Reduction of Serotonergic Gene Expression in the Midbrain Raphe Nuclei under Positive Fighting Experience

Dmitry A. Smagin, U. A. Boyarskikh, Natalia P. Bondar, М. Л. Филипенко, N. N. KudryavtsevaVide 2019 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

The concept of a major inhibitory role of serotonin in aggressive behavior is widely accepted by investigators. There was ample evidence that a pharmacologically-induced increase in the serotonin activity attenuates agonistic behavior in animals and that the manipulations inhibiting the brain serotonergic system can elicit aggressiveness in male mice and rats. Repeated experience of aggression in daily agonistic interactions has been shown to reduce serotonin activity in brain of victorious male mice. The study aimed to analyze expression of the serotonergic genes -Tph2, Sert, Maoa and 5ht1a, as well as Bdnf and Creb genes in the midbrain raphe nuclei of male mice with positive fighting experience in daily encounters and male mice with the same track record of aggression followed by two-week no-fight period. It has been shown that mRNA levels of the serotonergic and Creb genes are reduced in the winners in comparison with male mice without consecutive positive fighting experience of aggression. After the fighting deprivation the Tph2, Sert, Bdnf and Creb genes recover their expression while mRNA levels of Maoa and 5ht1a gene proceed at a significantly higher level as compared with the respective controls. Downregulation of serotonergic genes is indicative of the inhibition of serotonergic activity under repeated experience of aggression. Nevertheless, recovering of Tph2 and Sert gene expression and overexpression of Maoa and 5ht1a genes after no-fight period suggest that changes in brain serotonergic activity are not main cause of the behavioral pathology developing in male mice in this experimental context.

Introduction

The "serotonin deficiency hypothesis" is a cornerstone of neuropsychology, positing that low levels of serotonin (5-HT) correlate with increased aggression and impulsivity. While much research focuses on the effects of social defeat and stress, this study investigates the neurobiology of the "winner." Specifically, the research analyzes how a long-term "winning streak" (21 days of social victory) affects the genetic expression of the serotonergic system in the midbrain raphe nuclei—the brain's primary serotonin factory.

Methods

The researchers utilized the Sensory Contact Model, a behavioral paradigm where pairs of weight-matched male mice are housed in a cage divided by a perforated partition. This allows sensory contact without physical interaction, creating constant social tension. Once a day, the partition is removed for 10 minutes for agonistic interactions. Over 21 days, "winners" and "losers" are established.

The study compared three groups: 21-day winners, 21-day winners followed by a 14-day "no-fight" period (deprived winners), and a control group. Molecular analysis was performed using qRT-PCR to measure mRNA levels of key genes involved in serotonin synthesis, transport, and reception, as well as neuroplasticity markers.

Table 1: Genes, primer sequences, and their biological functions analyzed in the study.

Notably, the authors found that standard "housekeeping genes" (Gapdh, Hprt) were themselves altered by the experimental conditions, necessitating a relative percentage-based statistical approach rather than standard normalization.

Results

System-Wide Suppression in Winners

Chronic winning was found to downregulate the entire genetic pipeline of the serotonergic system. Immediate winners (after 21 days of victory) showed a significant decrease in mRNA levels for Tph2 (synthesis), Sert (transport), Maoa (catabolism), and 5ht1a (receptors), as well as Bdnf and Creb, compared to controls.

The Rebound Effect

After a 14-day "no-fight" break, the brain's genetic expression did not simply return to baseline:

  • Recovery: Tph2, Sert, Bdnf, and Creb returned to control levels.
  • Overshoot: Maoa and 5ht1a expression proceeded at a significantly higher level than in the control group. This suggests a compensatory feedback mechanism attempting to "re-brake" the aggressive system.

Discussion

The persistence of aggressive behavior after the no-fight period (the "deprivation effect"), despite the recovery or overexpression of serotonergic genes, suggests that serotonin inhibition is a consequence of chronic conflict rather than the sole driver of long-term behavioral pathology. The profound alteration of even "housekeeping" genes like Gapdh serves as a cautionary note for researchers in behavioral transcriptomics, highlighting how deeply social stress can rewire cellular function.

Because aggression remains high while the serotonergic system recovers, the authors conclude that other systems—potentially the dopaminergic or opioidergic pathways—may be responsible for the more permanent behavioral changes observed in chronic winners. Future research should focus on the interplay between these systems during the deprivation period to better understand the roots of persistent aggression.

Summary updated

Abstract

The concept of a major inhibitory role of serotonin in aggressive behavior is widely accepted by investigators. There was ample evidence that a pharmacologically-induced increase in the serotonin activity attenuates agonistic behavior in animals and that the manipulations inhibiting the brain serotonergic system can elicit aggressiveness in male mice and rats. Repeated experience of aggression in daily agonistic interactions has been shown to reduce serotonin activity in brain of victorious male mice. The study aimed to analyze expression of the serotonergic genes -Tph2, Sert, Maoa and 5ht1a, as well as Bdnf and Creb genes in the midbrain raphe nuclei of male mice with positive fighting experience in daily encounters and male mice with the same track record of aggression followed by two-week no-fight period. It has been shown that mRNA levels of the serotonergic and Creb genes are reduced in the winners in comparison with male mice without consecutive positive fighting experience of aggression. After the fighting deprivation the Tph2, Sert, Bdnf and Creb genes recover their expression while mRNA levels of Maoa and 5ht1a gene proceed at a significantly higher level as compared with the respective controls. Downregulation of serotonergic genes is indicative of the inhibition of serotonergic activity under repeated experience of aggression. Nevertheless, recovering of Tph2 and Sert gene expression and overexpression of Maoa and 5ht1a genes after no-fight period suggest that changes in brain serotonergic activity are not main cause of the behavioral pathology developing in male mice in this experimental context.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{smagin2019reduction,
  author = {Dmitry A. Smagin and U. A. Boyarskikh and Natalia P. Bondar and М. Л. Филипенко and N. N. Kudryavtseva and Dmitry Smagin and Natalia Kudryavtseva},
  title = {{Reduction of Serotonergic Gene Expression in the Midbrain Raphe Nuclei under Positive Fighting Experience}},
  booktitle = {Vide},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.37247/pabsc.1.2019.1},
}
Figure