Renewables need a grand-challenge strategy

Alan Bernstein, Edward H. Sargent, Alán Aspuru‐Guzik, Richard J. Cogdell, Graham R. Fleming, Rienk van Grondelle, Mario MolinaNature 2016 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Despite the ambitious targets set by the Paris Agreement, global public investment in renewable energy research and development (R&D) remains insufficient. Currently, less than 2% of total public research budgets are dedicated to renewables, totaling approximately US$6.5 billion annually. This paper argues that increasing funding alone is inadequate; a coordinated "grand challenges" strategy is required to focus international efforts on high-risk, high-reward innovations. Drawing on successful models from global health, we propose a framework for international collaboration to accelerate the transition to a decarbonized global economy.

Introduction

The transition to a low-carbon economy is one of the most significant hurdles of the 21st century. While political commitments to the Paris Agreement suggest a global consensus on the need for change, the financial and strategic reality of energy research tells a different story. Public spending on renewable energy R&D has remained stagnant, failing to keep pace with the scale of the climate crisis. To bridge this gap, a team of international experts proposes a fundamental shift in how we approach energy innovation: the adoption of a "grand challenges" strategy.

The Strategic Deficit in Energy R&D

The primary obstacle to rapid decarbonization is not merely a lack of capital, but a lack of coordination. While initiatives like "Mission Innovation" and the "Breakthrough Energy Coalition" have successfully increased the profile of energy funding, the field remains fragmented. Without a unified, global roadmap, research efforts are often siloed within national borders or specific disciplines. This fragmentation slows the development of disruptive innovations—the kind of "leapfrog" technologies necessary to displace entrenched fossil fuel infrastructures.

Current investment data from the International Energy Agency (IEA) underscores this stagnation. With only US$6.5 billion invested annually in public renewable R&D, the sector lacks the concentrated focus required to solve complex technical hurdles.

The Grand Challenges Framework

The authors advocate for a model inspired by the 2005 Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation initiative for global health. That initiative successfully galvanized the scientific community by setting specific, scientifically risky targets for neglected diseases and pathogens. A similar approach for renewables would involve a three-step implementation plan:

  1. Consortium Formation: Establishing a coalition of major funding partners, including governments from Mission Innovation, private investors from the Breakthrough Energy Coalition, and philanthropic organizations.
  2. International Science Board: Appointing a diverse, multidisciplinary board of researchers, policymakers, and industry leaders from both developed and developing nations to oversee the strategy.
  3. Priority Distillation: Tasking the board with defining a specific set of "grand challenges" to focus global research on high-impact areas.

Technical Priorities and Multidisciplinary Integration

A grand-challenge strategy would move beyond vague goals like "improving efficiency" toward granular technical targets. For example, in the realm of energy storage, the focus should shift toward large- and small-scale systems that are safe, inexpensive, and utilize Earth-abundant materials. This includes exploring "flow" systems and methods for storing energy as liquid fuels.

Furthermore, the strategy recognizes that energy systems do not exist in isolation. Renewable energy is tightly coupled with food security, water security, and poverty alleviation. Solutions must be multidisciplinary and adaptable to the local needs of the developing world, ensuring that the transition to clean energy supports broader sustainable development goals.

Bridging the Science-Policy Gap

Technical breakthroughs are necessary but insufficient on their own. The proposed framework emphasizes the need for stronger links between scientific innovation and policy implementation. Disruptive technologies often face market barriers; therefore, the grand challenges must also address economic and policy modeling. Policy levers, such as feed-in tariffs and carbon pricing, must be integrated into the R&D roadmap to create the market conditions necessary for new technologies to survive and scale.

Conclusion

The success of a grand-challenge strategy for renewables ultimately depends on political will and international cooperation. The difficulty of coordinating diverse national interests and private-sector motivations cannot be understated. However, the anniversary of the Paris Agreement provides a critical window of opportunity. By forming an International Science Board and defining a clear strategic roadmap now, the global community can turn current momentum into a structured, long-term initiative capable of meeting the climate challenge.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{bernstein2016renewables,
  author = {Alan Bernstein and Edward H. Sargent and Alán Aspuru‐Guzik and Richard J. Cogdell and Graham R. Fleming and Rienk van Grondelle and Mario Molina},
  title = {{Renewables need a grand-challenge strategy}},
  booktitle = {Nature},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1038/538030a},
}
Figure