Reply on RC1

Hongliang Zhang, Xiaodong Xie, Jianlin Hu, Momei Qin, Song Guo, Min Hu, Dongsheng Ji, Hongli Wang, Shengrong Lou, Cheng Huang, Chun‐Feng Liu, Ying Qi, Hong Liao, Yuanhang ZhangOpenalex Unknown 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract Traditional bottom-up emission inventories often overlook the significant impact of real-time traffic congestion on urban air quality. This study introduces a novel temporal-allocation approach that integrates TomTom congestion data with the Multi-resolution Emission Inventory for China (MEIC). By accounting for the "congestion penalty"—the substantial increase in pollutant emissions during stop-and-go traffic—the research quantifies the resulting surge in fine particulate matter ($PM_{2.5}$) and ozone ($O_3$) concentrations. Findings indicate that traffic congestion contributes to approximately 25,000 premature deaths annually in China, with some cities experiencing mortality rate increases as high as 17.5%. These results highlight the urgent need for urban planning strategies that prioritize traffic flow as a critical public health intervention.

Addressing the "Congestion Penalty" in Emission Modeling

While the link between vehicular traffic and air pollution is well-established, traditional "bottom-up" emission inventories frequently rely on monthly or annual averages. This approach masks the dynamic reality of urban life, where traffic is characterized by sharp diurnal peaks rather than a steady stream.

This study addresses two primary gaps in current modeling:

  1. Diurnal Variation: Most inventories fail to accurately capture hour-by-hour changes in traffic volume.
  2. The Congestion Penalty: Vehicles stuck in gridlock emit significantly more pollutants per kilometer than those moving at steady speeds due to frequent idling and acceleration.

By failing to account for these real-time fluctuations and speed-dependent emission rates, previous models likely underestimated the true impact of urban transportation on air quality and public health.

Methodology: A Temporal-Allocation Approach

To bridge this gap, researchers developed a new temporal-allocation approach to refine transportation emission data for the year 2020. The framework integrates high-resolution traffic data with chemical transport modeling to provide a more granular view of urban pollution.

Methodological framework for integrating traffic congestion data into emission inventories and assessing health impacts.

The process involves several key steps:

  • Traffic Flow Modeling: A sigmoid function was employed to convert "Congestion Level" (defined as extra travel time) from TomTom data into actual traffic flow.
  • Emission Correction Factors (ECF): Rather than assuming static emission rates, the team applied ECFs based on national technical guidelines. This allowed for adjustments based on actual driving speeds; for instance, emissions spike dramatically when average speeds drop below 20 km/h.
  • Chemical Transport Modeling: These refined emissions were processed through the CMAQ (Community Multiscale Air Quality) model to simulate ground-level concentrations of $PM_{2.5}$ and $O_3$.
  • Health Impact Assessment: Finally, China-specific concentration-response functions were used to estimate premature mortality from diseases such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and ischaemic heart disease (IHD).

Key Insights: Regional Hotspots and the "Weekend Effect"

The study revealed that the impact of congestion is far from uniform across China. The North China Plain (NCP) and the Sichuan Basin (SCB) emerged as the most affected regions, driven by a combination of high vehicle density and geographical features that trap pollutants.

One of the most striking findings was the "Weekend Effect." Congestion levels on workdays were found to be roughly 1.4 times higher than on weekends. While concentrations of $PM_{2.5}$ and $NO_2$ typically drop on weekends, $O_3$ levels often rise in "VOC-limited" urban regimes. This occurs because there is less $NO_x$ available to "titrate" or neutralize the ozone, leading to counterintuitive spikes in $O_3$ during periods of lower traffic.

Quantifying the Health Burden

The refined modeling shows that congestion is a primary driver of urban health risks. In major urban clusters, congestion alone can raise annual average $PM_{2.5}$ by up to 3.5 $\mu g/m^3$. While this increment may seem small, it represents a significant additional burden on top of existing baseline pollution.

The human cost is substantial:

  • Mortality: Traffic congestion is linked to approximately 20,000 excess deaths related to $PM_{2.5}$ and 5,000 deaths related to $O_3$ annually in China.
  • City-Specific Impacts: While major cities like Beijing see high absolute numbers (roughly 120 deaths per year), the relative increase is most pronounced in smaller, high-density tourist hubs. In Sanya, for example, the congestion-related mortality increase reached a staggering 17.5%.
  • Disease Burden: Cerebrovascular disease (CEVD) and Ischaemic heart disease (IHD) accounted for 81% of the total premature deaths attributed to congestion-related $PM_{2.5}$.

Limitations and Future Directions

The authors acknowledge several limitations, including the use of a sigmoid function derived from Parisian traffic data as a proxy for Chinese driving behavior. Additionally, while speed is a major factor, other variables like ambient temperature, fuel quality, and vehicle age also influence emission rates.

Future research should focus on incorporating more localized "big data" to further refine emission correction factors. Ultimately, the study emphasizes that urban planning and traffic management are not just matters of convenience—they are essential components of public health policy.

Summary updated

Abstract

<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> The greening impacts on China from 2000 to 2017 led to an increase in vegetated areas and thus enhanced biogenic volatile organic compound (BVOC) emissions. BVOCs are regarded as important precursors for ozone (O<span class="inline-formula"><sub>3</sub></span>) and secondary organic aerosol (SOA). As a result, accurate estimation of BVOC emissions is critical to understand their impacts on air quality. In this study, the Model of Emissions of Gases and Aerosols from Nature (MEGAN) v2.1 was used to investigate the impact of different leaf area index (LAI) and land cover (LC) datasets on BVOC emissions in China in 2016, and the effects on O<span class="inline-formula"><sub>3</sub></span> and SOA were evaluated based on the Community Multiscale Air Quality (CMAQ) modeling system. Three LAI satellite datasets of the Global LAnd Surface Satellite (GLASS), the Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) MOD15A2H version 6 (MOD15), and the Copernicus Global Land Service (CGLS), as well as three LC satellite datasets of the MODIS MCD12Q1 LC products, the Copernicus Climate Change Service (C3S) LC products, and the CGLS LC products, were used in five parallel experiments (cases: C1–C5). Results show that changing LAI and LC datasets of the model input has an impact on BVOC estimations. BVOC emissions in China ranged from 25.42 to 37.39 Tg in 2016 and were mainly concentrated in central and southeastern China. Changing the LC inputs for the MEGAN model has a more significant difference in BVOC estimates than using different LAI datasets. The combination of C3S LC and GLASS LAI performs better in the CMAQ model, indicating that it is the better choice for BVOC estimations in China. The highest contribution of BVOCs to O<span class="inline-formula"><sub>3</sub></span> and SOA can reach 12 ppb and 9.8 <span class="inline-formula">µ</span>g m<span class="inline-formula"><sup>−3</sup></span>, respectively. Changing the MEGAN inputs further impacts the concentrations of O<span class="inline-formula"><sub>3</sub></span> and SOA, especially changing LC datasets. The relative difference between MCD12Q1 LC and C3S LC is over 52 % and 140 % in O<span class="inline-formula"><sub>3</sub></span> and biogenic SOA (BSOA) in central and eastern China. The BSOA difference is mainly attributed to the isoprene SOA (ISOA), a major contributor to BSOA. The relative differences in ISOA between different cases are up to 160 % in eastern China. Therefore, our results suggest that the uncertainties in MEGAN inputs should be fully considered in future O<span class="inline-formula"><sub>3</sub></span> and SOA simulations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023reply,
  author = {Hongliang Zhang and Xiaodong Xie and Jianlin Hu and Momei Qin and Song Guo and Min Hu and Dongsheng Ji and Hongli Wang and Shengrong Lou and Cheng Huang and Chun‐Feng Liu and Ying Qi and Hong Liao and Yuanhang Zhang},
  title = {{Reply on RC1}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-2022-739-ac1},
}
Figure