Removal of Expression of Concern: Sodium butyrate ameliorated diabetic nephropathy-associated tubulointerstitial inflammation by modulating tight junction of renal tubular epithelial cells

Tingting Yang, L Lia, Heng Cai, Pian Sha, Yiying Wang, Jiaming Shen, Zhenzhou Jiang, Sitong Qian, Chujing Wei, Hao Yang, Xia Zhu, Tao Wang, Mengying Wu, Jianyun Wang, Qian Lü, Xiaoxing YinFood 2024 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

This mini-paper details the resolution of an Expression of Concern regarding a 2022 study published in Food & Function. Following a rigorous audit of new experimental data and full Western blot images, the Royal Society of Chemistry has confirmed the validity of the original findings: sodium butyrate mitigates kidney inflammation by modulating tight junctions in renal tubular epithelial cells.

Introduction: Restoring Scientific Trust

Diabetic nephropathy (DN) is a severe complication of diabetes characterized by chronic kidney damage and tubulointerstitial inflammation. A 2022 study by Yang et al. proposed that sodium butyrate, a gut-derived short-chain fatty acid, could offer therapeutic benefits by protecting the integrity of renal cells.

However, the paper was recently subject to an "Expression of Concern" (EoC). In academic publishing, an EoC is a formal notice issued when there are doubts about the integrity or reliability of a paper’s data. In this case, the reliability of the Western blot data—a technique used to detect specific proteins—had been questioned. This notice serves to inform the scientific community that those concerns have been resolved through rigorous re-verification.

Verification Methodology

The resolution of this concern involved a multi-step verification process mandated by the journal Food & Function:

  1. Request for Raw Data: The authors provided higher-quality images than those appearing in the original manuscript.
  2. Experimental Replication: The authors repeated the experiments to generate entirely new Western blot data, ensuring the findings were reproducible.
  3. Full Blot Submission: In line with modern standards for transparency, the authors provided "full blots" (showing the entire membrane rather than just cropped bands), which helps rule out image manipulation.
  4. Expert Audit: The new data and full blots were assessed by an independent expert to determine if the findings were consistent with the original claims.

Key Scientific Insights

The core scientific takeaway remains intact: sodium butyrate appears to be a viable therapeutic candidate for protecting kidney function in diabetic models. It works by "fixing" the tight junctions of renal tubular epithelial cells, which prevents the inflammatory leaks associated with diabetic kidney damage.

This case highlights a growing trend in biological sciences where journals are increasingly vigilant about Western blot integrity. Because these images can be subject to manipulation, providing full, uncropped membranes is becoming the gold standard for proof. It is relatively rare for an Expression of Concern to be removed in favor of the authors; this notice demonstrates that through transparency and a willingness to repeat labor-intensive experiments, researchers can successfully defend the validity of their work.

Limitations and Future Work

While the data's reliability has been confirmed, it is important to note that this notice addresses the integrity of the research rather than its clinical efficacy in humans. The original study was performed in laboratory models (in vitro or animal). Future research can now proceed to explore the specific signaling pathways sodium butyrate utilizes to modulate tight junctions. Additionally, this case serves as a reminder for researchers to maintain high-resolution, uncropped raw data from the outset of their experiments to avoid similar administrative hurdles.

Conclusion

The Royal Society of Chemistry has officially superseded the Expression of Concern. The expert review concluded that the outcomes and conclusions of the original study are unchanged despite the initial data quality issues. This ensures that future researchers citing the 2022 study can do so with confidence in the underlying protein expression data.

Summary updated

Abstract

Removal of Expression of Concern for 'Sodium butyrate ameliorated diabetic nephropathy-associated tubulointerstitial inflammation by modulating tight junction of renal tubular epithelial cells' by Tingting Yang <i>et al.</i>, <i>Food Funct.</i>, 2022, Accepted Manuscript, https://doi.org/10.1039/D2FO00940D.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2024removal,
  author = {Tingting Yang and L Lia and Heng Cai and Pian Sha and Yiying Wang and Jiaming Shen and Zhenzhou Jiang and Sitong Qian and Chujing Wei and Hao Yang and Xia Zhu and Tao Wang and Mengying Wu and Jianyun Wang and Qian Lü and Xiaoxing Yin},
  title = {{Removal of Expression of Concern: Sodium butyrate ameliorated diabetic nephropathy-associated tubulointerstitial inflammation by modulating tight junction of renal tubular epithelial cells}},
  booktitle = {Food},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1039/d4fo90012j},
}
Figure