Abstract
We propose that doped Weyl semimetals with time-reversal and certain crystalline symmetries are natural candidates to realize higher-order topological superconductors (HOTSCs). These materials exhibit a fully gapped bulk while the surface hosts robust gapless chiral hinge states. In such a doped Weyl semimetal, a featureless finite-range attractive interaction favors a $p + ip$ pairing symmetry. By analyzing its topological properties, we identify such a chiral pairing state as a HOTSC, which depending on the existence of a four-fold roto-inversion symmetry $R_{4z}$, is either intrinsic or extrinsic. We achieve this understanding via various methods recently developed for higher-order topology, including Wannier representability, Wannier spectrum, and defect classification approaches.
Introduction
Topological superconductors are highly sought after because they host Majorana modes—particles that are their own antiparticles—which serve as the building blocks for fault-tolerant quantum computers. While "first-order" topological superconductors host these modes on their surfaces, Higher-Order Topological Superconductors (HOTSCs) host them in lower-dimensional regions, such as the hinges or corners of a 3D crystal.
The challenge has been finding "intrinsic" materials that naturally realize these phases without needing complex setups like proximity-coupling. This paper explores whether Weyl semimetals (WSMs)—materials where electronic bands touch at specific points in momentum space—can naturally transition into a HOTSC phase when doped and subjected to electronic interactions.
Theoretical Framework and Methods
The authors employ a multi-pronged theoretical approach to characterize the superconducting phase:
- Mean-Field Theory: Analysis of the Cooper instability in a doped WSM with time-reversal and four-fold rotoinversion ($R_{4z}$) symmetries.
- Symmetry Indicators & Wannier Obstruction: Modern topological tools are used to check if electronic states can be represented by localized "Wannier functions." An "obstruction" to this representation signals a non-trivial topological phase.
- Defect Classification: The hinges of the crystal are treated as "defects" in a higher-dimensional space, allowing for the calculation of a Second Chern Number to prove the robustness of hinge states.
Key Insights
A crucial finding is that "featureless" finite-range attractive interactions favor $p + ip$ pairing. Unlike standard $s$-wave superconductivity, this chiral pairing enables topological hinge states. The $R_{4z}$ rotoinversion symmetry (a 90-degree rotation followed by a reflection) acts as the "secret sauce," ensuring the topology is intrinsic. This means the hinge states are tied to the bulk properties and cannot be removed by simply modifying the surface.
The authors describe a "spectral flow" of Wannier centers. As one moves through the Brillouin zone in the $z$-direction, the centers of the electronic charges shift in a way that necessitates the appearance of gapless modes at the hinges.
Results and Classification
The study provides a complete $\mathbb{Z}_2$ classification for $R_{4z}$-symmetric HOTSCs, distinguishing between intrinsic phases protected by $R_{4z}$ and extrinsic phases protected by simpler symmetries like $C_{2z}$. In the latter case, hinge modes are "fragile" and can be removed by surface treatments without closing the bulk gap. Numerical results confirm the presence of four chiral Majorana modes propagating along the hinges.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
While the paper provides a theoretical blueprint, identifying specific materials remains an open task. Candidates like doped MoTe$_2$ or WTe$_2$ are potential matches for these symmetry and doping requirements. Future work will need to address the "spin-full" nature of real materials and the specific interaction ranges required to stabilize the $p+ip$ pairing over competing states.
Summary updated