Report on 2107.09690v4

Alexey Khudorozhkov, Apoorv Tiwari, Claudio Chamon, Titus NeupertOpenalex Unknown 2022 · DOI · arXiv · OpenAlex

Abstract

We consider a 2D quantum spin model with ring-exchange interaction that has subsystem symmetries associated to conserved magnetization along rows and columns of a square lattice, which implies the conservation of the global dipole moment. The model is not integrable, but violates the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis through an extensive Hilbert space fragmentation, including an exponential number of inert subsectors with trivial dynamics, arising from kinetic constraints. While subsystem symmetries are quite restrictive for the dynamics, we show that they alone cannot account for such a number of inert states, even with infinite-range interactions. We present a procedure for constructing shielding structures that can separate and disentangle dynamically active regions from each other. Notably, subsystem symmetries allow the thickness of the shields to be dependent only on the interaction range rather than on the size of the active regions, unlike in the case of generic dipole-conserving systems.

Introduction: The Challenge of Thermalization

In classical physics, isolated systems typically reach equilibrium over time. In the quantum realm, this process is governed by the Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis (ETH), which posits that individual energy eigenstates of complex systems appear thermal to local observers. However, certain systems defy this expectation. While integrable and Many-Body Localized (MBL) systems are well-known exceptions, a new class has emerged: Hilbert space fragmentation. In these systems, the Hilbert space "shatters" into numerous disconnected fragments due to kinetic constraints rather than global symmetries.

The fragmented structure of the Hamiltonian H, showing its block-diagonal decomposition into disconnected sectors.

This paper investigates this phenomenon in a 2D setting, exploring how subsystem symmetries—where magnetization is conserved along every row and column—interact with local interactions to induce such shattering.

Methods and Model Specification

The study focuses on the spin-1/2 XY-plaquette model on a square lattice. The Hamiltonian is defined by "ring-exchange" terms that flip four spins around a plaquette, provided they are in a specific alternating configuration. To analyze the resulting fragmentation, the authors utilized:

  • Transfer Matrix Approach: For analytical counting of "inert states" (frozen configurations).
  • Exact Diagonalization (ED): To simulate small lattices (up to $6 \times 6$) and study spectral properties.
  • Gale-Ryser Algorithm: A combinatorial tool used to determine if a state with specific row/column magnetization sums even exists.
  • Level Spacing Statistics: To distinguish between integrable (Poisson) and chaotic (Wigner-Dyson) dynamics within fragments.

Key Insights: Locality and Shielding

A central finding is that subsystem symmetries alone do not guarantee exponential fragmentation. If interactions were infinite-range, the number of inert states would grow only sub-exponentially. The "shattering" is a consequence of the interplay between these symmetries and local interactions.

Furthermore, the authors introduce the concept of shielding structures—arrangements of inert spins that isolate active quantum regions. Remarkably, in this 2D model, these shields only need to be as thick as the interaction range, regardless of the size of the protected region. This allows for the coexistence of high-entanglement regions and perfectly isolated, frozen states.

Quantitative Results

The most striking result is the scaling of the fragmented space. For local interactions, the number of inert (frozen) states grows exponentially with the total number of sites ($N^2$).

Scaling of the number of states with lattice size N^2, highlighting the exponential growth of inert states following a 1.80^(N^2) law.

Numerical simulations confirm that the number of inert states follows the relation $\propto 1.80^{N^2}$. Additionally, the system exhibits "strong" ETH violation: even when a fragment is internally chaotic, it remains globally non-thermal because it is trapped within its sector. The fragmentation structure is also shown to be robust against infinitesimal random magnetic fields, indicating that the behavior is rooted in kinetic constraints rather than fine-tuned integrability.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the results are compelling, they are based on numerical data from relatively small clusters (up to $6 \times 6$) due to the exponential complexity of the Hilbert space. Future work could explore the thermodynamic limit more deeply. Additionally, while these shielding structures offer potential for protecting quantum information, practical implementation in hardware like Rydberg atoms or superconducting qubits remains an open challenge. Extending these concepts to 3D, where shields would form closed shells, represents another promising avenue for research.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider a 2D quantum spin model with ring-exchange interaction that has subsystem symmetries associated to conserved magnetization along rows and columns of a square lattice, which implies the conservation of the global dipole moment. The model is not integrable, but violates the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis through an extensive Hilbert space fragmentation, including an exponential number of inert subsectors with trivial dynamics, arising from kinetic constraints. While subsystem symmetries are quite restrictive for the dynamics, we show that they alone cannot account for such a number of inert states, even with infinite-range interactions. We present a procedure for constructing shielding structures that can separate and disentangle dynamically active regions from each other. Notably, subsystem symmetries allow the thickness of the shields to be dependent only on the interaction range rather than on the size of the active regions, unlike in the case of generic dipole-conserving systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{khudorozhkov2022report,
  author = {Alexey Khudorozhkov and Apoorv Tiwari and Claudio Chamon and Titus Neupert},
  title = {{Report on 2107.09690v4}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.21468/scipost.report.5071},
}
Figure