Report on 2207.00854v2

Yuji Hirono, Minyoung You, Stephen Angus, Gil Young ChoOpenalex Unknown 2022 · DOI · arXiv · OpenAlex

Abstract

Fractonic phases are new phases of matter that host excitations with restricted mobility. We show that a certain class of gapless fractonic phases are realized as a result of spontaneous breaking of continuous higher-form symmetries whose conserved charges do not commute with spatial translations. We refer to such symmetries as nonuniform higher-form symmetries. These symmetries fall within the standard definition of higher-form symmetries in quantum field theory, and the corresponding symmetry generators are topological. Worldlines of particles are regarded as the charged objects of 1-form symmetries, and mobility restrictions can be implemented by introducing additional 1-form symmetries whose generators do not commute with spatial translations. These features are realized by effective field theories associated with spontaneously broken nonuniform 1-form symmetries. At low energies, the theories reduce to known higher-rank gauge theories such as scalar/vector charge gauge theories, and the gapless excitations in these theories are interpreted as Nambu-Goldstone modes for higher-form symmetries. Due to the nonuniformity of the symmetry, some of the modes acquire a gap, which is the higher-form analogue of the inverse Higgs mechanism of spacetime symmetries. The gauge theories have emergent nonuniform magnetic symmetries, and some of the magnetic monopoles become fractonic. We identify the 't Hooft anomalies of the nonuniform higher-form symmetries and the corresponding bulk symmetry-protected topological phases. By this method, the mobility restrictions are fully determined by the choice of the commutation relations of charges with translations. This approach allows us to view existing (gapless) fracton models such as the scalar/vector charge gauge theories and their variants from a unified perspective and enables us to engineer theories with desired mobility restrictions.

Introduction

Fractons represent a novel frontier in condensed matter physics, characterized by excitations with restricted mobility. Unlike standard particles that move freely through a crystal, fractons may be restricted to lines (lineons), planes (planons), or remain entirely immobile. While higher-rank gauge theories have provided a descriptive framework for these phases, the field has lacked a fundamental, unifying symmetry principle.

This paper addresses this gap by extending the paradigm of spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) to nonuniform higher-form symmetries. In this framework, the mobility of an excitation is fundamentally tied to the underlying symmetry algebra—specifically, how conserved charges commute with spatial translations. This provides a systematic method to classify and engineer fractonic gauge theories based on the underlying algebra of the system.

Theoretical Framework

The authors utilize several advanced theoretical constructs to build their unified perspective:

Nonuniform Higher-Form Symmetries

The central innovation is the definition of symmetries where the conserved charge $Q$ has a non-trivial commutation relation with the translation operator $P_i$. For instance, the relation $[iP_i, Q'] = Q$ implies that the symmetry transformation is coordinate-dependent, or "nonuniform."

Extracted figure from page 4 of Report on 2207.00854v2

Gauging and Effective Field Theory

By gauging these nonuniform symmetries, the authors construct dynamical gauge fields. Using the language of differential forms, they develop Lagrangians invariant under these coordinate-dependent transformations. This process maps the abstract symmetry algebra to concrete physical models, such as scalar and vector charge gauge theories.

Inverse Higgs Mechanism for Higher-Forms

The nonuniformity of these 1-form symmetries leads to a higher-form analogue of the "inverse Higgs mechanism." In standard spacetime symmetries, certain Nambu–Goldstone modes (like rotations) are redundant with others (like translations) and thus become gapped. Similarly, in this framework, the nonuniformity gaps out specific modes, naturally reducing the number of gapless excitations in the resulting fracton theory.

Key Insights

  • Mobility as a Symmetry Property: The mobility of a particle is entirely determined by the commutation relations of the symmetry charges with translations. To render a particle immobile in a specific direction, one introduces a symmetry whose charge does not commute with the corresponding translation operator.
  • Fractons as Nambu-Goldstone Modes: Gapless excitations in these theories are interpreted as Goldstone bosons resulting from the SSB of 1-form symmetries, placing fractons firmly within the standard framework of modern quantum field theory.
  • Magnetic Fractons: The framework extends to the magnetic sector. Emergent magnetic symmetries are also nonuniform, leading to magnetic monopoles that exhibit fractonic behavior.

Results

The application of this symmetry principle yields several significant results:

  1. Derivation of Higher-Rank Theories: The authors successfully derive "scalar charge" and "vector charge" gauge theories from first principles using nonuniform symmetry algebras.
  2. Rigorous Mode Counting: Using Young diagrams, the authors provide a method to count gapless modes, correctly accounting for the Inverse Higgs effect that removes redundant degrees of freedom.
  3. X-Cube Model Connection: By "Higgsing" the $U(1)$ theory down to $\mathbb{Z}_n$ and restricting operator geometry, the authors recover the foliated field theory of the X-cube model, a landmark example of fracton topological order.
  4. Anomaly Matching: The work identifies the 5D Symmetry-Protected Topological (SPT) action that cancels the 't Hooft anomaly of the nonuniform 1-form symmetries, providing a topological characterization for these 4D phases.

Discussion and Future Directions

While this framework provides a powerful unifying principle, several avenues for future research remain. The stability of these phases at finite temperatures is an open question, particularly given the quadratic dispersion relations ($\omega \sim k^2$) often found in these models. Additionally, the conservation laws of nonuniform magnetic symmetries suggest the possibility of developing "fracton magnetohydrodynamics" (MHD). Finally, extending these symmetries to curved manifolds is necessary to understand the gravitational properties of fractonic matter, while generalizing to 2-form symmetries could describe line-like objects with restricted mobility.

Summary updated

Abstract

Fractonic phases are new phases of matter that host excitations with restricted mobility.We show that a certain class of gapless fractonic phases are realized as a result of spontaneous breaking of continuous higher-form symmetries whose conserved charges do not commute with spatial translations.We refer to such symmetries as nonuniform higher-form symmetries.These symmetries fall within the standard definition of higher-form symmetries in quantum field theory, and the corresponding symmetry generators are topological.Worldlines of particles are regarded as the charged objects of 1-form symmetries, and mobility restrictions can be implemented by introducing additional 1-form symmetries whose generators do not commute with spatial translations.These features are realized by effective field theories associated with spontaneously broken nonuniform 1form symmetries.At low energies, the theories reduce to known higher-rank gauge theories such as scalar/vector charge gauge theories, and the gapless excitations in these theories are interpreted as Nambu-Goldstone modes for higher-form symmetries.Due to the nonuniformity of the symmetry, some of the modes acquire a gap, which is the higher-form analogue of the inverse Higgs mechanism of spacetime symmetries.The gauge theories have emergent nonuniform magnetic symmetries, and some of the magnetic monopoles become fractonic.We identify the 't Hooft anomalies of the nonuniform higher-form symmetries and the corresponding bulk symmetry-protected topological phases.By this method, the mobility restrictions are fully determined by the choice of the commutation relations of charges with translations.This approach allows us to view existing (gapless) fracton models such as the scalar/vector charge gauge theories and their variants from a unified perspective and enables us to engineer theories with desired mobility restrictions. CONTENTSI. Introduction II.Fractons from nonuniform higher-form symmetries A. Nonuniform higher-form symmetries B. Strategy to realize fractons C. Deformation of symmetry generators III.Gauge theory with U (1) and dipole symmetries A. U (1) and dipole symmetries and their gauging B. Gauge theory of U (1) charge-and dipole-gauge fields C. Low energy limit and the relation to the scalar charge gauge theory D. Number of gapless modes E. Higher-form symmetries and fractons F. Dual theory G. SSB of higher-form symmetries H. Extended operators at low energies I. Gauging of nonuniform higher-form symmetries, 't Hooft anomalies, and an SPT action J. Higgsing and fracton order K. Variants of the scalar charge gauge theory IV.Vector charge gauge theory from nonuniform symmetries
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hirono2022report,
  author = {Yuji Hirono and Minyoung You and Stephen Angus and Gil Young Cho},
  title = {{Report on 2207.00854v2}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.21468/scipost.report.5773},
}

Loading related content...

Figure