post-completion. Without a formal post-evaluation mechanism, identifying management failures, verifying investment benefits, and improving future construction cycles becomes a challenge. This research addresses these issues by proposing a "whole process management" approach, moving away from ad-hoc reviews toward a structured system that accounts for the complexities and subjectivities inherent in large-scale infrastructure projects.
Methodology
The proposed evaluation model integrates three core components to ensure a comprehensive and objective assessment.
Life Cycle Theory and Index System
The evaluation index system is structured around the four distinct phases of a project's life cycle: pre-decision and post-evaluation, implementation preparation, construction implementation, and production operation. This holistic view ensures that root causes of project outcomes are traced back to their origins, whether in the planning or execution stages.
Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)
To manage the varying importance of different indicators, the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is employed. AHP allows for the mathematical determination of weights based on expert input, ensuring that critical factors—such as safety and quality—are prioritized appropriately within the final score.
Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation
Infrastructure projects often involve qualitative metrics that are difficult to quantify directly. Fuzzy logic is used to handle this uncertainty by converting subjective expert scores into a "membership degree" vector. This vector is then synthesized into a final quantitative grade, providing a rigorous bridge between qualitative judgment and quantitative analysis.
Empirical Analysis: The 110kV Wangcheng Project
The model was validated through a case study of the 110kV Wangcheng project within the Langfang City Distribution Network. Ten experts were invited to evaluate the project across the established index system using a five-tier comment set.
The evaluation process yielded a final fuzzy membership vector of (0.7830, 0.1412, 0.0758, 0, 0). Since the highest membership degree (0.7830) corresponds to the "Excellent" category, the project was officially rated as Excellent. This result demonstrates the model's ability to condense complex project data and diverse expert opinions into a clear, justifiable conclusion for management.
Conclusion
This research provides local power grid enterprises with a standardized toolkit for post-project evaluation. By focusing on the whole process and utilizing fuzzy comprehensive evaluation, utilities can gain deeper insights into their investment efficiency and management performance. While the current model relies on expert judgment for weighting, future developments could focus on automating data collection through Project Management Information Systems (PMIS) to enable real-time evaluations across broader geographic regions.
Summary updated