Report on 2210.11448v1

Sebastian MizeraOpenalex Unknown 2023 · DOI · arXiv · OpenAlex

Abstract

Singularities, such as poles and branch points, play a crucial role in investigating the analytic properties of scattering amplitudes that inform new computational techniques. In this note, we point out that scattering amplitudes can also have another class of singularities called natural boundaries of analyticity. They create a barrier beyond which analytic continuation cannot be performed. More concretely, we use unitarity to show that 2-to-2 scattering amplitudes in theories with a mass gap can have a natural boundary on the second sheet of the lightest threshold cut. There, an infinite number of ladder-type Landau singularities densely accumulates on the real axis in the center-of-mass energy plane. We argue that natural boundaries are generic features of higher-multiplicity scattering amplitudes in gapped theories.

Introduction

In particle physics, scattering amplitudes are fundamental objects used to describe particle collisions. To facilitate efficient calculations, these amplitudes are treated as analytic functions of complex variables, such as the center-of-mass energy squared $s$. The analytic structure—specifically the location and nature of singularities like poles (representing stable particles) and branch points (representing thresholds)—provides deep insights into the underlying physics.

A central question in S-matrix theory is whether these isolated singularities are the only obstructions to analyticity. This paper addresses the existence of "natural boundaries": dense sets of singularities that form an impenetrable barrier to analytic continuation. Unlike isolated poles, these boundaries prevent the mathematical extension of the amplitude into certain regions of the complex plane, representing a fundamental limit on the analytic properties of scattering processes.

Theoretical Framework

The study utilizes a non-perturbative approach rooted in the principle of unitarity, which ensures the conservation of probability in quantum processes. The primary tool is the elastic unitarity equation, which relates the amplitude on the physical (first) sheet to its value on the unphysical (second) sheet reached by crossing the threshold branch cut.

The author demonstrates that unitarity acts as a "singularity factory." Specifically, the relation $T_1 - T_2 \propto T_1 T_2$ implies that if a singularity exists at a certain point, the consistency of the theory necessitates the appearance of further singularities. By analyzing ladder-type diagrams, the author identifies a class of Landau singularities that are generated recursively.

Ladder-type diagrams used to identify the recursive generation of Landau singularities through unitarity.

These singularities correspond to classical scattering trajectories in complexified spacetime where intermediate particles go "on-shell." The paper draws a mathematical parallel to lacunary functions, which possess "gaps" in their power series and naturally develop boundaries beyond which they cannot be defined.

Key Results and Insights

The investigation reveals that for $2 \to 2$ scattering in theories with a mass gap $m$, an infinite sequence of ladder-type singularities accumulates densely on the real axis of the second sheet. This accumulation forms a natural boundary of analyticity.

The complex s-plane illustrating the accumulation of singularities on the second sheet, forming a natural boundary that prevents further analytic continuation.

Key findings include:

  • Location of the Boundary: On the second sheet, the boundary is located on the half-line $s \le (4 - k^2)m^2$. For a theory with three-particle interactions ($k=1$), this extends to $s \le 3m^2$.
  • The Second Sheet as the Locus: While the physical sheet remains clear of such dense barriers, the second sheet—critical for understanding resonances and unstable particles—is fundamentally restricted by this boundary.
  • Genericity: The author argues that these boundaries are not artifacts of specific models but are likely generic features of any gapped theory, particularly in higher-multiplicity processes ($2 \to n$).

Discussion and Future Directions

While the existence of natural boundaries is a significant theoretical result, several questions remain:

  1. Massless Theories: The current derivation relies on the mass gap to isolate the elastic region. In theories with massless particles (e.g., photons or gluons), the sheet structure is significantly more complex, and the current logic may not directly apply.
  2. Potential Cancellations: Although theoretically possible for different particle species to have perfectly canceling singularities, this would require extreme fine-tuning and is considered unlikely in realistic physical theories.
  3. Higher Multiplicity: Extending the rigorous proof of natural boundaries to $2 \to n$ amplitudes remains an open challenge.
  4. Physical Impact: A critical next step is determining whether these boundaries have observable consequences in physical measurements or if they primarily serve as a constraint on mathematical techniques.

In conclusion, the discovery of natural boundaries suggests that the analytic landscape of scattering amplitudes is far more complex than previously assumed, presenting both a challenge and a new frontier for S-matrix theory.

Summary updated

Abstract

Singularities, such as poles and branch points, play a crucial role in investigating the analytic properties of scattering amplitudes that inform new computational techniques.In this note, we point out that scattering amplitudes can also have another class of singularities called natural boundaries of analyticity.They create a barrier beyond which analytic continuation cannot be performed.More concretely, we use unitarity to show that 2 2 scattering amplitudes in theories with a mass gap can have a natural boundary on the second sheet of the lightest threshold cut.There, an infinite number of ladder-type Landau singularities densely accumulates on the real axis in the center-of-mass energy plane.We argue that natural boundaries are generic features of higher-multiplicity scattering amplitudes in gapped theories.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mizera2023report,
  author = {Sebastian Mizera},
  title = {{Report on 2210.11448v1}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.21468/scipost.report.6424},
}

Loading related content...

Figure