Research on Influencing Factors of Extra-Role Information Security Policy Compliance Behaviour Based on Structural Equation Model

Cong Wang, Chongrui Liu, Jidong Yao, Longfei LiProceedings of the 2022 2nd International Conference on Education, Information Management and Service Science (EIMSS 2022) 2022 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Information security incidents are frequently driven by employee noncompliance. While organizations focus on mandatory "in-role" behaviors, this study investigates "extra-role" compliance—proactive actions that exceed policy requirements. Analyzing data from 525 Chinese civil officials using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM), the research identifies organizational climate and peer behavior as key drivers, mediated by individual intention and response efficacy.

Introduction

In the world of cybersecurity, the "human factor" is often cited as the weakest link. Technical defenses are insufficient if internal threats—whether through negligence or malice—persist as a primary cause of security incidents. Most existing research focuses on "in-role" behavior: whether employees follow explicit rules. This paper shifts the focus to extra-role information security behavior, referring to proactive actions like helping a colleague with a security issue or reporting a subtle anomaly not covered in a manual. This study aims to understand the social and psychological factors that encourage this "above and beyond" mindset, particularly within the context of Oriental organizational culture.

Methodology

The researchers employed Structural Equation Modeling (SEM), a multivariate statistical analysis technique, to analyze structural relationships between variables. The study is grounded in Social Control Theory (SCT), expanding its scope to include extra-role behaviors as dependent variables.

Structural model illustrating the relationships between organizational factors and extra-role behavior.

Data was analyzed using SmartPLS 2.0 (Partial Least Squares). Variables were measured using 5-point Likert scales adapted from established literature. The five key constructs—Information Security (IS) Climate, Peer Behaviour, ISP Compliance Intention, Response Efficacy (the belief that security actions are effective), and Extra-role Behaviour—were validated for reliability and consistency.

Mean, standard deviation, and reliability metrics (AVE, CR) for the study's constructs.

Dataset

The study utilized a primary dataset collected through an internet questionnaire, resulting in 525 valid responses from Chinese civil officials. Participants were drawn from 42 departments and councils of the central government across Beijing, Fujian, Hebei, and Shandong using a stratified sampling method. The sample was demographically balanced by gender (50.5% female) and represented a wide range of ages, education levels, and professional tenures.

Key Insights and Results

The structural model was highly effective, explaining 68.5% of the variance in employees' extra-role ISP compliance behavior. All primary hypotheses were supported with high statistical significance ($p < 0.01$ or $p < 0.05$).

  • The Power of "Climate": An organization’s "security climate"—the shared perception of how security is valued—is a stronger predictor of response efficacy than peer behavior. The path from IS Climate to Response Efficacy (0.464) was the strongest in the model, highlighting the importance of culture in building trust in security systems.
  • Peer Influence is Nuanced: While peer behavior significantly impacts compliance intention, its effect size was smaller than that of the overall organizational climate. This suggests that while "fitting in" matters, top-down cultural signals are more potent for driving proactive behavior.
  • Mediation is Key: The environment (climate and peers) does not cause extra-role behavior directly. Instead, it works by shaping two internal states: ISP Compliance Intention and Response Efficacy. If an employee does not intend to comply or does not believe the rules work, a positive climate will not result in extra-role behavior.
  • Cultural Context: The findings validate that in Oriental cultures, social bonds and organizational atmosphere are highly effective levers for managing information security, confirming that "social controls" are just as vital as formal controls like penalties.

Conclusion and Future Work

The study demonstrates that fostering a strong organizational security climate and encouraging positive peer norms are critical for driving proactive security behaviors. However, the authors acknowledge limitations, including potential self-reporting bias and the cross-sectional nature of the data. Future research should utilize longitudinal designs to better establish causality and incorporate additional variables such as self-efficacy and the perceived "cost" of compliance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Information security noncompliance behaviour of employees within an organization is one of the primary reasons for the high frequency of information security incidents.The issue of information security compliance behaviour has attracted attention and importance.The information came from a poll of 525 Chinese civil officials.This study identified variables through empirical analysis that can forecast extra-role information security policies (ISP) compliance behaviours.Structural equation model (SEM) was established and the data was analysed by SmartPLS (Partial Least Square).The findings demonstrated a substantial relationship between peers' behaviour and extra-role ISP compliance by employees and the company information security atmosphere.Additionally, it was discovered that both the relationship between peer behaviour and extra-role behaviour and the relationship between the information security climate and extrarole behaviour were being mediated by employees' ISP compliance intention and response efficacy.Practical implications are discussed in conclusion.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2022research,
  author = {Cong Wang and Chongrui Liu and Jidong Yao and Longfei Li},
  title = {{Research on Influencing Factors of Extra-Role Information Security Policy Compliance Behaviour Based on Structural Equation Model}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the 2022 2nd International Conference on Education, Information Management and Service Science (EIMSS 2022)},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.2991/978-94-6463-024-4\_57},
}
Figure