Abstract Atmospheric aerosols can exert an influence on meteorology and air quality through aerosol–radiation interaction (ARI) and aerosol–cloud interaction (ACI), and this two-way feedback has been studied by applying two-way coupled meteorology and air quality models. As one of the regions with the highest aerosol loading in the world, Asia has attracted many researchers to investigate the aerosol effects with several two-way coupled models (WRF-Chem, WRF-CMAQ, GRAPES-CUACE, WRF-NAQPMS, and GATOR-GCMOM) over the last decade. This paper attempts to offer a bibliographic analysis regarding the current status of applications of two-way coupled models in Asia, related research focuses, model performances, and the effects of ARI and/or ACI on meteorology and air quality. There were a total of 160 peer-reviewed articles published between 2010 and 2019 in Asia meeting the inclusion criteria, with more than 79% of papers involving the WRF-Chem model. The number of relevant publications has an upward trend annually, and East Asia, India, and China, as well as the North China Plain are the most studied areas. The effects of ARI and both ARI and ACI induced by natural aerosols (particularly mineral dust) and anthropogenic aerosols (bulk aerosols, different chemical compositions, and aerosols from different sources) are widely investigated in Asia. Through the meta-analysis of surface meteorological and air quality variables simulated by two-way coupled models, the model performance affected by aerosol feedbacks depends on different variables, simulation time lengths, selection of two-way coupled models, and study areas. Future research perspectives with respect to the development, improvement, application, and evaluation of two-way coupled meteorology and air quality models are proposed.
Introduction
In traditional atmospheric modeling, "offline" systems have long been the standard: a meteorological model (such as WRF) generates weather data, which is then used by a chemistry model (such as CMAQ) to predict air quality. However, this one-way communication ignores the reality that pollutants like smoke and dust interact with sunlight and clouds, which in turn alters the weather. In regions with extreme pollution like East Asia and India, these feedbacks are too significant to be overlooked. The "online" or "two-way coupled" approach allows chemistry and physics to interact dynamically. This paper addresses the need for a unified understanding of how these models perform in Asia, synthesizing a decade of research to quantify aerosol impacts and identify knowledge gaps.
Methodology and Data Synthesis
The authors conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of 160 peer-reviewed articles published between 2010 and 2019. The bibliographic analysis identified WRF-Chem as the dominant model, utilized in 79% of the studies. To evaluate model performance, the researchers extracted Statistical Indices (SIs)—including Correlation Coefficients ($R$), Mean Bias (MB), and Root Mean Square Error (RMSE)—across various variables such as temperature, wind speed, and PM2.5 concentrations.
The primary dataset for this review consists of the 160 selected studies, from which a comprehensive meta-dataset was compiled. This dataset includes model configurations, study regions (e.g., North China Plain, Indo-Gangetic Plain), and statistical performance metrics.
Key Insights: The "Dome Effect" and ARI vs. ACI
A central finding of the synthesis is the reinforcement of the "dome effect." Light-absorbing aerosols, such as black carbon, warm the upper atmosphere while shading and cooling the surface. This process stabilizes the air and reduces the planetary boundary layer height (PBLH), trapping pollutants near the ground in a self-reinforcing cycle.
The review also highlights a disparity in research focus: 82% of the studies concentrate on Aerosol–Radiation Interactions (ARI), which involve the scattering and absorption of light. In contrast, Aerosol–Cloud Interactions (ACI)—how aerosols alter cloud brightness and lifetime—remain a frontier in the field, characterized by higher uncertainty and fewer dedicated studies. Furthermore, a sharp increase in publications after 2013 correlates with China’s "Action Plan on Prevention and Control of Atmospheric Pollution," demonstrating how policy priorities drive scientific advancement.
Quantitative Results
The meta-analysis provides concrete figures for the impact of aerosols in Asia:
- Radiative Impact: Aerosols lead to a median reduction of -15.92 W/m² in shortwave radiation reaching the surface, a value notably higher than those reported for North America or Europe.
- Meteorological Changes: On average, aerosol feedbacks resulted in a surface temperature decrease of -0.65 °C and a reduction in PBLH of -60.7 meters.
- Air Quality Impact: Feedbacks generally exacerbate air quality issues. During heavy haze episodes, two-way coupling increased simulated PM2.5 concentrations by an average of 19.32 µg/m³ at the hourly scale.
- Model Performance: The analysis revealed consistent systematic biases. Models generally underestimate surface temperature (T2) and overestimate wind speed (WS10). While turning on aerosol feedbacks often worsened the cold bias for temperature, it slightly improved wind speed predictions.
Limitations and Future Directions
The review identifies several critical areas for future research:
- Computational Efficiency: Two-way coupling is resource-intensive. Advancements in GPU computing and cloud clusters are necessary for these models to become standard in real-time forecasting.
- Reducing ACI Uncertainty: The representation of aerosols as ice nuclei (IN) or cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) remains inconsistent across models, leading to varied results for precipitation.
- Vertical Resolution: Most studies focus on surface variables. There is a significant need for more data and modeling on the vertical distribution of aerosols to better understand atmospheric stability.
- Long-term Analysis: Most existing research focuses on short-term pollution episodes. Future work must examine multi-year trends to understand climate-scale impacts.
Summary updated