Report on 2207.01479v1

Antoine Venaille, Yohei Onuki, Nicolas Perez, Armand LeclercOpenalex Unknown 2022 · DOI · arXiv · OpenAlex

Abstract

Inhomogeneous media commonly support a discrete number of wave modes that are trapped along interfaces defined by spatially varying parameters. In the case of multicomponent wave problems, those trapped modes fill a frequency gap between different wave bands. When they are robust against continuous deformations of parameters, such waves are said to be topological. It has been realized over the last decades that the existence of such topological waves can be predicted by computing a single topological invariant, the first Chern number, in a dual bulk wave problem that is much simpler to solve than the original wave equation involving spatially varying coefficients. The correspondence between the simple bulk problem and the more complicated interface problem is usually justified by invoking an abstract index theorem. Here, by applying ray tracing machinery to the paradigmatic example of equatorial shallow water waves, we propose a physical interpretation of this correspondence. We first compute ray trajectories in a phase space given by position and wavenumber of the wave packet. We then apply a quantization condition to describe the spectral properties of the original wave operator. This bridges the gap between previous work by Littlejohn and Flynn showing manifestation of Berry curvature in ray tracing equations, and more recent studies that computed the Chern number of flow models by integrating the Berry curvature over a closed surface in parameter space. We find that an integral of Berry curvature over this closed surface emerges naturally from the quantization condition, which allows us to recover the bulk-interface correspondence.

Introduction: The Robustness of Interface Waves

In physics, waves are often found "trapped" along interfaces, such as equatorial waves in the Earth's oceans or "edge states" in quantum Hall insulators. These waves exhibit remarkable robustness, persisting even when the interface is deformed. This stability is rooted in topology: the existence of these modes is predicted by a mathematical invariant known as the first Chern number.

The connection between the simple "bulk" properties of a medium and these complex "interface" modes is termed the bulk-interface correspondence. While mathematically established through abstract index theorems, it often lacks an intuitive physical picture. This paper addresses this gap by employing ray tracing—a semi-classical method common in optics—to demonstrate how topological properties manifest in the dynamic trajectories of wave packets.

Methodology: Semi-classical Analysis and Ray Tracing

The authors utilize the equatorial shallow water model as their primary theoretical framework. The approach involves several sophisticated steps:

  1. Wigner-Weyl Transform: Multicomponent wave equations (involving velocities and surface height) are converted into a scalar "symbolic" form, allowing the system to be treated like a classical Hamiltonian system.
  2. Semi-classical Expansion: A scale separation is assumed between the wave's wavelength and the spatial variations of the medium (WKB approximation).
  3. Ray Tracing Equations: Equations are derived for wave packet trajectories in phase space (position and wavenumber). A key finding is that the Berry curvature—measuring the "twist" in the wave's internal polarization—acts as a synthetic magnetic field, deviating the ray's path.
  4. Bohr-Sommerfeld Quantization: To determine discrete energy levels (eigenvalues), the authors require the phase accumulated by a wave packet along a closed phase-space orbit to be an integer multiple of $2\pi$.
Equatorial shallow water model setup on a rotating sphere.

Key Insights: Berry Curvature in Phase Space

  • Non-canonical Dynamics: Moving to gauge-independent coordinates for wave packets results in non-canonical Hamiltonian dynamics. The Berry curvature modifies the "density of states" within phase space.
  • The Berry Monopole: The topological properties of equatorial waves are generated by a "monopole" (a singularity) at the origin of the parameter space, serving as the source of Berry curvature.
  • Quantization as the Link: The Bohr-Sommerfeld quantization rule reveals that the integral of Berry curvature over a closed surface—the definition of the Chern number—emerges naturally as the term responsible for "mode imbalance."
  • Physical Interpretation of Spectral Flow: Spectral flow (the net movement of modes between frequency bands) is interpreted as the difference in the number of states hosted in phase space as a parameter, such as zonal wavenumber, varies from $-\infty$ to $+\infty$.

Results: Quantifying the Spectral Flow

The ray-tracing-plus-quantization approach successfully recovered the known spectral properties of equatorial waves, specifically the Matsuno spectrum.

Dispersion relation showing Poincaré and Rossby wave bands with spectral flow.

Key findings include:

  • Quantitative Mode Imbalance: For the positive-frequency Poincaré wave band, the mode imbalance is exactly $+2$, matching the Chern number calculated for the bulk system.
  • Modified Liouville Theorem: The authors proved that Berry curvature modifies the phase space volume element ($\delta V = (1 - \epsilon F_{yp}) dy_v dp_v$). This modification is precisely what "creates" the extra topological modes at the interface.

Discussion and Future Directions

While powerful, the current framework assumes the wave operator is Hermitian (energy-conserving). Many geophysical and astrophysical systems involve instabilities where the operator is non-Hermitian. Additionally, the bulk-boundary correspondence in continuous media is subtler than in discrete lattice systems, requiring careful definition of the "interface."

Future research directions include extending this ray-tracing approach to complex 3D geometries and non-Hermitian systems to investigate wave instabilities through a topological lens.

Summary updated

Abstract

Inhomogeneous media commonly support a discrete number of wave modes that are trapped along interfaces defined by spatially varying parameters.In the case of multicomponent wave problems, those trapped modes fill a frequency gap between different wave bands.When they are robust against continuous deformations of parameters, such waves are said to be topological.It has been realized over the last decades that the existence of such topological waves can be predicted by computing a single topological invariant, the first Chern number, in a dual bulk wave problem that is much simpler to solve than the original wave equation involving spatially varying coefficients.The correspondence between the simple bulk problem and the more complicated interface problem is usually justified by invoking an abstract index theorem.Here, by applying ray tracing machinery to the paradigmatic example of equatorial shallow water waves, we propose a physical interpretation of this correspondence.We first compute ray trajectories in a phase space given by position and wavenumber of the wave packet.We then apply a quantization condition to describe the spectral properties of the original wave operator.This bridges the gap between previous work by Littlejohn and Flynn showing manifestation of Berry curvature in ray tracing equations, and more recent studies that computed the Chern number of flow models by integrating the Berry curvature over a closed surface in parameter space.We find that an integral of Berry curvature over this closed surface emerges naturally from the quantization condition, which allows us to recover the bulkinterface correspondence.Contents I. Motivation from equatorial shallow water waves A. Wave equation and definition of the spectral flow B. The semi-classical limit for equatorial shallow water waves C. Strategy to interpret the spectral flow II.Scalar wave operator and symbols A. From multicomponent to scalar wave operator B. Expression of the scalar operator in the semi-classical limit C. Asymptotic expansion up to order one D. Application to the shallow water wave problem III.wave packet dynamics in the semi-classical regime A. Wave packet center of mass and wave packet momentum B. WKB ansatz for the scalar wavefield C. Assumption of a localized wave packet D. Ray tracing equations 1. Gauge dependent, canonical Hamiltonian form 2. Gauge independent, non-canonical Hamiltonian form 3. Application to shallow water waves IV.Topological properties of Matsuno symbol 1. Matsuno symbol and Kelvin plane waves.2. Berry curvature for eigenvectors of Matsuno symbol
BibTeX
@inproceedings{venaille2022report,
  author = {Antoine Venaille and Yohei Onuki and Nicolas Perez and Armand Leclerc},
  title = {{Report on 2207.01479v1}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.21468/scipost.report.5593},
}
Figure