Reply to: Disentangling biology from mathematical necessity in twentieth-century gymnosperm resilience trends

Xiangyi Li, Shilong Piao, Kai Wang, Xuhui Wang, Tao Wang, Philippe Ciais, Anping Chen, Xu Lian, Shushi Peng, Josep PeñuelasNature Ecology & Evolution 2021 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

In a formal "Matters Arising" rebuttal published in Nature Ecology & Evolution, Xiangyi Li and colleagues defend their 2020 findings regarding the shifting drought response of gymnosperms. The debate centers on a fundamental question in ecology: how should we mathematically define "resilience"? The authors argue that their discovery—that gymnosperms are becoming more sensitive to drought but also faster at recovering—is a robust biological signal, not a mathematical artifact as suggested by critics.

The Problem of "Bouncing Back"

The original 2020 study by Li et al. identified a "temporal trade-off" in gymnosperms over the last 60 years. While these trees (conifers and their relatives) have shown decreased resistance (lower growth during drought), they have simultaneously exhibited increased resilience (faster recovery post-drought).

However, a critique by Zheng et al. challenged this conclusion. They argued that the "increased resilience" was merely a byproduct of the specific formula used by Li et al. By applying the Lloret metric—a widely used alternative—Zheng et al. found no such trend. This sparked a technical debate over which metric accurately captures the biological reality of a tree "bouncing back" from environmental stress.

Comparing Mathematical Frameworks

The disagreement hinges on two primary mathematical definitions:

  1. The Li Metric (Equation 1): This metric defines resilience as the ratio of the growth deficit during the drought to the growth recovery observed two years later. Crucially, this treats resilience as a rate of recovery relative to the specific damage sustained by the individual tree.
  2. The Lloret Metric (Equation 2): This simpler metric defines resilience as the ratio of post-drought growth to pre-drought growth.

Li et al. argue that the Lloret metric suffers from "metric blindness." By only looking at the start and end points, it ignores the severity of the initial drought impact. If a tree is hit twice as hard by a drought but eventually returns to its pre-drought growth level, the Lloret metric would assign it the same resilience score as a tree that was barely affected.

Conceptual Proof: The "Depth of the Pit"

To demonstrate the flaw in the critics' approach, the authors utilized conceptual modeling to show how different drought severities affect resilience calculations.

Conceptual comparison of growth recovery metrics, illustrating how ignoring the initial growth reduction leads to biased resilience estimates.

As shown in the figure above, the "depth of the pit"—the growth reduction period—is essential for understanding the recovery process. If you ignore how deep that pit was, you cannot accurately measure the effort or the biological rate of the climb back out. The authors demonstrate that the Lloret metric is mathematically biased toward showing a positive relationship between resistance and resilience, which can obscure real signals of plant adaptation to increasing drought severity.

Biological Decoupling and the Role of CO2

Li et al. emphasize that their findings are rooted in distinct biological mechanisms rather than just mathematical formulas. Their research indicates that resistance is primarily driven by hydraulic traits—how trees manage water transport under stress. In contrast, resilience is driven by foliar economic traits—how trees maximize photosynthesis and carbon gain once water becomes available again.

Because different sets of traits control these two phases, it is biologically plausible for them to trend in opposite directions. The authors suggest that rising atmospheric $CO_2$ levels may be the "hidden hand" behind this trend. Increased $CO_2$ can act as a fertilizer, allowing trees to recover faster and achieve higher resilience, even as a warming climate makes them more vulnerable to the initial shock of drought events.

Conclusion

The authors conclude that the trend of increased resilience in gymnosperms is a valid adaptive response to a drying climate. While the ecology community continues to grapple with standardized metrics, Li et al. reaffirm that any meaningful measure of resilience must account for the magnitude of the initial disturbance. Simple ratio-based metrics like the Lloret metric risk losing the signal of how forests are actually responding to the escalating stresses of the Anthropocene.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2021reply,
  author = {Xiangyi Li and Shilong Piao and Kai Wang and Xuhui Wang and Tao Wang and Philippe Ciais and Anping Chen and Xu Lian and Shushi Peng and Josep Peñuelas},
  title = {{Reply to: Disentangling biology from mathematical necessity in twentieth-century gymnosperm resilience trends}},
  booktitle = {Nature Ecology \& Evolution},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41559-021-01412-4},
}

Loading related content...

Figure